Global menu

Our global pages

Close

Senior Costs Judge was wrong to hold that the new test of proportionality applies to still recoverable additional liabilities

  • United Kingdom
  • Costs Unit

07-11-2017

The anticipated judgment in the appeal of BNM v MGN has been handed down today. The Court of Appeal unanimously found in the claimant’s favour, confirming that the Senior Costs Judge had erred in his ruling that the new test of proportionality applied to Pre-April 2013 additional liabilities.

Whilst there are now fewer cases remaining involving Pre-April 2013 additional liabilities. For those remaining this decision is paramount to the recovery of additional liabilities.

The Court of Appeal has confirmed in this judgment that cases which involve Pre-April 2013 additional liabilities require the application two proportionality tests. Costs incurred Pre-April 2013 will be assessed under ‘old’ proportionality test, this will include the assessment of the additional liabilities. Costs incurred post-April 2013, will be assessed under the ‘new’ proportionality test.

Unfortunately, the Court of Appeal did not provide the expected guidance as to how the new test of proportionality should be applied in future matters. The Senior Costs Judge is to reconsider the issue of proportionality and issuing proceedings without any warning to the Defendant.

James Barrett, Legal Project Manager

< Go back

Print Friendly and PDF

© Eversheds Sutherland 2020. All rights reserved. Eversheds Sutherland is a global provider of legal and other services operating through various separate and distinct legal entities.

Eversheds Sutherland is the name and brand under which the members of Eversheds Sutherland Limited (Eversheds Sutherland (International) LLP and Eversheds Sutherland (US) LLP) and their respective controlled, managed and affiliated firms and the members of Eversheds Sutherland (Europe) Limited (each an "Eversheds Sutherland Entity" and together the "Eversheds Sutherland Entities") provide legal or other services to clients around the world. Eversheds Sutherland Entities are constituted and regulated in accordance with relevant local regulatory and legal requirements and operate in accordance with their locally registered names. The use of the name Eversheds Sutherland, is for description purposes only and does not imply that the Eversheds Sutherland Entities are in a partnership or are part of a global LLP. The responsibility for the provision of services to the client is defined in the terms of engagement between the instructed firm and the client.