Our global pages
Close- Global home
- About us
- Global services/practices
- Industries/sectors
- Our people
- Events/webinars
- News and articles
- Eversheds Sutherland (International) Press Hub
- Eversheds Sutherland (US) Press Hub
- News and articles: choose a location
- Careers
- Careers with Eversheds Sutherland
- Careers: choose a location
Lawbite: Jumping through all the sub-letting hoops
- United Kingdom
- Litigation and dispute management
- Real estate dispute resolution
22-03-2018
Warborough Investments Limited v Lunar Office SARL [2018] EWCA Civ 427 The Court of Appeal has held that, contrary to the decision at first instance, the sub-clauses of a lease setting out the terms for permitting underletting should be read cumulatively rather than as separate individual covenants. One sub-clause prohibited underlettings of part other than complete floors or shop units for terms over ten years. Another sub-clause prohibited underlettings at less than the best rent obtainable. The tenant’s predecessor had granted a sublease of less than a whole floor and for less than ten years and the tenant argued – and at first instance won – that the two sub-clauses were individual covenants and that the sublease was permissible as it satisfied the restriction in the second sub-clause and was for the best rent obtainable. Unsurprisingly the Court of Appeal held differently saying that there was a danger in approaching the construction of the document with preconceived ideas about what the parties, acting commercially, were likely to have intended and to allow those ideas to subvert the clear language of the document. The proper approach was to recognise that the sub-clauses were a series of negative covenants by the tenant which required to be complied with according to their terms. Key points
This information is for guidance purposes only and should not be regarded as a substitute for taking legal advice. Please refer to the full terms and conditions on our website.
- The Tax Talk: Discussing tax trends and topics from around the globe
- What's next for hybrid working
- High Court grants restraining order over NFTs confirming them to be “property” under English law
- Proposed changes to the Employment Services Act are on the horizon, it may be time to revisit the view
- Competition in the world of golf - the PGA Tour and LIV Golf