Corporate disputes – 2024 in review
Part 1 – Post M&A claims under a Share Purchase Agreement
December 09, 2024
Corporate disputes – 2024 in reviewPart 1 – Post M&A claims under a Share Purchase AgreementDecember 09, 2024 This is the first part of our 2024 review of various aspects of corporate disputes in reported England & Wales court decisions over the past year. In this briefing we consider the key updates in 2024 on post-M&A claims under a Share Purchase Agreement (SPA). Summary
Contractual Limitations - NotificationParties to an SPA usually include a contractual limitation period on non-tax warranty and indemnity claims which (absent fraud) require the buyer to give the seller notice of a claim within a defined period following completion (often 18 months or two years). The purpose of the limitation is to allow the seller to move on from most liabilities in the transaction sooner than the statutory limitation period. The draconian consequences for the buyer of getting a notice wrong has meant that these clauses have for many years given rise to significant ‘all or nothing’ disputes, with the content, timing and delivery of notices coming under sharp focus. In welcome news for buyers, the Court of Appeal held in Drax Smart Generation Holdco Ltd v Scottish Power Retail Holdings Ltd [2024] EWCA Civ 477 that the High Court erred in finding that the buyer’s notice for a breach of warranty claim was not compliant with the SPA. The consequence of the first instance decision was that the buyer’s warranty claim was time barred. The contractual limitation in question required the buyer to notify the seller of the claim “stating in reasonable detail the nature of the claim and the amount claimed (detailing the Buyer’s calculation of the Loss thereby alleged to have been suffered).” The buyer’s breach of warranty claim concerned an option agreement which had not been validly assigned. In its notification, the buyer calculated its damages based on future losses which would be suffered by the target. It is well established that the loss to a buyer of a breach of warranty in a post-M&A scenario is usually the difference in the value of the shares acquired by the buyer when comparing the ‘warranty false’ scenario with the ‘warranty true’ scenario. On these principles, the buyer’s notification of a claim for losses suffered by the target was not a proper basis to calculate the buyer’s loss. The buyer subsequently amended its Particulars of Claim so that its losses were calculated as a diminution in value of the shares of the target. At first instance, the court considered that the fact the buyer’s warranty claim was based on the difference in the value of the acquired shares was part of both the “nature of the claim” and essential to provide the necessary “reasonable detail” to satisfy the notification obligation. Having failed to comply with the notification obligation, the buyer was time barred from pursuing the claim. The Court of Appeal disagreed. The Court of Appeal’s view was that the nature of the claim was simple – under the terms of the SPA the target should have had the benefit of the option agreement, but did not, and a simple statement to that effect would satisfy the requirement of “reasonable detail” as to the “nature of the claim” in the notice clause. The court did not consider the language of the notification obligation meant that the buyer needed to specify that the damages claimed would be based on the diminution of value. Furthermore, the Court of Appeal held that while the buyer had subsequently changed the basis on which its loss was calculated, the loss calculation in the claim notice was a genuine estimate of loss, calculated in good faith. There was nothing in the notice clause and “no good reason” that the buyer should be held to the way in which the calculation was formulated in its notice of claim. As such, the buyer’s notice of claim met the requirements of the notice clause, and the claim was not time barred. This decision highlights the importance of complying with the requirements of a notification clause, but is a welcome confirmation that the courts are not looking for “traps to defeat what may be a valid claim” but will instead abide by the language and commercial purpose of such clauses. Material Adverse EffectWhere there is a gap between signing of the SPA and completion, it is common for parties to agree to certain contractual consequences if there should be a “Material Adverse Event” or an event that has a “Material Adverse Effect” or “Material Adverse Change” for the target. In order to exercise a MAE/MAC clause to terminate an SPA, there must be an event/effect/change which of itself has a material and adverse impact on the business of the target. An event/effect/change may reveal other issues with the target (which may be material and adverse) but pre-existing issues ‘revealed’ by an event/effect/change cannot be relied on as grounds to terminate. In BM Brazil I Fundo De Investimento Em Participacoes Multistrategia & Ors v Sibanye BM Brazil (Pty) Ltd & Anor [2024] EWHC 2566 (Comm) the Court considered whether wider issues in the state of the mining wall, revealed by a Geotechnological Event in a Brazilian nickel mine, could constitute a Material Adverse Effect with the consequences that the buyer could terminate the SPA between signing and completion. The Court held that the state of the mining wall was a matter which existed at the time of signature of the SPA, and could have been discovered during the due diligence phase. As such, the state of the mining wall could not be a “change event or effect” occurring since signature, and could not therefore be a Material Adverse Effect - only the Geotechnological Event itself could be a “change, event or effect” having a material and adverse effect on the business. The Court also considered what would constitute “material” to the operations or finances of the target. The Court made clear that the question of what is “material” is dependent on the facts and circumstances of the transaction, and that, while there is no “bright line test”, it is likely that in order to be material, the impact on a business or its operations would need to be measured over a “commercially reasonable period….measured in years rather than months”. On the facts, the Geotechnological Event was not sufficiently material to constitute a Material Adverse Effect, and as such the buyers were not entitled to terminate the SPA and were obliged to complete. This decision highlights the importance of thoroughly and objectively investigating the effects of an event, effect, or change itself on the business of the target, before attempting to exercise a MAC/MAE clause. See our article on this issue here. Expert DeterminationAn M&A transaction that includes a deferred consideration mechanism such as an “earn-out” will often provide for disputes on the calculation of the deferred consideration to be resolved by an accountant in a binding expert determination process. This can be a useful mechanism to ensure a relatively short-form determination by a tribunal that is an expert in the subject matter of the dispute. In Onecom Group Ltd v Palmer [2024] EWHC 867 (Comm) the quantum of the buyer’s breach of warranty claim overlapped with the determination of the deferred consideration payable to the seller. The purchase price was a combination of consideration payable at completion and deferred consideration via an earn out mechanism, calculated as a multiple of EBITDA (to be assessed if not agreed via expert determination). The parties could not agree the EBITDA figure and referred a number of disputed items in the EBITDA calculation to expert determination (the “Expert Determination Issues”). However, there was a significant amount of overlap between the Outstanding Matters, and the issues that were the subject of a separate breach of warranty claim by the buyer. The buyer alleged in its breach of warranty claim that the seller had not disclosed salaries of certain key employees; an Expert Determination Issue referred to the expert was the ongoing cost to the target of those same key employees. The notification clause for the buyer’s breach of warranty claim, stated legal proceedings must be commenced “within six months of giving written notice of such claim or…..the date on which such claim becomes an actual liability or becomes capable of being quantified”. The buyer commenced legal proceedings more than six months after giving written notice of its claim on the basis that its claim could not be quantified until the Expert Determination Issues had been determined by the expert because of the overlap in subject matter. The buyer argued that if the expert found in its favour on an Expert Determination Issue, it could not bring a warranty claim in respect of the same subject matter, as it would not have suffered any loss. As such, its claim was not “capable of being quantified” until the expert determination procedure had been completed. The buyer had commenced legal proceedings within six months of the expert determination procedure completing and as such, the buyer argued, its claim was not time barred under the notification clause. The Court agreed with the buyer, finding that, given the overlap:
This case highlights the importance of properly considering the interaction between consideration adjustment provisions and limitation periods for warranty claims. A related issue arose in the case of Mr Darryl Adie & Mr Brett Cooper v Ingenuity Digital Limited [2024] EWHC 2902 (Ch). In that case, the seller sought declarations that the buyer could not run an expert determination to a conclusion and then make an indemnity claim in relation to the same underlying matters, arguing that this would allow for double recovery. The court disagreed and held that the expert determination process should run first and the seller could then contest the buyer’s indemnity claim, including by arguing at that time against a double recovery if appropriate. The court highlighted that if sellers want to restrict the buyer’s remedy for a particular issue, they need to be explicit about this and clear on the fact of the drafting; see our article ‘Share purchase agreement - relationship between price adjustment and indemnity claims’ for further information. Latest Insights
Latest News
Latest Events
legal updates November 16, 2026 COP31: Finance, trade and the challenge of turning climate ambition into in... legal updates November 16, 2026 COP31: Children, Youth, Education and Skills Day legal updates November 13, 2026 COP31: Leaders’ Summit | Resilient Cities and Built Environment legal updates November 12, 2026 COP31: Leaders’ Summit | Zero Waste - The business case for zero waste deal alerts November 06, 2026 Eversheds Sutherland advises Mercedes-Benz on European fast-charging partne... firm news November 05, 2026 Eversheds Sutherland hires partner Peter Cheng to lead Hong Kong ECM practi... firm news October 27, 2026 Eversheds Sutherland (International) announces senior leadership appointmen... firm news October 26, 2026 Eversheds Sutherland deepens fintech and regulatory bench with double partn... hybrid Europe Action Week 2026 Europe Action Week returns this November with a dynamic mix of events designed to help you navigate what’s next. virtual Belgian employment law training November 17, 2026 2.00pm - 5.00pm (GMT) Virtual in-person Industrial relations masterclass November 18, 2026 9.30am - 4.30pm (GMT) London, United Kingdom virtual Immigration UK Business – sponsor licencing course November 24, 2026 9.30am - 11.30am (GMT) Virtual |