Court of Appeal (England and Wales) shines a light for developers on how they can bring claims under the Defective Premises Act 1972
August 08, 2023
Court of Appeal (England and Wales) shines a light for developers on how they can bring claims under the Defective Premises Act 1972August 08, 2023 The Building Safety Act 2022 (BSA) has introduced widespread legal reform, such as extending limitation periods and rights of action under the Defective Premises Act 1972 (DPA). This pervasive change created some uncertainty as to how such statutory provisions should be interpreted in light of building safety claims. This has been clarified in the much anticipated Court of Appeal’s decision in URS Corporation Limited v BDW Trading Limited[1]. These findings will be of particular interest to developers, contractors and consultants who are liable for existing building safety defects. BackgroundThe DPA provides a statutory cause of action against anyone who undertook work at a dwelling which caused it to be unfit for habitation. Prior to the BSA, claims under the DPA had a 6 year limitation period. As such the DPA was rarely used and many parties preferred to make contractual claims (which have a 12 year limitation period, if executed by deed). In the aftermath of the Grenfell tragedy it was found that there was a huge legacy issue with defective cladding installed in residential flats and in many cases the contractual limitation period had already expired. This was the case in the initial proceedings between BDW, a developer, and URS, its structural engineer; BDW therefore brought a claim in negligence (which can, in certain circumstances, benefit from a 15 year long stop date for limitation). The claim was made for pure economic loss, rather than physical damage. This is typical of many building safety claims, where the defect is due to inadequate design and/or specification and preventative remedial work is needed before physical damage can manifest in the event of a fire. This brought into question when the cause of action arises for building safety claims in negligence. Whilst this claim was ongoing, the BSA was enacted. It extended the limitation period to 30 years for DPA claims[2], which applies retrospectively for any loss that was incurred prior to 28 June 2022. It was unclear however whether BDW could amend its existing proceedings to include this cause of action and whether, as a developer who had sold their proprietary interest, it was owed any duty under the DPA. The Negligence ClaimDid URS owe BDW a duty of care?URS claimed that they were not liable to BDW in negligence because BDW’s claim fell outside of the scope of their duty of care. URS argued that they only owed a duty to protect BDW’s proprietary interest and risk of loss to third parties and that neither of these duties had been breached because BDW had sold on their interest in the property in question and no physical loss had been suffered by the occupants. The Court of Appeal dismissed URS’s arguments and claimed that the duty of care on a professional is to guard against the risk of economic loss arising from a negligent design that could cause defects. It rejected that this duty was in any way diminished when BDW sold on its interest, as BDW owned the property when URS performed its services and when the cause of action accrued. When does the cause of action accrue for pure economic loss?Previous cases such as Pirelli General Cable Works Limited v Oscar Faber & Partners[3] noted that in relation to physical damage a claimant’s cause of action in negligence did not accrue until the damage occurred. This is problematic for building safety cases where defective design does not automatically lead to physical damage and may only materialise in the event of a fire. The Court of Appeal decided that the cause of action in a negligence claims for economic loss occurs when the individual buildings achieve practical completion, as that is when the defective design has been incorporated into the buildings. The DPA ClaimIs it possible to amend ongoing proceedings to include a claim under the DPA?The BSA makes it clear that the 30 year retrospective limitation period for DPA claims will not apply to matters which have been finally determined in court or arbitration, or which have settled. There is no mention in the BSA as to whether or not the 30 year retrospective limitation period can be invoked in ongoing litigation. This was relevant as BDW wanted to amend its original claim in negligence against URS to add a claim under DPA. The Court of Appeal decided that “there was no exception relating to the rights of parties involved in ongoing litigation”.[4] There was nothing to stop BDW amending its claim to include reference to the DPA. This was because the retrospective 30 year limitation period under the BSA “is to be treated as always having been in force”.[5] The Court also acknowledged that the BSA already has express exclusions relevant to how retrospective liability will apply and such exclusions do not include or reference ongoing litigation. Is the developer owed a duty of care under the DPA?This raised the next question of whether the developer, BDW, was owed a duty under the DPA in order to bring a claim. There had been some previous doubt on this point for the following reasons:
The TCC judge at first instance decided that it was “at least reasonably arguable”[6] that a developer is owed duties under the DPA, but there was no direct authority on this point. In relation to the first point, the Court of Appeal decided that the Developer is owed a duty under DPA, notwithstanding that they also owe the same duty. It was noted that similar corresponding duties can be owed and due in a contractual chain and that there was no reason why any rights under the DPA should only be considered binary[7]. Secondly, the fact that the developer had sold on its interest in the property did not preclude it from making a claim under the DPA. It was noted that the DPA provides that liability is “not abated by the subsequent disposal of the premises by the person who owed the duty”.[8] This residual liability under the DPA was a sufficient basis upon which the developer could make a claim under the DPA, notwithstanding what physical or economic loss they had actually suffered. Is the right to a fair trial hindered by the 30 year retrospective liability claim under the DPA?It was considered whether the ability of BDW to use the 30 retrospective liability claim was unfair on URS and hindered URS’s right to a fair trial. It was noted that the provisions of the BSA did not preclude a defendant’s rights under the European Convention of Human Rights. It was also noted that this right to a fair trial could be invoked in proceedings if the defendant’s pre-existing document retention policy destroyed key evidence for claims, which arose from the introduction of the 30 year retrospective limitation period[9]. The Contribution ClaimWhen can a contribution claim be initiated from a third party?Another action brought by BDW was a contribution claim from URS under the Civil Liability (Contribution) Act 1978. This permits a party to recover a contribution from any other person who is liable in respect of the same damage. The Limitation Act 1980 provides for a specific time limit for claiming such contribution, which is two years from determination (by court or arbitration) or settlement of the underlying dispute[10]. This had created some confusion as to whether the underlying claim must first be established before a contribution claim can be made. The Court of Appeal clarified that the two year period is a procedural bar and “is not addressing when the cause of action for contribution might accrue in the first place.”[11] As such, it was decided that a contribution claim could be made even when the underlying claim is “potentially notional or theoretical”[12]. This is helpful for those seeking a claim in contribution, as it means that there is less likelihood of the limitation period for such claim running out before putting the other party on notice. ConclusionsDevelopers will welcome that they can claim under the DPA, as it allows them to potentially pass on the liability that they incur under the BSA/DPA onto contractors/consultants using the same 30 year retrospective liability that they are subject to, under the BSA. This, combined with the Court’s relaxed approach on when contribution claims can commence, will mean that contractors and consultants may quickly be on the receiving end of a number of developer-led claims. The decision in URS v BDW has provided much needed clarity on how the provisions of the BSA should be interpreted. It is not expected that this decision will be appealed to the Supreme Court and it therefore constitutes the final word on this matter. However, given the introduction of such widespread and complex legal reform by the BSA coupled with the fact that the DPA has, until now, been a fairly under-used piece of legislation we expect more issues to arise and therefore further insight from the Courts in the future. Written by Gemma Irving. For further information please contact Claire Randall-Smith. [1] EWCA Civ 772 [2] S.135 BSA 2022 [3] 1983 2 AC 1 [4] Coulson at paragraph 160 [5] s.135(3) BSA 2022 [6] Adrian William KC (sitting as deputy High Court judge in the TCC) in BDW Trading Ltd v [7] Coulson paragraph 189. [8] S.3 DPA 1972 [9] Coulson paragraph 170. [10] s.10 Limitation Act 1980 [11] Coulson at para 213 [12] Coulson at paragraph 201 Latest InsightsLatest News
Latest Events
legal updates November 17, 2026 Mandatory human rights due diligence is coming to the UK legal updates November 17, 2026 COP31: Science, industry and technology – from pledges to investment pipeli... legal updates November 17, 2026 Industrial Horizons legal updates November 16, 2026 COP31: Finance, trade and the challenge of turning climate ambition into in... deal alerts November 06, 2026 Eversheds Sutherland advises Mercedes-Benz on European fast-charging partne... firm news November 05, 2026 Eversheds Sutherland hires partner Peter Cheng to lead Hong Kong ECM practi... firm news October 27, 2026 Eversheds Sutherland (International) announces senior leadership appointmen... firm news October 26, 2026 Eversheds Sutherland deepens fintech and regulatory bench with double partn... hybrid Europe Action Week 2026 Europe Action Week returns this November with a dynamic mix of events designed to help you navigate what’s next. in-person Industrial relations masterclass November 18, 2026 9.30am - 4.30pm (GMT) London, United Kingdom virtual Immigration UK Business – sponsor licencing course November 24, 2026 9.30am - 11.30am (GMT) Virtual virtual UK employment law training December 01, 2026 1pm - 4pm (GMT) Virtual |