Diversity and inclusion in financial services: the regulators outline their plans
July 28, 2021
Diversity and inclusion in financial services: the regulators outline their plansJuly 28, 2021 Is diversity and inclusion a regulatory issue? The UK financial services regulators, the FCA, the PRA and the Bank of England, certainly think so, but until recently, there has been little by way of specific guidance as to how that philosophy translates into regulatory reality. On 7 July 2021, the regulators started to put some flesh on the bones of that philosophy, by publishing a joint discussion paper (DP21/2) outlining their plans to improve diversity and inclusion in the financial services sector. There is a lot in the paper, and much of it will have far-reaching consequences for regulated firms’ policies, approach and use of metrics. The paper sets out a wide range of policy options including the use of targets to improve representation, measures to make senior leaders directly accountable for diversity and inclusion in their firms, linking remuneration to diversity and inclusion metrics, and reviewing the regulators’ approach to considering diversity and inclusion in relation to non-financial misconduct. The paper also discusses the use of data and disclosure to enable firms, regulators and other stakeholders to monitor progress. The deadline for submitting comments on the paper is 30 September 2021. The regulators will use the feedback and data received to develop more detailed proposals, which they intend to consult on in Q1 2022, with a formal policy statement expected in Q3 2022. However, the regulators have set out a clear direction of travel, which firms would be well advised to get on board with now, rather than waiting until the policy statement. The context
Diversity and inclusion is a critical component of the UK financial services regulators’ work on culture and governance. As highlighted in the latest FCA Business Plan, it is one of the cross-market priorities for the FCA in the coming year and is part of the FCA’s existing work on the treatment of customers, including vulnerability and the proposed Consumer Duty (FCA CP21/13). The FCA has also launched a consultation on proposals to improve transparency for investors on the diversity of Boards and executive management teams. For the Bank of England and the PRA, a key consideration is the connection between insufficient diversity and inclusion and groupthink, which in their view can present a serious risk to firms’ safety and soundness. The regulators also recognise that they have a responsibility to lead by example and have not shied away from acknowledging their own shortcomings. The FCA recently published its Annual Diversity Report, while the Bank of England Court has published its Review of Ethnic Diversity and Inclusion at the Bank. These actions further underline the strategic importance of diversity and inclusion to the regulators. The discussion paper notes that despite a great deal of discussion and research on diversity and inclusion over the years, progress has been limited. And while much attention has been paid to diversity – particularly gender diversity – there has been less focus on inclusion. Inclusivity is, however, crucial to delivering the benefits of diversity and key to this is psychological safety, which has for some time been a core aspect of the FCA’s work on culture and governance. Psychological safety refers to an environment where people feel free to share ideas and speak up and, as the discussion paper notes, is “an essential first step to creating an inclusive culture”. The regulators’ goal is to see increased diversity and inclusion in financial services translate into safer and sounder firms with better governance and risk management, a more innovative industry, and financial products and services that meet the diverse needs of consumers. This last point was alluded to in a speech earlier this year by FCA Chief Executive Nikhil Rathi, who commented that the lack of diversity at the top of financial services firms “raises questions about firms’ ability to understand the different communities they serve, and their different needs”. A broad definition of diversityWhen considering diversity, the regulators’ focus is on ‘diversity of thought’ (also referred to as ‘cognitive diversity’). This is defined broadly, as “bringing together a wide range of different styles of thinking among members of a group. Factors that could lead to diverse thinking could include, but [are] not limited, to different perspectives, abilities, knowledge, attitudes, information styles, and demographic characteristics, or any combination of these”. Characteristics that may, in the regulators’ view, influence diversity of thought include the nine protected characteristics defined in the Equality Act 2010 (age, disability, gender reassignment, marriage and civil partnership, pregnancy and maternity, race, religion or belief, sex, and sexual orientation), as well as other factors such as socio-economic background, gender (including where it does not coincide with sex), and cultural background. The regulators also recognise that individuals can have a combination of different diversity factors, and that the interconnected nature of those factors can create overlapping and independent systems of discrimination or disadvantage, often referred to as ‘intersectionality’.
|
Points to considerGiven that completion of a diversity questionnaire will be voluntary, and in view of the personal nature of the data requested, it is inevitable that not all staff will respond. This means that firms may have only a partial picture of the diversity characteristics of their workforce, and this limitation may affect the quality of diversity data provided to the regulators under any future reporting requirements. Nonetheless, while recognising that the proposed approach to data collection and reporting will create an additional burden for firms, it is a rational approach for improving the quality of data available and informing policy development in this area. Legal, data protection and systems issues will present hurdles to effective and accurate data collection and to this end, communication with employees and trust are key. Gathering data about personal characteristics such as ethnicity will require processing of ‘special category’ data in accordance with strict requirements under the UK General Data Protection Regulation (UK GDPR). If the data is collected for the purpose of complying with a legal requirement then this is likely to be a lawful ground for processing. However, employers need to exercise caution to ensure that processing is indeed a lawful ground within the UK GDPR. It will also be necessary to have privacy notices and retention policies in place and ensure adequate safeguards for processing and storing data. |
The discussion paper sets out a range of potential policy options aimed at increasing diversity and inclusion in financial services. Recognising the need for proportionality, the regulators do not intend to take a ‘one size fits all’ approach. They aim to avoid imposing rules that would not be effective or appropriate for smaller firms and, accordingly, some of the options discussed would apply only to larger firms.
In the regulators’ view, delivering meaningful improvements in diversity and inclusion requires “deep cultural change” in many firms. Strong leadership, particularly by Boards and senior management, is key to this. The regulators consider that a firm’s Board is the appropriate body for setting the diversity and inclusion strategy and policy and overseeing its progress.
Specific policy options under consideration by the regulators include the following:
Points to considerIn respect of Board representation targets, it is difficult to see a strong case for limiting such targets to gender representation only, as such an approach would not achieve the breadth of diversity necessary to meet the regulators’ policy objectives. Guidance on diversity and inclusion metrics should be welcomed as it will assist firms in developing and applying properly considered approaches, based on identified good practice, to setting and adjusting variable remuneration awards. |
The discussion paper set out a number of options relating to firms’ policies and practices.
Points to considerWhile the suggested options may appear laudable, firms should exercise caution. Lawful positive action to promote diversity is limited under the Equality Act 2010 and the line between lawful and unlawful positive action can be hard to draw. For example, encouraging underrepresented groups to apply is likely to be lawful but limiting vacancies to minority candidates is not. Equally, offering training to improve accessibility may be permissible but if this training is limited to just one group with a protected characteristic under the Equality Act 2010, it may be discriminatory. ‘Tie breaker’ positive action allows employers to prefer a candidate from an underrepresented group where two or more candidates are of equal merit, but this is only permissible where it is a proportionate way of addressing the underrepresentation. Practically, it is hard to show that two candidates are of equal merit and relying on this ground can prove to be a minefield. |
The discussion paper also sets out proposed regulatory measures that could be taken to improve diversity and inclusion in the sector.
Points to considerWhile the FCA has previously taken enforcement action against individuals for non-financial misconduct, the facts of these cases have tended to be outliers and do not provide much assistance in understanding regulatory thinking in relation to more borderline conduct. The introduction of guidance on non-financial misconduct will bring much-needed clarity and should be welcomed by firms and individuals. The suggestion that approvals for SMF appointments could potentially be withheld on diversity and inclusion grounds is intriguing and, if taken forward, it will be interesting to see how this plays out in practice. Intervention of this nature may create legal risk for the regulators: they will need to have a robust case for withholding approval on these grounds if they are to avoid being accused of engaging in discriminatory practices themselves. Regulatory guidance in respect of the Threshold Conditions should also be welcomed, as the commentary in the discussion paper raises the prospect of firms with particularly poor records on diversity and inclusion losing their regulatory authorisation. |
Having talked previously about diversity and inclusion in relatively high-level terms, the FCA, PRA and Bank of England have now given firms a clearer indication of the types of requirements that may be introduced. While detailed rules and guidance are still some way off, with a policy statement not expected until Q3 2022 at the earliest, the discussion paper is a helpful development that will assist firms’ understanding of regulatory thinking. It also gives firms an opportunity to shape policy in an area that is an important part of regulators’ broader Environmental, Social and Governance (ESG) agenda, both in the UK and around the globe.
Given the far-reaching nature of many of the policy options, it is in firms’ interests to provide feedback to the regulators and start considering the feasibility of complying with the types of requirements set out in the discussion paper. While the dialogue on diversity and inclusion in financial services may still be in its infancy, there can be no doubt that following the implementation of rules and guidance, the regulators intend to use their powers to take action against firms that fail to meet minimum expectations, particularly where those failures have an impact on consumers and markets.
legal updates
November 16, 2026
COP31: Finance, trade and the challenge of turning climate ambition into in...
legal updates
November 13, 2026
COP31: Leaders’ Summit | Resilient Cities and Built Environment 
legal updates
November 12, 2026
COP31: Leaders’ Summit | Zero Waste - The business case for zero waste
legal updates
November 11, 2026
COP31: Energy and Transport – Electrification takes center stage in Antalya
deal alerts
November 06, 2026
Eversheds Sutherland advises Mercedes-Benz on European fast-charging partne...
firm news
November 05, 2026
Eversheds Sutherland hires partner Peter Cheng to lead Hong Kong ECM practi...
firm news
October 27, 2026
Eversheds Sutherland (International) announces senior leadership appointmen...
firm news
October 26, 2026
Eversheds Sutherland deepens fintech and regulatory bench with double partn...
hybrid
Europe Action Week 2026
Europe Action Week returns this November with a dynamic mix of events designed to help you navigate what’s next.
virtual
Belgian employment law training
November 17, 2026
2.00pm - 5.00pm (GMT)
Virtual
in-person
Industrial relations masterclass
November 18, 2026
9.30am - 4.30pm (GMT)
London, United Kingdom
virtual
Immigration UK Business – sponsor licencing course
November 24, 2026
9.30am - 11.30am (GMT)
Virtual