Employee representation considerations when introducing or making changes to pensions and benefits
April 27, 2023
Employee representation considerations when introducing or making changes to pensions and benefitsApril 27, 2023 Employers are confronted daily with a range of compensation and benefits issues, including pensions matters. As recruitment and retention issues continue to be compounded by talent shortages in some sectors and with an ever-changing body of legislation and regulation globally, these issues become even more demanding for multi-national employers. Compliance with obligations towards employee representative bodies can often be overlooked in the desire to keep up with the multitude of factors influencing compensation and benefits. However, such oversight can have a significant impact on the cost and timing, as well as the risk profile, of measures. Following on from our Representation in the workplace: Essential guide for global businesses, in this briefing we explore some of the employee representation considerations when introducing or making changes to pensions and benefits, with a particular focus on the Netherlands. Information and consultation obligations: compensation and benefits changesThe relationship with employee representative bodies in the workplace, whether unions, employee forums, Works Councils or other bodies, is often at the heart of effective and positive employee relations within any business. Globally, collective consultation with representative bodies on significant workplace measures is a familiar concept, particularly in respect of large-scale reduction in force or business change exercises. However, often less familiar is the requirement in some countries to consult with such bodies where compensation and benefits schemes are introduced, amended or withdrawn. Where obligations with employee representative bodies are triggered by a proposed workplace measure, this can trigger a legal obligation in some jurisdictions to establish a body for the purpose of consulting on that measure if there is not already a body in existence, or at least enter into discussion with the employees to ascertain any desire for a body to be established. Where the obligation arises, the employee representative body must be created before implementing the proposed workplace measure. In other jurisdictions, the absence of an existing body can require the information and consultation exercise to be carried out directly with employees. For example, in the UK, where an employer is obliged to inform and consult employee representatives before making certain changes to occupational pension schemes. The requirement covers a number of statutory "listed changes", including the closure of a scheme to new members or changing the basis on which members accrue benefits. Where there is no existing recognised trade union or elected employee forum, employers must go through a prescribed process to establish a body for information and consultation purposes. Focus on: the NetherlandsIn the Netherlands, The Works Council Act stipulates the various powers of different employee representative bodies according to the type of measure and number of employees. Every business that employs in general 50 or more individuals in the Netherlands is required to set up a Works Council, a non-corporate body consisting of elected employees of the company. The Works Council has a number of general rights, such as the right of initiative and the right to receive all information needed for the performance of its tasks. Depending on the proposed measure or circumstances, the Works Council may also have the right to render prior advice, or the right of consent. The consent of any Works Council is required before any measures are taken to introduce, amend or withdraw certain benefits schemes, including pensions and any remuneration or job assessment system. An exception applies in the case of pension plans administered by a mandatory industry-wide pension fund and/or exhaustively arranged in an applicable collective labour agreement, where labour unions have primary authority. Generally, establishing or making changes to a pension scheme, or certain changes to remuneration such as a new bonus or incentive scheme or changes to a scheme that results in a change to the system of entitlement to a bonus, will require the prior consent of the Works Council. The Works Council consent procedure is prescribed by law, including a requirement for the proposal to be presented by the employer to the Works Council in writing with a summary of the reasons for it, as well as the expected consequences for the workforce. The consent must be sought before any decision is taken on the proposed measure and at a time when the Works Council can still affect that decision, with the Works Council having the right to ask for further information or explanation. In addition, the consent of the individual employee members will be required to change their existing employment conditions, with unilateral changes permitted only in very limited circumstances. Compensation is not legally required to effect the change, but in practice a monetary incentive is often provided in order to gain the consent. Where a Works Council has a right of consent, failing to start the process of seeking that consent in a timely manner will inevitably prolong the process and delay implementation of the measure. Moreover, failing to obtain such consent can have additional significant consequences, including rendering any applicable measure null and void and potentially resulting in legal proceedings being initiated. A new pension system on the horizon in the NetherlandsThe pension system in the Netherlands will soon face an unprecedented reform, with defined benefit agreements no longer allowed for future accruals, and all accrued pension benefits converted to defined contribution by default. Particularly in view of the statutory right to consent regarding pension changes, central to the implementation of that reform will be the interaction between employers, employees and Works Councils. The new Pensions Act is expected to take effect from 1 July 2023, with the transition period ending on 31 December 2026. Part of this major operation is that employers (except for those obliged to participate in an industry wide pension fund) will be required to prepare detailed transition plans, including dealing with any related compensation to employees. The proposed pension changes, together with the related changes to existing employment conditions, will require approval from the Works Council and from the impacted employees. In addition, employers will need to adjust the applicable contracts with pension providers. What key actions should employers in the Netherlands be taking now?In the case of mandatory industry-wide pension funds, in principle, arrangements will be organised centrally between the collective labor agreement parties and the pension fund administrators. In other cases, employers will have significant work to do in effecting the required changes. Starting early to engage with employees and employee representative bodies regarding the pension system changes and the resulting impact and proposed measures will be key to a successful process. Employers should bear in mind that, regardless of the statutory nature of the pension reforms, the prior consent of any Works Council will be required as a primary step. Once that consent is obtained, a process should then take place to obtain the individual consent of each employee to the change to their employment conditions. Careful planning will be required for each stage of this process, providing enough information throughout to build and maintain trust and to seek to achieve a collaborate process. How we can helpOur teams of lawyers have extensive experience in advising both locally and globally on change management projects, including changes to benefits and pensions, wherever in the world businesses are located. Our lawyers are ideally placed to support in managing such projects, including providing practical and strategic advice on different laws and practices to maximize the aims and benefits. We also regularly carry out a programme of events, webinars and training courses designed to keep you up to date, including a series of courses across a number of jurisdictions on Working with the Works Council.
Latest Insights
Latest News
Latest Events
legal updates November 19, 2026 Learning from experience | Mentoring for Alumni legal updates November 19, 2026 COP31: People and progress in focus as negotiations reach a critical stage legal updates November 18, 2026 COP31: Oceans, nature and land use gain ground in climate policy and inves... legal updates November 18, 2026 The EU Pharma Package: Key Reforms for Pharmaceutical Companies client news November 19, 2026 Eversheds Sutherland advises EDF on landmark UK energy retail acquisition deal alerts November 06, 2026 Eversheds Sutherland advises Mercedes-Benz on European fast-charging partne... firm news November 05, 2026 Eversheds Sutherland hires partner Peter Cheng to lead Hong Kong ECM practi... firm news October 27, 2026 Eversheds Sutherland (International) announces senior leadership appointmen... hybrid Europe Action Week 2026 Europe Action Week returns this November with a dynamic mix of events designed to help you navigate what’s next. virtual Immigration UK Business – sponsor licencing course November 24, 2026 9.30am - 11.30am (GMT) Virtual virtual UK employment law training December 01, 2026 1pm - 4pm (GMT) Virtual virtual Strategic Reflections on COP31 December 02, 2026 10am GMT | 11am CET Virtual, |