English High Court reverts to earlier test for the purposes of freezing injunctions
What is needed for “a good arguable case on the merits”
May 07, 2024
English High Court reverts to earlier test for the purposes of freezing injunctionsWhat is needed for “a good arguable case on the merits”May 07, 2024 Facts of the CasesMagomedov The claimants (“Cs”) allege conspiracy claims involving the deprivation of stakes in a Russian sea port and shipping company. Cs applied for a notification injunction against the twentieth defendant (“D20”). After the hearing, Butcher J identified to the parties two recent cases apparently reflecting a change in the law on the test of “good arguable case on the merits” in relation to freezing injunctions (i.e. Harrington v Mehta [2022] EWHC 2960 (Ch) and Chowgule v Shirke [2023] EWHC 2815 (Comm)) and invited the parties’ submissions on them. In Harrington and Chowgule, the Court had departed from the “traditional” test on “good arguable case on the merits” in relation to freezing injunctions (i.e. “one which is more than barely capable of serious argument, but not necessarily one which the judge considers would have a better than 50 per cent chance of success”, per Mustill J in Ninemia Maritime Corp v Trave Schiffahrtsgesellschaft GmbH (The 'Niedersachsen') [1983] 2 Lloyd's Rep 600 at [605]), and had instead applied the higher standard of test developed in relation to jurisdiction gateways (i.e. the applicant must prove they have the “better of the argument”, per the three-limbed test in Brownlie v Four Seasons Holdings Inc [2017] UKSC 80). The Court did this in Harrington and Chowgule on the apprehension that the law on “good arguable case on the merits” had essentially been unified for both freezing injunctions and jurisdiction gateways as a result of Brownlie and later authorities decided by reference to it (in particular Lakatamia Shipping Co. Ltd. v Morimoto [2019] EWCA Civ 2203 and Kaefer Aislamientos SA de CV v AMS Drilling Mexico SA de CV [2019] EWCA Civ 10). Unitel The claimant (“C”) alleges that the second defendant (“D2”) breached her director duties to C in causing it to grant uncommercial loans to the first defendant (“D1”) (a company which she owned). C applied for a worldwide freezing injunction against D2 having joined her to existing proceedings against D1. There was significant argument at the hearing about what “good arguable case on the merits” meant in relation to freezing injunctions, as a result of the decisions in Harrington, Lakatamia, and Kaefer, and (as was at issue in Magomedov) whether the law had moved on such that the Court must apply the higher standard of test derived from Brownlie rather than the “traditiona l” test in The Niedersachsen. The DecisionsMagomedov Butcher J, having analysed the relevant authorities and textbooks, found “without real doubt” that the decisions in Harrington and Chowgule were wrong insofar as they applied the test derived from Brownlie to freezing injunctions instead of the test derived from The Niedersachsen. Whilst there had been developments in the law in relation to jurisdiction gateways (i.e. Brownlie and subsequent authorities) those were not developments in relation to freezing injunctions, in relation to which the “traditional” lower test continued to apply. Butcher J found that Cs had satisfied that test, along with the other limbs of the test for a notification injunction (i.e. there was a real risk of dissipation of assets and it was just and convenient to grant the order), and so granted the order sought. Unitel Bright J had the benefit of Butcher J’s decision which had been handed down a few days after the hearing in Unitel. Bright J agreed with Butcher J’s analysis essentially for the same reasons, as well as the finding that the Court of Appeal’s decision in Lakatamia was unclear on this issue and could only be understood if the Court of Appeal had not intended to change the law in this area (noting that the Court of Appeal in Lakatamia was being asked to decide an issue regarding risk of dissipation rather than “good arguable case on the merits”, which might explain the lack of clarity in the relevant part of its decision). Bright J found that C had proven that it had a “good arguable case on the merits”, along with the two other limbs of the test for a freezing injunction, and so granted the order sought. Practical AnalysisNotwithstanding the decisions in Magomedov and Unitel, the law in this area remains (as Bright J found) in a state of confusion and would benefit from a definitive answer from the Court of Appeal. Until then, respondents to freezing injunctions will likely seek to argue that the High Court should apply the higher standard of the test derived from Brownlie in deciding whether an applicant has a “good arguable case on the merits”; while applicants, out of an abundance of caution pending such clarification, should consider whether they can satisfy this higher standard before launching their application. In practice, that might necessitate further factual investigations and work on the evidence in support, all of which will likely increase the time it takes to prepare such application and accordingly the cost involved (including at any return hearing, where it may be that expert evidence is also required). Bright J made observations about these potential consequences of the current uncertainty of the law and the need for clarity so as to avoid them. Further, if an ex parte applicant is proceeding on the basis of the “traditional” test in The Niedersachsen, then it should make clear as part of its duty of full and frank disclosure and fair presentation that the law in this area is uncertain and that the respondent (had they been present) might argue that the higher test derived from Brownlie should apply (before going on to explain why the applicant considers this is not the case). To do otherwise risks the respondent identifying it as a breach of that duty, and potentially using it as a basis to seek the discharge of the injunction and / or to resist its renewal at a return hearing.
Latest Insights
Latest News
Latest Events
legal updates November 13, 2026 COP31: Leaders’ Summit | Resilient Cities and Built Environment legal updates November 12, 2026 COP31: Leaders’ Summit | Zero Waste - The business case for zero waste legal updates November 11, 2026 COP31: Energy and Transport – Electrification takes center stage in Antalya legal updates November 11, 2026 Algorithmic Management of Workforces: Is your business a “platform” without... deal alerts November 06, 2026 Eversheds Sutherland advises Mercedes-Benz on European fast-charging partne... firm news November 05, 2026 Eversheds Sutherland hires partner Peter Cheng to lead Hong Kong ECM practi... firm news October 27, 2026 Eversheds Sutherland (International) announces senior leadership appointmen... firm news October 26, 2026 Eversheds Sutherland deepens fintech and regulatory bench with double partn... hybrid Europe Action Week 2026 Europe Action Week returns this November with a dynamic mix of events designed to help you navigate what’s next. virtual Belgian employment law training November 17, 2026 2.00pm - 5.00pm (GMT) Virtual in-person Industrial relations masterclass November 18, 2026 9.30am - 4.30pm (GMT) London, United Kingdom virtual Immigration UK Business – sponsor licencing course November 24, 2026 9.30am - 11.30am (GMT) Virtual |