High Court lifts up a rock: rule amendments and section 37 confirmations
June 20, 2023
High Court lifts up a rock: rule amendments and section 37 confirmationsJune 20, 2023 On Friday last week the High Court in Virgin Media v NTL Pension Trustees gave its views on whether historic amendments to benefits made after 6 April 1997 in a contracted-out salary-related scheme are valid in the absence of a written “section 37” confirmation from the actuary. It found that they are not but has left the door open for both further argument and an appeal. This speedbrief looks at the background to, and potential implications of, this case for DB schemes that were previously contracted-out on a salary-related basis. The legal backgroundPrior to 6 April 2016, pension schemes could contract-out of the state second pension if they met various conditions which were set out in the Pension Schemes Act 1993 (“PSA 93”), regulations and guidance. DB schemes that contracted-out on a salary-related basis were known as “COSR” schemes. From 6 April 1997, COSR schemes had to provide benefits for 90% of members that satisfied an overall quality standard called the “reference scheme test” – broadly, a pension at age 65 of 1/80th of qualifying band earnings and a 50% spouse’s pension. The actuary had to confirm every three years that the scheme continued to meet this test. Members’ contracted-out rights under the reference scheme test were commonly called “section 9(2B) rights” after the relevant section of the PSA 93. Section 37 PSA 93 contains restrictions on amendments to contracted-out schemes (or schemes that were formally contracted-out) which are broadly aimed at ensuring the reference scheme test continued to be met. The conditions which amendments needed to satisfy up to the abolition of contracting out in April 2016 are set out in regulation 42 of the Occupational Pension Schemes (Contracting out) Regulations 1996 and changed over time. The interpretation of this legislation and how it interacts with other aspects of the COSR regime has long been a source of uncertainty. Some of the potential issues included:
The NTL case is the first court decision to address these issues directly. The caseThe NTL case concerned the form of the legislation that was in effect until 6 April 2013. The High Court decided three key issues:
Eversheds Sutherland acted for the Trustee in the case, which took a neutral stance as to the outcome but needed to know the correct basis on which to administer benefits. What next?The High Court’s decision may have very important consequences for some COSR schemes. This is because changes to members’ section 9(2B) rights which were not accompanied by a section 37 confirmation – going as far back as 1997 – will on the face of this judgment be void.
There should be greater clarity about what is happening next sometime in July. It is also possible that the government will be lobbied by the pensions industry to try and ‘fix’ the effect of this judgment. Possible next stepsIf the High Court’s decision stands, there will be a number of issues that COSR schemes need to consider where section 37 confirmations cannot be found in relation to amendments to section 9(2B) rights made between 6 April 1997 and 6 April 2016 (when the requirement for written confirmation was removed). In some cases, there may be sufficient evidence to conclude that a confirmation was given but has been lost, but in other cases the evidence may indicate that no confirmation was given and the amendments are potentially void. If, as seems likely, a large number of schemes are affected by this decision, it is worth noting that section 37 includes a power for regulations to retrospectively validate rule amendments that would otherwise be void under that provision. DWP has not yet made any regulations under this power in relation to section 9 (2B) rights but may choose to do so in response to the judgment. Where, for example, a scheme can show that an amendment satisfied section 67 (and did not detrimentally affect accrued rights) and the next actuarial valuation confirmed that the reference scheme test continued to be met, it is difficult to see what the policy reason would be for saying amendments are void. Where schemes are about to enter into a buy in, buy out or any other irreversible arrangement that effectively crystallises the benefit entitlements that members have in the scheme, the parties need to consider the effect that this decision has on those arrangements and whether the benefit structure could be affected by the absence of any section 37 confirmations. In other cases, trustees may want to consider if a review of their documentation is needed at this stage (for example to gain an initial understanding of the scope of the potential issue for their scheme), or if they want to wait until later in the summer when we expect there will be more clarity around whether an appeal, further hearing or DWP regulations are likely to be forthcoming. We will keep you updated on any developments in this area. For more information or support, contact your usual ES legal adviser or any of the contacts below: Latest Insights
Latest News
Latest Events
legal updates November 20, 2026 COP31: Enhancing Implementation - Revised draft seeks consensus amid compet... legal updates November 20, 2026 Implementation of the EU Pay Transparency Directive: New development in Spa... legal updates November 19, 2026 COP31: People and progress in focus as negotiations reach a critical stage legal updates November 19, 2026 Learning from experience | Mentoring for Alumni client news November 19, 2026 Eversheds Sutherland advises EDF on landmark UK energy retail acquisition deal alerts November 06, 2026 Eversheds Sutherland advises Mercedes-Benz on European fast-charging partne... firm news November 05, 2026 Eversheds Sutherland hires partner Peter Cheng to lead Hong Kong ECM practi... firm news October 27, 2026 Eversheds Sutherland (International) announces senior leadership appointmen... hybrid Europe Action Week 2026 Europe Action Week returns this November with a dynamic mix of events designed to help you navigate what’s next. virtual Immigration UK Business – sponsor licencing course November 24, 2026 9.30am - 11.30am (GMT) Virtual virtual UK employment law training December 01, 2026 1pm - 4pm (GMT) Virtual virtual Strategic Reflections on COP31 December 02, 2026 10am GMT | 11am CET Virtual, |