In detail: The UK Supreme Court issues landmark decision on backdated holiday pay
October 04, 2023
In detail: The UK Supreme Court issues landmark decision on backdated holiday payOctober 04, 2023 The Supreme Court has handed down a significant decision today in the case of Chief Constable of the Police Service (NI) v Agnew and others, finally resolving the long-disputed “cut off” for backdated holiday pay claims where such claims are pursued in the Employment Tribunal as unlawful deductions from wages. Reversing the position as previously understood in Great Britain, the court has found that a period of three months or more between alleged deductions, or a lawful payment, does not act as a break to any series of deductions which limits prior (backdated) claims. What constitutes a series of deductions is far more nuanced and is a question of fact. The implications for employers in terms of backdated holiday pay claims, particularly from those not recognised as employees, could be significant. It is even more significant in Northern Ireland, where the two year statutory back stop on unlawful deduction claims does not apply. Legal BackgroundWhere an employee claims to have received no or inadequate holiday pay, claims which are open to them in the employment tribunal include: an alleged breach of the Working Time Regulations 1998 (or in Northern Ireland, the Working Time Regulations (Northern Ireland) 1998 and subsequently the Working Time Regulations (Northern Ireland) 2016) or breach of the right not to suffer unauthorised deductions from wages (section 13 Employment Rights Act 1996)(section 13 ERA). Equivalent provisions apply in Northern Ireland under the Employment Rights (Northern Ireland) Order 1996. The basis of claim under section 13 ERA is that there has been an unauthorised deduction from wages (as defined). Claims must be submitted within three months of the alleged deduction or, where there has been more than one, within three months of the last in a “series of deductions”. In the latter case, provided that a series of deductions can be established, the Tribunal has jurisdiction to consider the whole series of deductions from the start. However, two important clarifications have been introduced subsequently:
In the current case of Agnew, the Northern Irish Court of Appeal (NICA) rejected the three month gap rule, finding it to be too blunt an instrument for determining whether there has been a “series” of unlawful deductions from wages, particularly in the context of holiday pay. However, decisions of the Northern Irish courts are not binding in Great Britain, which has temporarily led to a divergence in case authorities and the approach to backdated holiday pay claims as between Northern Ireland and Great Britain. This appeal decision by the Supreme Court now rectifies that inconsistency, being applicable across all areas of the UK. FactsAgnew was one of 3,380 police officers and 364 civilian employees who brought unlawful deductions from wages claims against the Police Service of Northern Ireland (PSNI), based on underpayments of holiday pay over several years. The PSNI accepted that their calculation of holiday had been wrong, resulting in a “deduction from wages”, but disputed the extent of the remedy available to the Claimants. The PSNI contended that the “three month gap rule” restricted the amounts that could be claimed (the recoverable amounts on this restricted basis amounting to approximately £300,000). This was on the basis that any series of deductions can be broken by a gap of more than three months between unlawful deductions or by a lawful payment, based on the Bear Scotland Ltd v Fulton ruling. The Claimants contended that their claims should be allowed to go back to the commencement of the Working Time Regulations (Northern Ireland) 1998 (at a cost to the Police Service of approximately £30 million). Although a core issue in the case originally related to worker status and eligibility of police officers/sergeants to claim, in order to assess the employer’s potential liability for backdated unlawful deductions from wages claims, the NICA was also asked to determine whether:
The NICA declined to follow the EAT in Bear Scotland as regards the meaning of a “series of deductions” and when a series might be interrupted. The ERA is silent on these issues but the NICA held:
The Supreme Court DecisionThe Supreme Court has upheld the NICA’s decision and dismissed the appeal. On the issue of the “series of deductions”, the Supreme Court agreed with the NICA’s interpretation that the three month gap rule could lead to unfair results and act against the legislation’s purpose of protecting workers from exploitation. What constitutes a series of deductions will always be a question of fact. In the present case, the fact that the deductions were linked by a common fault in the error in calculation pointed towards there being a series of deductions. The Supreme Court also briefly dealt with other grounds of appeal. In particular, the Supreme Court concurred with the NICA that annual leave is not taken in a particular sequence and held instead that all sources of annual leave (i.e., the four weeks deriving from European law, the 1.6 weeks under the WTR and contractual leave) are indistinguishable. On the correct mode of calculation, the Supreme Court again upheld the NICA’s finding that this is a question of fact, but indicated that working days should be used for this purpose, not calendar days. On the issue of the appropriate reference period, this was again considered to be a question of fact, albeit the “pragmatic approach” encouraged by the NICA, being a 12-month reference period, was referred to. CommentEmployers should review their records of holiday pay and overtime and allowances to assess any potential claims for underpayment of holiday pay, ensuring that internal audits have the benefit of legal professional privilege. Specialist legal advice should be taken before making changes to the way holiday pay is calculated or compromising actual or potential back pay claims for holiday pay. We would expect to see a renewed focus on the topic of holiday pay in light in this decision, with sizable potential liability for employers in unpaid holiday pay. It can no longer be assumed that a series of deductions is broken by a gap of more than three months or by a lawful payment. Although a two year limit on claims for deductions of wages has been in place in England, Wales and Scotland since 2014, no equivalent provision currently applies in Northern Ireland and claims can therefore span a significant period, potentially going back to the commencement of the Working Time Regulations (Northern Ireland) 1998. Many employers may previously have adopted the “watch this space” approach, but the Supreme Court’s decision has brought finality to this issue, meaning that it is now necessary for employers to take action. How we can helpOur teams across the UK, including in Northern Ireland, can help with advice on the correct calculation of holiday pay and on managing the risk of potential holiday pay liability. Latest News
Latest Events
client news November 19, 2026 Eversheds Sutherland advises EDF on landmark UK energy retail acquisition deal alerts November 06, 2026 Eversheds Sutherland advises Mercedes-Benz on European fast-charging partne... firm news November 05, 2026 Eversheds Sutherland hires partner Peter Cheng to lead Hong Kong ECM practi... firm news October 27, 2026 Eversheds Sutherland (International) announces senior leadership appointmen... hybrid Europe Action Week 2026 Europe Action Week returns this November with a dynamic mix of events designed to help you navigate what’s next. virtual Immigration UK Business – sponsor licencing course November 24, 2026 9.30am - 11.30am (GMT) Virtual virtual UK employment law training December 01, 2026 1pm - 4pm (GMT) Virtual virtual Strategic Reflections on COP31 December 02, 2026 10am GMT | 11am CET Virtual, |