Landmark Commercial Court Ruling on employer termination requirements in pension schemes
In the Matter of Amcor Pension Scheme (Ireland) (1)
April 08, 2025
Landmark Commercial Court Ruling on employer termination requirements in pension schemesIn the Matter of Amcor Pension Scheme (Ireland) (1)April 08, 2025 On 28 March 2025, Mr. Justice Denis McDonald delivered a seminal judgment in the Commercial Court in the case of In the Matter of Amcor Pension Scheme (Ireland): Amcor Pension Trust (Ireland) Company Limited by Guarantee v Amcor Holding No. 1 Limited. The ruling clarifies a long-standing debate in the pension industry: whether employers are required to provide reasonable notice before terminating their liability to pay contributions to defined benefit pensions schemes. Eversheds Sutherland represented the successful respondent, Amcor Holding No. 1 Limited, the principal employer of the Amcor Pension Scheme (Ireland), in these proceedings. Case detailsIn this case, the Applicant / Trustee of the Scheme sought the court's determination on two questions regarding the interpretation of the Scheme documents. These questions centred on a provision that allowed the Respondent / Employer to terminate its liability to pay contributions to the Scheme. The Employer argued that the provision in question permitted immediate termination, while the Trustee contended that reasonable notice must be given. In the alternative, the Trustee argued that a term should be implied into the Scheme documents to that effect. Ultimately, the court determined that, on a proper interpretation of the Deed, the provision in question did not obligate the Employer to provide reasonable notice of termination. The court also rejected the Applicant’s alternative case, finding that the proposed implied term did not satisfy the criteria set out in the BP Refinery test (discussed below). The Scheme & notice of terminationThe Scheme, which was originally established in March 1991, was a defined benefit scheme funded by contributions from the principal employer and members. On 26 May 2022, the Employer sent a letter to the Trustee terminating its liability to pay contributions to the Scheme with immediate effect. The Trustee did not accept the immediate termination, arguing that the courts would likely imply a reasonable notice period into the Scheme documents. The Trustee sought actuarial advice and estimated a significant buy-out deficit. On 30 September 2022, the Trustee made a formal contribution demand, which the Respondent did not accept. Interpretation of pension scheme documentsThe judgment outlines the applicable principles for interpreting pension scheme documents, noting that while the principles of interpretation are very similar to those governing other contractual documents, additional principles apply due to the nature of pension arrangements. The court stated that the principles of interpretation for pension deeds require a practical and purposive approach, considering the factual matrix, market practice, and the document as a whole. The court also emphasised that a deed should not be analysed through the lens of a dispute that has subsequently arisen but should be construed by reference to the meaning that the wording would convey to a reasonable person in the parties’ position. The particular provision under consideration in this case was Clause 5(4) of the Scheme’s governing trust deed which provided: “An Employer may at any time, by notice in writing to the Trustees, terminate its liability to pay contributions to the Fund. Any notice of termination is without prejudice to any obligation of the Employer to pay contributions to the Fund in respect of any period before the effective date of the notice.” Considering the wider provisions of the Deed, the court also found that, provided the notice was clear as to the date on which the cessation of contributions was to take effect, allowing for immediate termination would not undermine the general operation of the Scheme. The Trustee had argued that allowing immediate termination by the Employer would render the Scheme’s wind-up rule unworkable. This was on the basis that it would deny the Trustee the time necessary to take the practical steps required of them under the Scheme’s wind-up rule which provided for benefits to be secured where practicable through the purchase of insurance policies or annuities. However, the court rejected this argument noting that there was nothing in the language of the Deed which indicated that the Trustee was required to take any steps during the period between the receipt of a termination notice and the effective date of that notice. The wind-up process prescribed by the Deed would only be triggered once the Scheme had actually been terminated and the wind-up process would have to be followed regardless of whether advance notice had been provided or not. On that basis, the court saw no reason to conclude that a notice period was a necessary element of the wind-up process nor that its absence would conflict with the process or render it unworkable. Interestingly, in considering Clause 5(4) in light of the wider provisions of the Scheme, the court expressly referenced the balance of power under the Deed, and specifically the terms of the contribution rule, as a relevant factor in its interpretation. Ultimately, the court found that there was no scope to interpret Clause 5(4) in the manner advanced by the Applicant. To do so would effectively involve a rewriting of the Deed and a shift in the balance of power between the parties in a manner that was clearly not reflective of the agreement between the parties. The court held that this was evident when one read and interpreted the Deed as a whole. Implication of a termThe Applicant alternatively argued that a term should be implied into the 2008 Deed requiring the Employer to give reasonable notice before terminating contributions. The relevant test for implied terms is the one originally summarised in the B.P. Refinery(2) case which was more recently approved and applied by the Court of Appeal in Flynn v Breccia(3) (the BP Refinery test). This test comprises five criteria, four of which must be satisfied, with the second and third elements being alternatives. The court found that the first criterion - that the term contended for should be reasonable and equitable - was readily satisfied, also noting that a requirement for advance notice to terminate contributions is a relatively common feature of pension schemes. The second and third (alternative) requirements of the BP Refinery test are that: the term is either necessary to give business efficacy to the contract (the business efficacy test); or so obvious that "it goes without saying" (the obviousness test). In analysing these requirements, the court noted that they needed to be considered by reference to the position of the parties when the Deed was put in place, rather than through the lens of the dispute (ie without the benefit of hindsight). Regarding the obviousness test, the court stated that it was by no means obvious that the “hypothetical reasonable employer” would, beyond doubt, consider there should be a requirement that advance notice be given to the trustee of its intention to cease contributions. The court, having concluded that the obviousness test was not satisfied, turned to the alternative business efficacy test. It stated that this test does not require absolute necessity but rather that the contract would lack commercial or practical coherence without the implied term. The court again considered the various steps that a trustee would need to take following receipt of a termination notice, and found that these steps would need to be taken regardless of whether notice was given, as they are necessary for the Trustee to fulfil its obligations to ensure the members receive their entitled benefits upon the termination of the Scheme (as required under Clause 33(4) of the Deed). The court therefore determined that it is not necessary to imply a term requiring reasonable notice to give business efficacy to the Deed. The court highlighted that implying such a term would essentially involve creating a different contract than the one originally agreed upon by the parties. While it was not strictly necessary to consider the remaining two criteria of the BP Refinery test in circumstances where neither the obviousness test nor the business efficacy test was satisfied, the court nevertheless did so. It found that while a term would be capable of clear expression by inserting "[x] months” into the working of Clause 5(4), there was not sufficient evidence before the court to conclude what period of notice would be reasonable in this case. Regarding the final criterion - that the proposed implied term must not contradict any express term - the court would not go so far as to suggest that the proposed implied term was directly contradicted by the express terms in the Deed, noting that many existing schemes operate successfully with such a term. As such, the court rejected the Applicant's alternative basis for the case, concluding that the proposed implied term does not satisfy the B.P. Refinery test approved in Flynn v. Breccia. Final thoughtsThe ruling in this case reaffirms well-established contractual principles and brings welcome clarification in relation to previous deeds with a similar termination clause as the Amcor Deed. The court gave effect to the plain meaning of the clause, namely, the Employer could terminate without notice. The decision also reinforces the significance of precise language in legal documents and the necessity for trustees to thoroughly comprehend the terms of their schemes. The decision also serves as a reminder of the court's reluctance to imply terms into detailed and carefully drafted agreements. Many defined benefit pension schemes include clauses that permit employers to terminate their contributions to a pension scheme. Given the prevalence of such termination clauses, the court's ruling in this case sets a precedent that will likely influence the interpretation and application of similar clauses in other such schemes. Employers and trustees of defined benefit pension schemes will need to carefully review their scheme documents and consider the implications of this judgment on their own arrangements.
1) (2025) IEHC 176 2) BP Refinery (Westernport) PTY Ltd v Shire of Hastings (1977) 180 CLR 266 Latest Insights
Latest News
Latest Events
legal updates November 19, 2026 Learning from experience | Mentoring for Alumni legal updates November 19, 2026 COP31: People and progress in focus as negotiations reach a critical stage legal updates November 18, 2026 The EU Pharma Package: Key Reforms for Pharmaceutical Companies legal updates November 18, 2026 COP31: Oceans, nature and land use gain ground in climate policy and inves... client news November 19, 2026 Eversheds Sutherland advises EDF on landmark UK energy retail acquisition deal alerts November 06, 2026 Eversheds Sutherland advises Mercedes-Benz on European fast-charging partne... firm news November 05, 2026 Eversheds Sutherland hires partner Peter Cheng to lead Hong Kong ECM practi... firm news October 27, 2026 Eversheds Sutherland (International) announces senior leadership appointmen... hybrid Europe Action Week 2026 Europe Action Week returns this November with a dynamic mix of events designed to help you navigate what’s next. virtual Immigration UK Business – sponsor licencing course November 24, 2026 9.30am - 11.30am (GMT) Virtual virtual UK employment law training December 01, 2026 1pm - 4pm (GMT) Virtual virtual Strategic Reflections on COP31 December 02, 2026 10am GMT | 11am CET Virtual, |