Multiple unfair relationship claims on single claim forms
England and Wales Court confirm that claims must be served and therefore issued and tried individually
October 18, 2023
Multiple unfair relationship claims on single claim formsEngland and Wales Court confirm that claims must be served and therefore issued and tried individuallyOctober 18, 2023 Why should I read this?HHJ Worster sitting in the Birmingham County Court has held that thousands of 'motor commission' claims made pursuant to section 140A of the Consumer Credit Act 1974 (CCA) and issued across eight claim forms against eight motor finance lenders, cannot proceed as presently constituted under CPR 7.3, and must be severed. Practically, this means that the claims must be individually issued and tried in the County Court. HHJ Worster also refused to order that the cases proceed by way of sample/lead cases. CPR 7.31 is increasingly seen as another route for bringing group litigation and this judgment provides further guidance on CPR 7.3 following the Divisional Court judgment in Abbots and ors v Ministry of Defence [2023], which was coincidentally handed down as HHJ Worster was finalising his decision in this case. In Abbott, the Divisional Court (overturning the lower court) allowed thousands of military noise deafness claims to proceed on one claim form2 because the claims had sufficient commonality of significant issues of fact, and that it would be useful or helpful, in the interests of justice, that the claims be disposed of in the same proceedings rather than in separate sets of proceedings. In this case, HHJ Worster took a different view and found that the claims did not have common issues of sufficient significance that they should not be tried in the same proceedings. One conclusion that can be drawn from both judgments is that whether or not CPR 7.3 is the correct procedure to bring group litigation will depend on the facts and circumstances of the claims, and early co-operation between the parties to try and agree the correct route for the case management of such claims is crucial. Further, unfair relationship claims under section 140 CCA are by their nature fact-specific, and multi-factorial, such that bringing multiple unfair relationship claims on one claim form via CPR 7.3 is unlikely to be appropriate. A previous judgment in the same claim marks a further success for the defendant lenders who succeeded in containing the proceedings to the County Court on the basis that the County Court has exclusive jurisdiction under the CCA. BackgroundThe underlying litigation relates to eight claims. The claimants in these eight claims purchased motor vehicles from car dealers and entered into credit agreements to finance their purchases. There are currently over 6,700 claimants, all represented by the same solicitors, Barings Law. The defendants are eight motor finance companies who entered into the credit agreements with the claimants. In some cases, the dealers introduced the relevant claimant to the relevant defendant. In other cases, there were credit intermediaries (finance brokers) who performed that role. Pursuant to CPR 7.3, all the claims against a particular defendant had been gathered together and made in one claim form, so that one claim covered multiple claimants. The claimants alleged that the relationship between the individual claimants and the defendants was unfair pursuant to section 140A CCA because of the failure to disclose the nature of commission arrangements between the dealer or intermediary and the relevant finance company (defendant). Following the issue of the eight claims in the Birmingham County Court, the claimants applied to transfer the proceedings to the Circuit Commercial Court in Birmingham (High Court) for directions and management of the claims as a whole. The defendants opposed that application on the basis that the High Court had no jurisdiction to hear unfair relationship claims under the CCA. In March 2023, HHJ Worster agreed that the County Court's jurisdiction to hear and determine such claims was indeed an exclusive one and therefore dismissed the claimants' application to transfer3. A second set of issues remained between the parties:
What did the court decide?The severance issue
The case management issue
CommentIn order to bring group litigation via CPR 7.3, claimants will need to be comfortable that the test of convenience can be met. Claimants (and their law firms) will be well advised to liaise with potential defendants before issuing claims to try to agree the procedure. Even then, it could be unravelled if the Court disagrees (although this may be less likely if the parties have agreed). Further, the judgment shows that due to the very specific and individual nature of unfair relationship claims, it will likely be difficult to bring multiple unfair relationship claims via CPR 7.3 in the future. As to sampling arrangements, the burden is on the claimant to propose a workable, proportionate and fair sampling regime sufficiently early on so that defendants can see from the start what is proposed and for any differences to be catered for. Ba rings Law were criticised in this case for not fully thinking through what was being proposed. HHJ Worster commented that "if litigation of this type and scale is to be manageable, it calls not only for cooperation between the parties, but for a particular level of efficiency from the solicitors prosecuting the claim" Note that the claimants applied to HHJ Worster for permission to appeal his decision and this has subsequently been granted. The appeal hearing is awaited. Eversheds Sutherland acted for the two lenders in this matter, who were the lead parties on successfully arguing in relation to the severance and case management issue
Key contacts
Latest Insights
Latest News
Latest Events
legal updates November 20, 2026 COP31: Enhancing Implementation - Revised draft seeks consensus amid compet... legal updates November 20, 2026 Implementation of the EU Pay Transparency Directive: New development in Spa... legal updates November 19, 2026 COP31: People and progress in focus as negotiations reach a critical stage legal updates November 19, 2026 Learning from experience | Mentoring for Alumni client news November 19, 2026 Eversheds Sutherland advises EDF on landmark UK energy retail acquisition deal alerts November 06, 2026 Eversheds Sutherland advises Mercedes-Benz on European fast-charging partne... firm news November 05, 2026 Eversheds Sutherland hires partner Peter Cheng to lead Hong Kong ECM practi... firm news October 27, 2026 Eversheds Sutherland (International) announces senior leadership appointmen... hybrid Europe Action Week 2026 Europe Action Week returns this November with a dynamic mix of events designed to help you navigate what’s next. virtual Immigration UK Business – sponsor licencing course November 24, 2026 9.30am - 11.30am (GMT) Virtual virtual UK employment law training December 01, 2026 1pm - 4pm (GMT) Virtual virtual Strategic Reflections on COP31 December 02, 2026 10am GMT | 11am CET Virtual, |