Non-material damages under data protection legislation - Recent guidance from the Circuit Court in Ireland
July 25, 2023
Non-material damages under data protection legislation - Recent guidance from the Circuit Court in IrelandJuly 25, 2023 On 11 July 2023 the Circuit Court delivered judgment in Kaminski v Ballymaguire Foods Limited[1] (“Kaminski”). This is the Irish Courts’ first written judgment considering non-material damages under Article 82 of the General Data Protection Regulation 2016/679 (the “GDPR”) and under section 117 of the Data Protection Act 2018 (the “2018 Act”). While Article 82 of the GDPR provides that an individual who suffers non-material damage as a result of infringement of the GDPR has the right to receive compensation from the controller or processor for the damage suffered, until now there has been an absence of Irish judicial precedent as to how non-material damages are determined. BackgroundThe plaintiff data subject was employed as a supervisor by the defendant food manufacturing company. As part of a meeting between the quality control manager and several of the defendant’s employees, various CCTV clips of the workplace were shown. The defendant submitted that the purpose of this meeting was to address instances of poor food safety practice and identify corrective actions. While the plaintiff was not present at the meeting, he was informed by another employee that he featured in one of the CCTV clips which was shown. The plaintiff issued proceedings under section 117 of the 2018 Act alleging that the further processing of his personal data, through CCTV footage of him being shown at the meeting, amounted to unlawful processing under the 2018 Act and the GDPR. As a result of the unlawful processing the plaintiff alleged that he suffered damage and distress in the form of anxiety and embarrassment following remarks made to him by his work colleagues. DecisionThe Court referred, in its judgment, to the recent Court of Justice of the European Union (the “CJEU”) decision in UI v Österreichische Post[2]. The CJEU held that there is no minimum threshold for damage suffered that a data subject must meet in order to be entitled to compensation for non-material damages under Article 82 of the GDPR. The CJEU also held that a right to compensation for non-material damage does not automatically arise from mere infringement of the GDPR. In Kaminski, the Court found that there was a lack of clarity and transparency in relation to the defendant’s data protection policies. Furthermore, the Court held that no legal basis regarding the processing of the plaintiff’s personal data for training purposes was initially identified by the defendant and it was only through legal submissions that the defendant claimed it was relying on legitimate interest as its legal basis. However, the Court noted that the defendant did not carry out a legitimate interest assessment to identify what the legitimate interest was and if the processing was necessary to achieve said interest. The Court was ultimately satisfied that:
In its judgment, the Court outlined (with caution, in the absence of clarification from the Superior Courts, the Oireachtas and outstanding preliminary references before the CJEU) a number of factors which should be considered when assessing non-material damages. The factors include the following:
Despite the absence of a medical report, the Court accepted that the plaintiff’s loss “went beyond mere upset and created an emotional experience and negative emotions of insecurity which did affect [the plaintiff] for a short period of time”. The Court awarded the plaintiff €2,000 in non-material damages. Commentary This judgment offers welcome guidance as to how non-material damages in data protection claims will be assessed by the Irish Courts. The level of damages payable in this case indicates that many such claims under section 117 of the 2018 Act will come within the jurisdiction of the District Court which, following the commencement of the Courts and Civil Law (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 2023, will have the jurisdiction to hear these data protection claims. This is further underscored by one of the factors in assessing damages for non-material loss proffered by the Circuit Court in Kaminski, namely that even where non-material can be proved is not trivial, “damages in may cases will probably be modest”. This is a significant and timely judgment, in circumstances where the Irish Courts have recently stayed[3] a number of other proceedings issued pursuant to section 117 of the 2018 Act, pending the determination of a number of preliminary references to the CJEU concerning Article 82 of the GDPR. No such stay was sought in the Kaminski case, nor was the Court requested to state a case to the Court of Appeal, which was noted by the Court. It is expected that these preliminary references will provide further guidance on the assessment of non-material damages in data protection claims. Our experienced data protection team would be happy to help you navigate this complex area. [1] Arkadiusz Kaminski v Ballymaguire Foods Limited [2023] IECC 5 [2] UI v Österreichische Post Case C-300/21 [3] Cunniam v Parcel Connect Limited trading as Fastway Couriers Ireland and Others [2023] IECC 1 For more information, please contact:Rosalyn English, Solicitor, IP, Tech & DP | RosalynEnglish@eversheds-sutherland.ie Key contacts
Latest Insights
Latest News
Latest Events
legal updates November 13, 2026 COP31: Leaders’ Summit | Resilient Cities and Built Environment legal updates November 12, 2026 COP31: Leaders’ Summit | Zero Waste - The business case for zero waste legal updates November 11, 2026 COP31: Energy and Transport – Electrification takes center stage in Antalya legal updates November 11, 2026 Algorithmic Management of Workforces: Is your business a “platform” without... deal alerts November 06, 2026 Eversheds Sutherland advises Mercedes-Benz on European fast-charging partne... firm news November 05, 2026 Eversheds Sutherland hires partner Peter Cheng to lead Hong Kong ECM practi... firm news October 27, 2026 Eversheds Sutherland (International) announces senior leadership appointmen... firm news October 26, 2026 Eversheds Sutherland deepens fintech and regulatory bench with double partn... hybrid Europe Action Week 2026 Europe Action Week returns this November with a dynamic mix of events designed to help you navigate what’s next. virtual Belgian employment law training November 17, 2026 2.00pm - 5.00pm (GMT) Virtual in-person Industrial relations masterclass November 18, 2026 9.30am - 4.30pm (GMT) London, United Kingdom virtual Immigration UK Business – sponsor licencing course November 24, 2026 9.30am - 11.30am (GMT) Virtual |