Permission to appeal and fresh evidence in the QFC Court
June 12, 2025
Permission to appeal and fresh evidence in the QFC CourtJune 12, 2025 The Qatar Financial Centre (QFC) Civil and Commercial Court emphasises the finality of first-instance decisions. Whilst appeals are possible, the path to the Appellate Division is narrow, governed by strict rules. This article examines recent developments in the Court’s approach to granting permission to appeal and admitting fresh evidence, drawing insights from the recent case of Devisers Advisory Services LLC v Farwin Farook Muhammed [2025] QIC (A) 2, which our firm undertook. The purpose is to clarify the practical application of these crucial procedural aspects for litigants. BackgroundThis case concerned a dispute over a QAR 37,500 fee paid to Devisers Advisory Services LLC (the ‘Applicant’) for visa consultancy services. When Devisers’ client could not proceed with the application, the Applicant sought to retain the full fee based on the agreement. The client counterclaimed for a refund but made an open offer allowing the Applicant to keep QAR 5,000 for work done. The First Instance Circuit, handling the matter as a Small Claim, applied Article 107 of the QFC Contract Regulations (dealing with excessive penalty clauses), following the precedent in Manan Jain v Devisers [2024] QIC (A) 2. Finding the full fee “grossly excessive,” the Court reduced the amount the Applicant could retain to QAR 5,000, noting the Applicant had not provided evidence at that stage to justify a higher sum. The Applicant then applied for permission to appeal to the QFC Appellate Division, arguing the First Instance Circuit had misapplied Article 107 by failing to properly assess the work done and the reasonableness of the fee. The Applicant also sought to introduce new evidence on appeal—an invoice for significant costs incurred—to support its position. The two-pronged test for permission to appealArticle 35.1 of the QFC Court’s Regulations and Procedural Rules (‘Rules’) establishes that first-instance judgements are typically final. Permission to appeal to the Appellate Division will only be granted if an applicant satisfies a stringent two-part test: a) there must be substantial grounds for considering that a judgement or decision is erroneous; and b) there must be a significant risk that the alleged error will result in serious injustice. Both conditions must be met for permission to be granted (Devisers at 11). This high bar serves the administration of justice by filtering out appeals lacking reasonable prospects of success, thereby saving parties time and costs (Al Tamra Holding Group v Pinsent Masons LLP [2018] QIC (A) 1; Hammad Shawabkeh v Daman Health Insurance Qatar LLC [2017] QIC (A) 1). First limb: Substantial grounds for considering the judgement erroneous The first limb typically requires the appellant to demonstrate either an “arguable case” that the lower court made a specific error (Taha Babiker and another v Al Mal Bank LLC [2011] QIC (A) 1), or that the appeal raises “arguable issues of general importance” (Chedid & Associates Qatar LLC v Said Bou Ayash [2015] QIC (A) 2). An “arguable case” typically means showing a plausible argument that the first instance court misapplied the law or breached procedural fairness. It focuses on errors specific to the judgement under appeal. “Arguable issues of general importance”, as discussed in Chedid, allows for appeals even if a specific error is not immediately obvious, provided the case raises a point of law or principle that requires clarification for the benefit of future cases or the wider public interest. In Devisers v Farwin, the Appellate Division found that the first limb was not satisfied. The Court reasoned that the Applicant had the opportunity at first instance to present evidence justifying why it should retain more than QAR 5,000 if Article 107 were applied, but chose not to do so. Since the Applicant failed to put forward evidence supporting a different calculation, the First Instance Circuit was entitled to proceed based on the available information, which included the respondent’s offer of QAR 5,000. Therefore, the Court concluded there were no substantial grounds to consider the judgement erroneous based on the evidence actually presented at first instance. Second limb: Significant risk of serious injustice Even if an arguable error (the first limb) is identified, permission may still be refused if the second limb—significant risk of serious injustice—is not met. The Court has previously indicated that if the amount at stake is very small, it may be incapable of constituting “serious injustice” (Chedid). This principle carries particular weight for cases assigned to the Small Claims Track. The Appellate Division emphasises maintaining the objectives of fair, speedy and cost-effective justice within this track (Klaas Bouwman v Kofler Group Middle East LLC [2024] QIC (A) 1). Appeals in small claims are scrutinised carefully to ensure they are not simply tactics to delay payment or impose disproportionate costs on the respondent (Hadi Jaloul v Experts Credit Solutions Consultancy LLC [2023] QIC (A) 13; Sandy Beach Refreshments Cafeteria LLC v AHK Enterprise LLC [2024] QIC (A) 8). In Devisers v Farwin, the Appellate Division applied this reasoning rigorously. The sum in dispute (QAR 32,500) was noted as being “towards the lower end of the Small Claims Track”. The Applicant argued that a serious injustice existed because the first-instance erroneous decision might be relied upon by other clients in future. The Court rejected this argument, and held that the first-instance decision merely applied the established principles from Jain regarding Article 107 to the specific facts as presented. The ruling did not prevent the Applicant from arguing the specifics of work performed and presenting relevant evidence in any future cases. Each case would turn on its own facts and evidence. The Devisers ruling clarifies that the “serious injustice” must relate to the specific impact of the judgement in the case at hand, particularly in the context of small claims. Potential, speculative impacts on hypothetical future litigation involving different facts do not meet this high threshold. Admitting fresh evidence on appeal: an exceptional matterAppeals in the QFC Court are generally reviews, not re-hearings. Consequently, the admission of evidence not presented at first instance is heavily restricted and permitted only in “special circumstances” (Aarnout Henri Nicolaes Wennekers v Qatar Free Zones Authority [2024] QIC (A) 7). Parties must provide compelling reasons and a strong explanation for the failure to adduce the evidence earlier (Devisers Advisory Services LLC v Muhammad Zahid [2023] QIC (A) 11). The Devisers v Farwin case provides an illustration of this strict approach. The Applicant sought to introduce an invoice for costs incurred, arguing that as a self-represented litigant at first instance, it had not fully grasped the legal importance or the implication of presenting this specific evidence before ethe lower court. The Appellate Division rejected this argument, and highlighted that the Applicant was an experienced litigant, familiar with court proceedings (including being the appellant in the related Jain case). It held that the Applicant was sufficiently experienced to understand what evidence was required or should have sought legal advice if unsure. The Court concluded that being a litigant-in-person, particularly an experienced one, did not automatically constitute a “special circumstance” or a “good reason” justifying the failure to present relevant evidence at the appropriate time. This strict stance contrasts with rare cases such as Daruna For Real Estate Brokerage Co LLC and another v Lesha Bank LLC [2023] QIC (A) 4 [5]. There, fresh evidence was admitted, but under specific circumstances involving non-disclosure by the opposing party, and where the documents merely clarified undisputed background facts without contradicting prior evidence or undermining the trial process. The Court stressed even then that admitting fresh evidence is only for “rare circumstances”. Whilst Devisers reinforces the high bar, the precise boundaries of “special circumstances” remain defined on a case-by-case basis. The Court has not provided an exhaustive list of qualifying situations. Questions may still arise regarding, for instance, evidence that genuinely could not have been obtained with reasonable diligence before the trial concluded, or situations involving fraud or misrepresentation discovered post-judgement. How the Court will assess the “compelling” nature of explanations in novel factual scenarios remains an area for potential future development in its jurisprudence. Key takeaways for litigantsThe decision in Devisers v Farwin reinforces several critical points for parties litigating in the QFC Court:
ConclusionThe QFC Court maintains a high threshold for granting permission to appeal, prioritising finality and efficiency. The Devisers v Farwin ruling underscores the critical importance of presenting all evidence at first instance and clarifies the application of the ‘serious injustice’ test, especially in small claims. It also reinforces the very limited scope for introducing fresh evidence on appeal, reminding litigants to prepare their cases thoroughly from the outset. Latest Insights
Latest News
Latest Events
legal updates November 19, 2026 Learning from experience | Mentoring for Alumni legal updates November 19, 2026 COP31: People and progress in focus as negotiations reach a critical stage legal updates November 18, 2026 The EU Pharma Package: Key Reforms for Pharmaceutical Companies legal updates November 18, 2026 COP31: Oceans, nature and land use gain ground in climate policy and inves... client news November 19, 2026 Eversheds Sutherland advises EDF on landmark UK energy retail acquisition deal alerts November 06, 2026 Eversheds Sutherland advises Mercedes-Benz on European fast-charging partne... firm news November 05, 2026 Eversheds Sutherland hires partner Peter Cheng to lead Hong Kong ECM practi... firm news October 27, 2026 Eversheds Sutherland (International) announces senior leadership appointmen... hybrid Europe Action Week 2026 Europe Action Week returns this November with a dynamic mix of events designed to help you navigate what’s next. virtual Immigration UK Business – sponsor licencing course November 24, 2026 9.30am - 11.30am (GMT) Virtual virtual UK employment law training December 01, 2026 1pm - 4pm (GMT) Virtual virtual Strategic Reflections on COP31 December 02, 2026 10am GMT | 11am CET Virtual, |