Remuneration disadvantage - no adjustment to the best-paid colleague
Baden-Württemberg Regional Labour Court (LAG) of 1 October 2024 - 2 Sa 14/24
November 21, 2024
Remuneration disadvantage - no adjustment to the best-paid colleagueBaden-Württemberg Regional Labour Court (LAG) of 1 October 2024 - 2 Sa 14/24November 21, 2024 If there is unequal pay between women and men, employers must demonstrate and prove that this was exclusively due to reasons other than gender. If gender-based discrimination is established, the claim for payment of the pay difference is primarily based on the average pay (median pay) of the comparison group of the other gender. This does not apply if there is a concrete presumption of discrimination against a specific employee. Facts of the caseThe female employee, who had worked for the employer for almost 30 years, claimed higher remuneration on the grounds of equal pay in accordance with the German Transparency in Remuneration Act (EntgTranspG) and the General Equal Treatment Act (AGG). More than 15 years ago, she was promoted to head of department (third management level of the company). She returned from parental leave to work part-time. Since then, she has been paid less than her male colleagues at the same level. Her salary was both below the median salary of the female peer group and significantly below the median salary of the male peer group. She primarily claimed the difference between her individual remuneration and the remuneration of a male comparator colleague named by her - who was the highest paid - and alternatively claimed the difference between her individual remuneration and the median remuneration of the male comparator group. The female employee therefore demanded an additional payment for the past five years totalling 420,000 euros. The employee claimed unequal treatment due to her gender. However, she was unable to substantiate unequal treatment in relation to the male colleague she named. The decisionThe Baden-Württemberg Higher Labour Court also essentially agreed with the lower court and awarded the female employee a claim to a difference in pay - but only to the amount of the median pay of the male peer group. The court took from Art. 157 TFEU and Sections 3 (1), 7 EntgTranspG that not just any indication within the meaning of Section 22 AGG of gender-based pay discrimination is sufficient to justify a claim for the maximum conceivable difference - in this case to the best-paid male colleague. Rather, it demanded concrete evidence of gender-based discrimination in relation to the remuneration primarily claimed by the male colleague named. The special feature of the case was that the salary of the colleague used for comparison was significantly higher than the median salary of the male peer group. At the same time, the female employee also received less pay than the specific median pay of the female peer group. Therefore, the LAG found that there was no sufficient connection between the gender-based disadvantage and the named male colleague. Consequences for practiceIf a difference in pay has been established on the basis of an employee's right to information, employers are faced with a high burden of presentation and proof to explain the difference in pay by objective, gender-independent factors. The objective criteria put forward must be based on a legitimate objective and be suitable and necessary. In the specific case, only the amount of the pay difference was still in dispute. The appeal to the BAG was authorised due to its fundamental importance. It has therefore not yet been legally clarified whether the amount of the pay difference is actually based on the median pay of the male peer group. It therefore remains to be seen what position the BAG will take on this. Practical tipParticularly in view of the Pay Transparency Directive to be implemented by the German legislator, employers should review their salary structures at an early stage and pay equal pay for equal work and work of equal value - regardless of gender. If there are objective criteria against equal pay, detailed documentation is still recommended. Care should also be taken to ensure that the weighting of the objective criteria is sufficiently taken into account. In the case of performance-related criteria, on the other hand, other salary components - such as performance-related remuneration - should be used. Gender-neutral - purely performance-related - remuneration can be achieved through target agreements. Latest Insights
Latest News
Latest Events
legal updates November 13, 2026 COP31: Leaders’ Summit | Resilient Cities and Built Environment legal updates November 12, 2026 COP31: Leaders’ Summit | Zero Waste - The business case for zero waste legal updates November 11, 2026 COP31: Energy and Transport – Electrification takes center stage in Antalya legal updates November 11, 2026 Algorithmic Management of Workforces: Is your business a “platform” without... deal alerts November 06, 2026 Eversheds Sutherland advises Mercedes-Benz on European fast-charging partne... firm news November 05, 2026 Eversheds Sutherland hires partner Peter Cheng to lead Hong Kong ECM practi... firm news October 27, 2026 Eversheds Sutherland (International) announces senior leadership appointmen... firm news October 26, 2026 Eversheds Sutherland deepens fintech and regulatory bench with double partn... hybrid Europe Action Week 2026 Europe Action Week returns this November with a dynamic mix of events designed to help you navigate what’s next. virtual Belgian employment law training November 17, 2026 2.00pm - 5.00pm (GMT) Virtual in-person Industrial relations masterclass November 18, 2026 9.30am - 4.30pm (GMT) London, United Kingdom virtual Immigration UK Business – sponsor licencing course November 24, 2026 9.30am - 11.30am (GMT) Virtual |