Securing the First Indemnity Costs Award in the QFC Court
October 27, 2025
Securing the First Indemnity Costs Award in the QFC CourtOctober 27, 2025 In a landmark decision, and for the first time in the Qatar Financial Centre (“QFC”) Civil and Commercial Court’s (“Court”) 16-year history, Eversheds Sutherland has successfully secured a costs award which was assessed on an indemnity basis. IntroductionThe judgment, delivered on 19 October 2025, underscores the Court’s readiness to impose enhanced costs where litigants engage in unreasonable or abusive conduct, signalling a significant development in the Court’s approach. This article will provide an overview of the proceedings, the Court’s reasoning for awarding indemnity costs, and the broader implications of this landmark judgment for future litigation before the QFC Court. BackgroundThe dispute arose from an employment claim in Sami Mahgoub Mohammed Moustafa v Sharq Insurance LLC [2025] QIC (C) 9, brought before the Court. The Claimant advanced multiple claims seeking substantial monetary compensation, alleging contractual and employment-related breaches. On behalf of the Defendant, Eversheds Sutherland prepared a comprehensive defence addressing the full scope of the Claimant’s allegations. Importantly, prior to the evidential hearing, the Defendant—through Eversheds Sutherland—made a ‘drop-hands’ settlement offer proposing payment of a small amount in respect of travel-related entitlements. This amount corresponded to the only uncontested aspect of the dispute. The Claimant, however, failed to respond or engage with the offer, electing instead to proceed to trial. Following detailed written submissions and a full hearing before the First Instance Circuit, the Court, on 24 December 2024, found that the Claimant’s allegations were largely unsubstantiated and unsupported by evidence, and awarded only the precise sum offered by the Defendant in its settlement offer. The Claimant subsequently applied for permission to appeal, advancing 23 grounds of appeal that included allegations of judicial bias, unfairness, and procedural error against both the First Instance Circuit and the Defendant. On 1 June 2025, the Appellate Division refused permission to appeal, describing the application as “without merit.” The Appellate Court noted that the Claimant had failed to identify any error of law or fact and that the claim had no prospects of success as it was unsupported by any admissible evidence. Following the dismissal of the appeal, Eversheds Sutherland initiated a costs assessment application before the Registrar seeking recovery of the Defendant’s legal costs incurred at both the first instance and appellate stages. The Claimant did not fully participate in the cost assessment process. After reviewing the matter, the Registrar determined that the Defendant had acted reasonably and professionally throughout the proceedings, whereas the Claimant’s conduct—including the rejection of a fair settlement offer, the hopeless pursuit of meritless claims, and the abuse of the Court’s process through unfounded allegations—had unreasonably prolonged the litigation. Consequently, on 19 October 2025, the Registrar ordered the unsuccessful party to pay the opposing party’s legal costs on the indemnity basis. The Court's JudgmentIn determining the appropriate basis for awarding costs, the Registrar relied on his earlier reasoning in Bank Audi LLC v Al Fardan Investment Company LLC [2023] QIC (C) 4, where he analysed the English Civil Procedure Rules and the commentary in Cook on Costs. In that decision, the Registrar had explained that while the QFC Regulations do not explicitly distinguish between ‘standard’ and ‘indemnity’ costs, the Court retains a broad discretion under Article 34 to make such order “as it thinks fit.” Drawing on English principles, the Registrar in Bank Audi noted that indemnity costs may be appropriate where a party’s conduct demonstrates culpability or abuse of process; for example, by unreasonably rejecting a settlement offer, pursuing a hopeless claim, or making unfounded allegations. The Registrar reaffirmed and applied those principles in the present case, holding that the Claimant’s conduct justified an order for costs on the indemnity basis for two distinct reasons. Second, the Registrar found that the Claimant’s case was “hopeless” and “completely unfounded”. The Court of First Instance had already described the claims in those terms, and the Registrar observed that the Claimant: “held himself throughout as a lawyer and therefore had no excuse to conduct the case in this fashion”. He cited Wates Construction Ltd v HGP Greentree Allchurch Evans Ltd [2005] EWHC 2174 (TCC), as quoted in Bank Audi, to describe this as the “continued pursuit of a hopeless claim”. The Registrar further held that the Claimant’s conduct during the appellate proceedings resulted in the abuse of process. The application for permission to appeal, which raised 23 grounds, included numerous accusations against the First Instance Circuit, such as calling its judgment “an insult to fair adjudication” and “morally indefensible”. The Registrar described these allegations as “outrageous and scurrilous”, noting they were made without evidence and constituted “an affront to the integrity of the judicial process”. The Appellate Division had already characterised the appeal as “without merit”, and the Registrar concluded that such conduct amounted to significantly unreasonable behaviour and abuse of the Court’s process. Having reviewed these factors, the Registrar determined that indemnity costs were appropriate for both the first-instance and appellate proceedings. The order was intended to reflect the Court’s disapproval of the Claimant’s conduct, deter similar behaviour, and reinforce the QFC Court’s commitment to maintaining high standards of procedural fairness and professionalism. Key TakeawaysThis case marks a significant development in the QFC Court’s costs jurisprudence, establishing that litigants who engage in unreasonable conduct, reject fair settlement opportunities, or continue to pursue meritless claims may face indemnity costs orders. Going forward, practitioners should approach dispute resolution within the QFC with heightened emphasis on settlement strategy, procedural integrity, and cost management, recognising that the Court expects—and will enforce—the highest standards of litigation conduct. In practical terms, parties should ensure that all settlement communications are timely, well-documented, and proportionate to the issues in dispute, as the Court may later examine such offers when determining costs. Counsel should also consider making early and reasonable offers to narrow or resolve issues, as doing so may significantly mitigate cost exposure. Latest Insights
Latest News
Latest Events
legal updates November 18, 2026 COP31: Oceans, nature and land use gain ground in climate policy and inves... legal updates November 18, 2026 Legal Telescope: The business of digital content – managing risk, trust and... legal updates November 18, 2026 The EU Pharma Package: Key Reforms for Pharmaceutical Companies legal updates November 17, 2026 Mandatory human rights due diligence is coming to the UK deal alerts November 06, 2026 Eversheds Sutherland advises Mercedes-Benz on European fast-charging partne... firm news November 05, 2026 Eversheds Sutherland hires partner Peter Cheng to lead Hong Kong ECM practi... firm news October 27, 2026 Eversheds Sutherland (International) announces senior leadership appointmen... firm news October 26, 2026 Eversheds Sutherland deepens fintech and regulatory bench with double partn... hybrid Europe Action Week 2026 Europe Action Week returns this November with a dynamic mix of events designed to help you navigate what’s next. virtual Immigration UK Business – sponsor licencing course November 24, 2026 9.30am - 11.30am (GMT) Virtual virtual UK employment law training December 01, 2026 1pm - 4pm (GMT) Virtual virtual Strategic Reflections on COP31 December 02, 2026 10am GMT | 11am CET Virtual, |