Introduction
The Tenth Circuit recently affirmed the Tax Court’s denial of Liberty Global Inc.’s $240 million foreign tax credit (FTC) claim stemming from the recapture of an overall foreign loss (OFL) triggered by the $3.9 billion sale of its Japanese controlled foreign corporation (CFC), Jupiter Telecommunications (J:COM).1 The decision reinforces the limitations on the availability of foreign tax credits and clarifies that taxpayers cannot expand creditability beyond the strict confines of the statutory sourcing rules.
Background on OFL Recapture Provisions
The provision in dispute, section 904(f)(3)(A)(i), provides that it applies “notwithstanding any other provision of this chapter” and requires re-sourcing of income recognized “by reason of such disposition.” The regulation provides that “such gain will be treated as foreign source income subject to the same limitation as the income the property generated.”
The Dispute
Liberty Global, a Denver-based multinational, sold its controlling stake in its Japanese CFC, J:COM, in 2010, generating a gain of approximately $3.25 billion. Because Liberty Global had an OFL account of $474M, both parties agreed that the re-sourcing rule of section 904(f)(3) was triggered by the CFC stock sale, and that section 904(f)(3)(A) recaptured the OFL through the recognition of an equal amount of gain ($474M) and treated that amount as foreign source income (FSI).
The parties disagreed as to whether section 904(f)(3) also required the remainder of the CFC sale gain to be recharacterized as FSI. Liberty Global sought to use the re-sourcing rule with respect to the remainder of the gain to support a $240 million FTC.
The IRS disagreed, asserting that only the amount needed to offset the OFL account could be re-sourced under section 904(f)(3). The remainder defaulted to the general sourcing rule under section 865(a), which treats gains from stock sales by US corporations as US-sourced.
The Tax Court held for the government, reasoning that section 904(f)(3) does not address gain other than the gain re-sourced to recapture the OFL. The court determined that section 904(f)(3) did not address the remainder of the gain, that there was no conflict between section 904 and section 865 with respect to that portion of the gain. The Tax Court also rejected Liberty Global’s argument that the regulations addressed the remainder of the gain, holding that the regulations were silent with respect to the amount of gain to be re-sourced and also, in context, did not address the treatment of the remainder of the gain. Liberty Global appealed to the Tenth Circuit.
The Tenth Circuit Decision
As it had before the Tax Court, Liberty Global argued that the text of section 904(f)(3), which provides that it applies “notwithstanding any other provision” displaced the general sourcing rules if section 904 was triggered, and that the Treasury regulations contained broad language and could be read to require re-sourcing the entire gain.
Writing for a unanimous panel, Judge Timothy Tymkovich rejected Liberty Global’s arguments, emphasizing that a “notwithstanding” clause operates only in the event of a conflict. Because section 904(f) applies only to OFL recapture and is silent on gains in excess of the OFL recapture amount, there is no conflict with section 865(a), and the general sourcing rule applies to the excess gains.
The court also disagreed with Liberty Global’s reliance on the broadly written language of the regulations. Reading the regulation in harmony with the statute, the panel held that the regulations applied only to the extent specified in section 904(f)(3), namely, the amount equal to the OFL balance. Any broader interpretation would improperly expand the statute.
Eversheds Sutherland Observation
The Tenth Circuit’s decision confirms that only the portion of gain equal to a taxpayer’s overall foreign loss balance may be re-sourced as FSI. Excess gain defaults to the general rule of section 865(a) and is US-sourced. This result limits taxpayers’ opportunities to expand the foreign tax credit base through dispositions of foreign affiliates.
The ruling also highlights statutory and regulatory interpretation applying the larger context of the statute rather than focusing solely on the text of a particular sub-section. Interpretations of statutory or regulatory text that may be inconsistent with the context and purpose of the larger provision are an uphill battle. |
__________
If you have any questions about this Legal Briefing, please feel free to contact any of the attorneys listed or the Eversheds Sutherland attorney with whom you regularly work.
1 Liberty Global, Inc. v. Commissioner, No. 24-9004 (10th Cir. Aug. 22, 2025).