Why should I read this?
Earlier this year, the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) conducted a detailed survey of over 1,000 London Market insurers, London Market intermediaries, wholesale banks and brokers to better understand how they record and manage allegations of non-financial misconduct (NFM) such as bullying, sexual harassment and discrimination.
The FCA has now published its survey findings and suggested actions for all regulated financial services (FS) firms.
Ahead of a long-awaited FCA policy statement on NFM due to be published towards the end of 2024, FS firms should use these findings to benchmark whether their own internal processes for reporting and investigating allegations of NFM are suitably robust. In this article we take a closer look at the survey findings and analyse their implications, as well as actions firms may want to consider.
Reported NFM incidents
The survey asked firms to report all NFM-related incidents occurring in 2021, 2022 and 2023, and the most recent or final disciplinary or other outcome for each incident. ‘Incidents’ included both alleged and confirmed occurrences of NFM, whether or not already reported, or meeting the FCA reporting threshold.
Between 2021 and 2023, the FCA found that incidents of NFM increased by 1000 from 1,363 to 2,347 across the firms surveyed, with the increase from 2021-2022 making up roughly a third of those, and two-thirds from 2022-2023. This could be viewed as positive, because firms have improved their “speak up” culture and sent clear messages about unacceptable behaviour or negative because incidents of NFM are simply on the rise.
The results were also broken down into the subsectors surveyed (“subsectors”) e.g. London Market Insurers. The levels of different types of NFM naturally differed between subsectors.
Key findings and comments:
- of the firms surveyed, the results showed that a very high proportion of smaller firms (0 to 49 employees) reported no NFM incidents during 2021, 2022 or 2023. This is surprising; whilst it could indicate a better, more inclusive culture in smaller firms, it may be more likely to indicate a lack of internal HR/compliance resource – or perhaps a less mature “speak up” culture
- bullying and harassment (26%) and discrimination (23%) were the most reported types of NFM incident across all subsectors. Taken together they made up between roughly 30-50% of incidents depending on the subsectors
- this was followed to a lesser degree by sexual harassment incidents with a range of 6-16%. Violence or intimidation, and possession or use of illegal drugs incidents were far less common
- 41% of NFM incidents were reported in an “other” category. According to firms’ responses, this included misuse of alcohol (sometimes contributing to poor conduct or inappropriate behaviour); inappropriate/offensive language/communication style (both within firms and to third parties); data or IT security breaches e.g. inappropriate sharing/misuse of confidential information; retaliatory behaviour when allegations had been made against employees; and conduct breaches or breaches of policies and procedures (including misuse of expenses/gifts/hospitality)
Considerations for firms:
- small regulated firms should consider their policies and procedures to ensure that staff feel confident to recognise and speak up about NFM
- firms should assess whether they would have a similarly high proportion of bullying, discrimination and sexual harassment incidents as the survey evidences. If so, consider what further work should be done in this area (see further below regarding the new legal duty to prevent sexual harassment)
- firms will need to develop a clear and consistent view of NFM to enable them to identify and respond to incidents that may fall within the “other” category appropriately, whilst retaining flexible policies and procedures to encompass incidents that do not neatly fall into a particular category
How firms detect NFM
This was divided into grievances “or other formal processes for escalation”; formal whistleblowing; market surveillance tools (e.g. monitoring email or telephone); and “other” which firms reported as consisting of third parties witnessing misconduct; informal concerns raised with HR, line managers or compliance functions; and a proactive approach from line managers.
Key findings and comments:
- across all subsectors more than half of incidents were detected through grievances “or other formal processes for escalation”
- a very small proportion were raised through whistleblowing channels – although this was significantly higher in wholesale banks (32%).
- later on in the survey, it was noted that a small proportion of firms did not even report having whistleblowing policies in place. SYSC 18.3.1of the FCA Handbook requires firms to establish, implement and maintain appropriate and effective arrangements for the disclosure of reportable concerns by whistleblowers
- surveillance methods were 1-10% depending on the subsector
Considerations for firms:
- firms should review whether their whistleblowing policies and procedures are sufficiently easy to use, trustworthy and designed to ensure the safe handling of concerns and prevention of victimisation. Are whistleblowers enabled and encouraged to speak up about NFM complaints, having confidence that their allegations will be kept confidential and investigated appropriately?
- firms should also ensure that staff are being properly trained on the firm’s whistleblowing arrangements and that it covers all requirements under SYSC 18.3.4
- the above is of course dependent on firms having whistleblowing policies and procedures in the first place. A breach of this requirement could lead to FCA intervention, including investigation/enforcement action
- grievances are reactionary, and firms should look at how they can be more proactive in detecting NFM in other ways, such as promoting the detection methods firms identified in the “other” category and through the use of engagement and conduct audits
- The Equality and Human Rights (EHRC) Technical Guidance covering harassment generally and the new proactive duty on all employers to prevent the sexual harassment of their employees in the course of their employment (which came into force on 26 October 2024), along with its 8-step guide for preventing sexual harassment at work, are particularly helpful resources. Employers will already have to use them to determine their strategies for complying with the new preventative duty, but the proactive approaches suggested in them could be equally applicable to detecting other types of NFM
- EHRC examples include risk assessments, anonymous surveys, keeping records (whether concerns are raised formally or informally) and includes what to do if an employee wants to keep the matter confidential, how to spot warning signs beyond formal and informal complaints, how to give staff every opportunity to raise issues in a variety of situations and training that should be provided to managers (and wider staff) to enable proactive detection & reporting
Outcomes
Outcomes of NFM incidents included where disciplinary or other action was taken (ranging from dismissal, written warning, verbal warning to “other” such as D&I training or coaching), or where a decision was awaited or no action taken was taken. The findings were split by subsectors and also analysed further to exclude complaints not upheld.
Key findings and comments:
- 62% of reported discrimination incidents and 47% of reported bullying and harassment incidents between 2021 and 2023 were not upheld. Bearing in mind these categories were the most reported type of NFM, this may appear disproportionately high
- disciplinary or other action was taken in 64% of sexual harassment incidents and 22% of upheld sexual harassment complaints led to dismissal. More appear to have been dealt with by verbal warnings or “other” outcomes, such as training. This is perhaps not surprising in an industry where a written warning would have regulatory consequences, but potentially reveals the dilemmas firms face in balancing what can be perceived as “career ending” written warnings (that would be reportable) against the seriousness of the conduct and appropriate outcome
- dismissal was most likely for incidents of possession or use of illegal drugs, and violence and intimidation (21% each) as well as sexual harassment – reflecting the more clear cut actions firms can take in relation to the first two categories
- a much higher proportion of discrimination or bullying and harassment claims were dealt with by “other” actions, including training. The fact that this was a highly used outcome raises the question as to whether staff are adequately educated and trained on discrimination or bullying and harassment in the first place
Considerations for firms:
- with respect to the disparities between complaints not upheld (discrimination; bullying and harassment) and the rates of disciplinary action and dismissals for the other categories mentioned, the FCA wants the industry to reflect on whether they are explainable
- firms should review whether their training on discrimination and harassment is fit for purpose, properly undertaken and understood. Online training should ensure that it is tailored to the type of staff, that shortcuts cannot be taken, that understanding is assessed, and that it is reinforced by messaging and conduct from managers and the board. This is of paramount importance as firms implement “reasonable steps” to prevent the sexual harassment of their employees (to become “all reasonable steps” under the Employment Rights Bill, which also makes new provisions for employers to prevent harassment by third parties)
- firms should consider whether they are handling reported NFM incidents appropriately. Do those who investigate and make decisions on NFM complaints have appropriate training and support? In particular firms should consider whether the sanction being applied when NFM is upheld is appropriate in light of the conduct. The FCA is likely to take a dim view of issuing a verbal warning to avoid reporting when serious conduct has occurred
- firms need to consider whether their managers are adequately equipped to recognise and respond to reports of NFM. Under current draft proposals for NFM rules, a manager’s failure to protect staff from NFM, or take seriously/deal effectively with complaints of NFM, could amount to a breach of Individual Conduct Rule 2, which requires Conduct Rules staff to act with due skill, care and diligence. It is unclear whether the FCA’s policy statement will retain this wording, but it is clear that managers need to be supported in how to recognise and deal with NFM appropriately
“Further” outcomes
This section encompassed the use of settlement agreements and confidentiality agreements (often referred to as NDAs), as well as remuneration adjustments.
Key findings and comments:
- whilst the number of settlement agreements with complainants of NFM fell between 2021 (126) and 2023 (101), some incidences are still awaiting a decision, so it is unlikely that this represents a significant downward trend, particularly with the increased number of agreements concluded in 2022 (134). By contrast, the number of settlement agreements signed by the subject of a complaint (i.e. the alleged perpetrator) were 44, 54, and 47 respectively. The majority of these were incidents involving sexual harassment. This may be a good sign in that it shows that firms do not view settlement agreements to be appropriate in those circumstances, as it would potentially be rewarding misconduct to provide severance terms. This survey result could also be viewed as being reflective evidence from the Sexism in the City Inquiry that often it is the complainants of NFM who are the ones who leave employment. However, often it is simply the case that complainants of serious NFM ask to leave their employer on agreed severance terms, and the settlement agreement is the appropriate response to support that employee. With that in mind, it will be interesting to see if this trend changes with the introduction of NFM rules
- there is a noticeable downward trend of confidentiality agreements – 87, 73, and 51 in 2021, 2022 and 2023. This suggests that some firms misunderstood that confidentiality agreements that were part of a settlement agreement (as is often the case) should be included in this response. However, this could also show that the Solicitor’s Regulation Authority Warning Notice on the use of NDAs is being taken more seriously as time goes by. Confidentiality agreements are commonly used in settlement agreements to protect confidential information, but the SRA have most recently emphasised that they should not be used routinely. In addition they should not attempt to prevent the disclosure of misconduct or breaches of regulatory requirements to regulators, or prevent whistleblowing protected by law
- in all sectors, action taken following non-financial misconduct rarely resulted in remuneration adjustment. When remuneration was adjusted it was mostly against unvested variable pay
Considerations for firms:
- firms need to remember the requirement in SYSC 18.5.1R that settlement agreements must include a term making clear that nothing prevents an employee from making a protected disclosure
- the Solicitor’s Regulation Authority Warning Notice was updated in August 2024 to make it much clearer that lawyers should consider each case individually when drafting settlement agreements and/or NDAs, and should only include NDAs where necessary (and include the other carve-outs already specified in the Notice)
- the FCA and PRA regard NFM as a risk. Firms should consider their obligations under any applicable remuneration code (or their own remuneration policies) to consider whether it is appropriate to make more use of remuneration adjustments where NFM allegations are upheld. Under the FCA’s remuneration codes, firms must have remuneration policies and practices that are consistent with, and promote, sound and effective risk management
Governance
The survey requested information on firms’ governance structures and Management Information (MI) relating to NFM.
Key findings and comments:
- 38% of respondents stated that a board or a board level committee did not receive MI about NFM
- 33% stated that they have no formal governance structure or committee that decides the outcomes and disciplinary actions for those involved in NFM cases.
Considerations for firms:
- firms should reflect on the FCA’s comment that while it expects firms to take a proportionate approach, it considers that “the responses to questions about board MI and governance structures suggest that large firms’ governance and oversight of non-financial misconduct could be falling short of [the FCA’s] expectations for the size, nature and complexity of the firms’ businesses”
- recent cases within and outside the FS sector show that allegations of NFM can pose a major risk to organisations. The FCA states that (aligning with its statutory objectives) it is prioritising work on non-financial misconduct and promoting healthy cultures to improve outcomes for markets and consumers and reduce harm. It also notes that firms may gain a competitive advantage through improved governance and MI
- as such, firms should be identifying, managing and monitoring NFM within their risk management frameworks
Regulatory References
This section covered findings on including NFM in references, updating regulatory references, and using NFM information in relation to fitness and propriety (FIT) assessments.
Key findings and comments:
- 92% of respondents said they would include incidents of NFM in a regulatory reference (should the situation arise). This was backed up in the survey by a steady increase of firms including information relating to NFM in regulatory references in 2021 (16), 2022 (21) and 2023 (43). The wholesale market may have taken note of the warning given in June 2023 about taking regulatory referencing far more seriously both in relation to providing references and when hiring new recruits
- 87% said they would update a regulatory reference following an NFM incident
- the number of individuals being hired where an incident of non-financial misconduct was included on the regulatory reference halved, across all subsectors, from 10 in 2021 to 5 in 2023
- across all sectors, between 2021 and 2023, a total of 93 individuals had their FIT assessment amended because of an NFM-related incident that either took place in the workplace (or in the course of the firm’s activities) or was unrelated to the workplace
Considerations for firms:
- firms should consider whether their approach to dealing with NFM when providing and updating regulatory references meets the FCA’s expectations
- firms should also consider how they respond to incidents of NFM in a regulatory reference when hiring new staff
- both of these, along with FIT assessments will need to be considered in the light of the expected policy statement on NFM. In oral evidence to the Treasury Committee the FCA has made it clear that their proposals, following these findings, will seek to make clear that NFM information relevant to fitness and propriety should be disclosed in regulatory references
- when dealing with regulatory references, consistency of approach towards individuals is essential. Firms may want to consider drafting standard wording to attach to regulatory reference requests setting out the requesting firm’s approach to NFM where there are currently grey areas
Next steps for FS firms on non-financial misconduct
The FCA comments that the results should be “a catalyst for regulated firms’ boards and trade associations to prioritise and act on issues of non-financial misconduct that lead to poor working cultures and can ultimately harm consumers or market integrity”.
It says:
“Following this publication, we expect firms to reflect on the data and consider how their own performance compares with their peers. We want firms to discuss non-financial misconduct at senior management and board level and consider whether they need to take steps to improve their culture; how they identify and manage risks; how they address non-financial misconduct on an ongoing basis.”
It notes this should encourage the sharing of good practice through trade associations forums. Whilst this approach has been criticised by some as leaving too much responsibility to firms and trade bodies, consistency of approach in relation to NFM between – as well as within – firms is an important goal, and potentially those at the coalface may be the ones best placed to try to achieve this.
FS firms should not wait for the NFM policy statement to audit their own NFM incidents and consider what needs to be reviewed and changed. The legal duty to prevent the sexual harassment of employees is already in force, and preparations and strategies for that should be addressed together with preparation for rules on NFM.
The new duty regarding sexual harassment puts the onus firmly on the employer to show that it has actually taken reasonable preventative steps. Such steps must be taken even if no issues have been brought to the attention of the business, and the EHRC Guidance referred to above sets the bar very high. Under the Employment Rights Bill, we can also expect further regulations specifying what is “reasonable” for the purposes of the new preventative duty on sexual harassment. All this can be used in firms’ work on strategies to prevent and deal with incidents of NFM.
The Employment Rights Bill will also add a specific whistleblowing category for sexual harassment where the preventative duty applies. The Sexism in the City Inquiry showed that victims’ reluctance to blow the whistle remains a huge challenge in the FS sector when it comes to detecting and preventing NFM. Whilst the current Government’s approach to whistleblowing apart from this is yet to be fully confirmed (it is not clear if the DBT’s review is being continued, which the FCA was to feed into), we do know that whistleblowing is key. This is nothing new for FS firms and should be a key area of focus.
Further reading