UK Supreme Court lowers bar for finding bad faith in trade mark applications
November 18, 2024
UK Supreme Court lowers bar for finding bad faith in trade mark applicationsNovember 18, 2024 Why should I read this?Bad faith has been the subject of a large volume of case law over recent years. It can be used as an absolute ground of invalidity if at the time of the application the applicant acted in bad faith, rendering the trade mark invalid. Unfortunately, the term is not defined, which has no doubt been in part responsible for the number of cases in this area. The decision of the Supreme Court in SkyKick UK Ltd and another (Appellants) v Sky Ltd and others (Respondents) has provided welcome clarity and made it easier to demonstrate that a party has acted in bad faith when applying for a trade mark. Such an attack on the validity of a trade mark is often used by defendants as a counterclaim in trade mark infringement proceedings, and this decision is likely to increase the use of this tactic, particularly where the party alleging infringement holds a trade mark registration in relation to a wide range of goods and services. This article looks at what the court decided in relation to bad faith, and gives practical tips on what this case means for brand owners in relation to their trade mark filing and brand protection strategies. Background to the caseThe decision of the Supreme Court marks the end of a saga of litigation involving four High Court judgments starting in 2018, referring questions to the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) and its subsequent opinion in 2019, and a Court of Appeal judgment in 2021. SkyKick appealed to the Supreme Court, but at an extremely late stage it applied to withdraw its appeal with the support of Sky as the parties had reached settlement. However, given the public importance of the issues in the case, the Supreme Court refused the application and went on to hand down its judgment in any event. In summary, Sky brought proceedings against SkyKick for infringement of five of its trade marks, four registered in the EU and one in the UK, all for the word “SKY.” Two of the EU trade marks were for the word “SKY” in two different stylised fonts, and one EU trade mark and the UK trade mark were simply for the word “SKY” (together the Marks). All were registered in relation to a wide range of goods and services. Sky objected to SkyKick’s use of “SkyKick” and variants of it in relation to email migration and storage products and services that fell within the scope of their registrations, and also claimed that SkyKick had passed off their goods and services as those of, or connected with, Sky. SkyKick counterclaimed that the Marks were wholly or partially invalid, first on the basis that the specification lacked clarity and precision, and secondly on the basis that the applications had been made in bad faith because Sky had no genuine intention of using the Marks in relation to all (or at least some of) the goods and services for which they were registered. Two elements of the case fell away and were not considered by the Supreme Court: The passing off claim was unsuccessful at first instance and an appeal against this was dismissed by the Court of Appeal; as such it is not relevant to this case. SkyKick’s counterclaim that the Marks were invalid due to the specification lacked clarity was the subject of one of the questions referred to the CJEU, and the CJEU held that a mark cannot be declared wholly or partially invalid on this basis, and consequently this part of SkyKick’s claim was dismissed. The rest of this article focuses on the key issue of the case, namely bad faith. What did the court decide in relation to bad faith?The issue central to this case is whether a trade mark registration can be invalidated in whole or part on the basis that the application to register the mark was made in bad faith because the applicant did not, at the time the application was made, have a genuine intention to use the mark in relation to some or all of the goods or services for which it sought protection. The lack of intention to use a mark can be divided into two categories:
(i) Goods and services for which there is no prospect of use at all In relation to the first category, the Court of Appeal held that it was implicit in the CJEU opinion that it is not bad faith to apply to register a trade mark without any intention to use it in relation to the goods and services covered by the application (as an applicant may not know exactly what the future holds for their business), and that the overall breadth of the specification of goods and services is not a ground for concluding that the application was made in bad faith. The Supreme Court disagreed and held that where a trade mark applicant failed to provide a reasonable explanation for expansive filings, it would be open to a court to find that the application was indeed made in bad faith in respect of those goods and services. The Court of Appeal and the CJEU also held that there will only be bad faith where the absence of an intention to use the mark is coupled with: “objective, relevant and consistent indicia tending to show that when the application was filed, the applicant had the intention either of undermining, in a manner inconsistent with honest practices, the interests of third parties, or of obtaining, without even targeting a specific third party, an exclusive right for purposes other than those falling within the functions of a trade mark”. The essential function of a trade mark is to denote the origin of a good or service and allow it to be distinguished from those provided by other parties. “Purposes other than those falling within the functions of a trade mark” could be to use the registrations as “legal weapons” to threaten or bring infringement actions and deter third parties from using similar signs. The Supreme Court disagreed that these intentions would need to be demonstrated for a finding of bad faith. It felt that the effect of this would mean that it would in practice be very difficult, if not impossible, for a third party to make out a case of bad faith filing on the ground that the applicant had no intention of using the mark in relation to some or all of the goods or services included in the application, proving what was in the mind of someone else being inherently difficult. Instead, the width and size of the specification of goods and services and their nature would need to be compared to the size and nature of the applicant’s business (or lack of it) to see whether these are sufficient to rebut the presumption of good faith and so justify the conclusion that the application was filed, at least in part, in bad faith. The court confirmed that partial invalidity of a trade mark registration is possible (i.e. in respect of the goods and services for which the applicant never had any intention of using the mark): in such cases the specification for the mark will be narrowed to remove these goods and services rather than the trade mark as a whole becoming invalid. Takeaways:
it is reasonable to infer that the application constituted, in whole or in part, an abuse of the trade mark system and so was made in bad faith.
(ii) Overly broad descriptions of the owner’s actual or intended goods and services The Court of Appeal judgment appears to preclude a finding of bad faith based on the use of overly broad categories of goods and services (for example, software) where the applicant had an intention to use the mark in relation to some but not all of the goods and services within that broad category, even where a term covers sub-categories of goods or services in relation to which the applicant never had any intention of using the mark and there was no realistic prospect of it ever doing so. The Supreme Court disagreed as it felt the effect of this would be unfair as traders who used broad terminology to describe the goods and services would find themselves in a better position than those who used the appropriate sub-categories, holding that this could not have been the intention of the legislation. Trade mark filing practices have changed over the years as case law evolved in this area, and so the court held that if they were required or encouraged to use class headings this can be taken into account. Takeaway: Including goods and services that an applicant does not intend to use the mark for along with others it does because they both fall under the same class heading can now demonstrate the filing was made at least in part in bad faith. As a result, specifications should be drafted to accurately reflect the applicant’s activities. Any goods/services which it intends to launch under the trade mark in the short to medium term should also be covered by the application but it should be recorded that it intends to use the trade mark for those goods/services in the future. FairnessA related point of interest was fairness in the procedure of making a case of bad faith. An accusation of bad faith is clearly a serious allegation, and so it is fair that the party alleging bad faith should set out its case out clearly. The Court of Appeal held that as part of this, an alleging party such as SkyKick was required to put forward a narrower category of goods and services to which the registration ought to be restricted. This is clearly difficult for an alleging party, as only the applicant truly knows which goods and services it intends, even conditionally, to use the mark in relation to (and which it never will), and this intention dictates what the scope of the registration should be. As such, the Supreme Court held that the party seeking a declaration of bad faith need only explain its case relying on the objective facts available to it. It will then be for the accused party to answer that case, and to the extent it fails to do so the presumption of good faith will be displaced, opening the door to a finding of bad faith. In the third High Court hearing each side put forward suggested restricted specifications for the Marks and the court made clear that if they did not agree with either of these then the court itself would decide where the line should be drawn. Neither side put forward a “fall back” position (for use in the event the court disagreed with the initial amended specifications put forward by the parties), and so this was the course the court ended up taking in the fourth hearing after the CJEU had given its opinion, and it amended the specification as it saw fit. The Court of Appeal held that the judge should not have done this, and that SkyKick should have set out a further amended specification. The Supreme Court disagreed, holding that it the judge had indicated in advance this would happen if he did not agree with the suggestions put forward by either side, and so it doing this was not unfair and neither side was materially disadvantaged by the judge in redrawing the specification. Takeaway: A party seeking a declaration of bad faith need only explain its case relying on the objective facts available to it and does not need to put forward a narrower category of goods and services to which the registration ought to be restricted (though during proceedings may consider doing this as this may be preferable to the judge deciding what should be in and what should be out of the specification). Other factors relevant to an assessment of bad faithThe Supreme Court held the following were relevant factors to the assessment of bad faith which the Court of Appeal failed to take into consideration:
The Supreme Court felt this supported the SkyKick’s case that Sky had applied for and secured registrations for the Marks across a great range of goods and services which they never had any intention to sell or provide, and yet they were prepared to deploy the full armoury presented by these Marks against a trader. Effect of bad faith on infringementAs mentioned above, a counterclaim of bad faith to attack the validity of a trade mark is a common line of defence in trade mark infringement proceedings. This case confirmed that where a finding of bad faith is made in relation to some but not all of the goods or services covered by the registration, the registration falls away in relation to those goods or services but remains valid in relation to the remaining goods or services (i.e. the ones in relation to which the registration holder had an intention to the mark for at the time they applied to register the trade mark). Consequently, whether there remains an infringement case to answer depends upon whether the activities of the alleged infringer fall within the remaining valid goods and services left within the trade mark specification. The infringement aspect of this case is not as noteworthy as the bad faith element as the Supreme Court agreed with the Court of Appeal:
The case also set out the correct approach in infringement cases when some of the terms in a trade mark specification are unclear. In such cases: “The correct approach, as a matter of principle, in considering a specification of services which is defined by terms which are not clear or precise, is to confine the terms used to the substance or core of their possible meanings… So too, if a specification of goods is defined by terms which are ambiguous, then it should be confined to those goods which are clearly covered.” This is an unsurprising approach, as allowing ambiguity to favour the trade mark applicant would incentivise unclear and nebulous trade mark specifications. This in turn would make it harder for parties to determine, from looking at the trade marks on the register, what is covered and consequently what they can and cannot do in relation to a specific mark, so there are clear policy reasons for adopting this position. Takeaway: Ensure trade mark specifications are clear and unambiguous in order to ensure the mark covers all goods and services desired. Divergence between UK and EU trade mark law and jurisdiction of UK courts in relation to EU trade marksIn UK, a trade mark applicant is required to state that the mark is being used in relation to the goods or services in relation to which it is sought to register the mark, or that the applicant has a bona fide intention that it should be so used. Such a requirement does not exist in the EU, but the UK’s requirement for this is not prohibited by the Trade Marks Directive. The Supreme Court indicated that a false declaration of intent to use could be a factor indicative of bad faith. As a final point, the ruling confirmed that UK courts retained jurisdiction to hear cases concerning EU trade marks protected by registration for the territory of the EU that were pending as at the “IP completion date” of 31 December 2020 which marked the end of the Brexit transition period. This point will become of decreasing relevance moving forward as it only affects proceedings that were pending on 31 December 2020, but clarity in this respect is still welcome. ConclusionThe Supreme Court’s ruling demonstrates the inherent tension in the trade mark filing system between seeking to avoid parties holding monopolies over marks for goods and services that they are not using (and will not use) the mark in relation to, and allowing an applicant an appropriate degree of protection in business areas that they do not currently operate but may expand into within the five year grace period following registration (after which marks may be vulnerable to attacks for non-use if they have not been used). The position adopted by the Supreme Court in this case has shifted the dial towards avoiding monopolies and abuses of the trade mark filing system. The conclusion of this long-running case will undoubtedly shape future trade mark litigation and trade mark registration strategies going forward. Brand owners should review the wording of the specifications of their existing trade mark portfolios and take the guidance this case provides into account when determining their registration strategy for new applications, and those involved in or contemplating infringement proceedings should consider the likelihood of a finding of bad faith in relation to the specification of the registered marks. Latest InsightsLatest News
Latest Events
legal updates November 17, 2026 Mandatory human rights due diligence is coming to the UK legal updates November 17, 2026 COP31: Science, industry and technology – from pledges to investment pipeli... legal updates November 17, 2026 Industrial Horizons legal updates November 16, 2026 COP31: Finance, trade and the challenge of turning climate ambition into in... deal alerts November 06, 2026 Eversheds Sutherland advises Mercedes-Benz on European fast-charging partne... firm news November 05, 2026 Eversheds Sutherland hires partner Peter Cheng to lead Hong Kong ECM practi... firm news October 27, 2026 Eversheds Sutherland (International) announces senior leadership appointmen... firm news October 26, 2026 Eversheds Sutherland deepens fintech and regulatory bench with double partn... hybrid Europe Action Week 2026 Europe Action Week returns this November with a dynamic mix of events designed to help you navigate what’s next. in-person Industrial relations masterclass November 18, 2026 9.30am - 4.30pm (GMT) London, United Kingdom virtual Immigration UK Business – sponsor licencing course November 24, 2026 9.30am - 11.30am (GMT) Virtual virtual UK employment law training December 01, 2026 1pm - 4pm (GMT) Virtual |