Second attempt permitted: a failed attempt at service does not preclude the works council hearing
Baden-Württemberg Regional Labour Court (LAG) judgement of 10 June 2026 – 19 Sa 6/26
November 20, 2026
Second attempt permitted: a failed attempt at service does not preclude the works council hearingBaden-Württemberg Regional Labour Court (LAG) judgement of 10 June 2026 – 19 Sa 6/26November 20, 2026 If a notice of termination is not delivered, the works council consultation is not deemed to have been exhausted. A new notice of termination based on the same decision to terminate is not a second notice of termination. A second consultation is not required. However, companies should take care when formulating the termination date during the consultation. Facts of the caseA security company wished to dismiss an employee who was on probation. It consulted the works council. Notice of dismissal ‘at the earliest possible date’ was given. The works council allowed its consultation period to lapse without commenting. The letter of dismissal was to be delivered by a courier service. Two attempts at delivery failed. Following the employee’s hospitalisation, the company drew up a new notice of dismissal and handed it to him in person. It did not consult the works council again. The Mannheim Labour Court therefore deemed the dismissal invalid: a further consultation is only dispensable if the works council had unreservedly agreed to the first dismissal. Mere silence is not sufficient. The decisionThe Regional Labour Court (LAG) took a different view and dismissed the claim of the employee. A notice of dismissal only takes effect upon receipt. If it never arrived, the employer has not yet exercised their right to dismiss. The consultation is therefore not ‘exhausted’. The second letter is thus not a new notice of dismissal, but the first implementation of the original decision to dismiss. In the LAG’s view, prior consent from the works council is not a prerequisite in this specific scenario. The employer acquires the right to terminate the employment contract upon completion of a proper consultation procedure – regardless of whether the works council agrees, objects or remains silent. In doing so, the LAG takes a stance contrary to the interpretation of the Federal Labour Court’s (BAG) 1989 case law that has been upheld to date: in that case, it was ruled that a repeat consultation was only dispensable if the works council had consented to the (first) dismissal. Implications for practiceThe ruling provides relief in cases of delivery failures where it is undisputed that a notice of dismissal has not been received. However, it is not yet legally binding: the Regional Labour Court (LAG) has allowed an appeal, and the case is pending before the Federal Labour Court (BAG) (2 AZR 156/26). Until then, a residual risk remains. A further risk lies in the termination date. If the employer notifies the works council of a fixed termination date, a delay in the delivery may postpone that date. If, for example, the notice is received in the following month, the employment relationship may end one month later. The actual termination date will then differ from the one named in the consultation. As the facts of the dismissal and the termination date have changed over time, a new consultation may be necessary. In the case in question, it helped the company that it had not specified a fixed date, but rather the ‘next possible date’. Practical tipCompanies should phrase the termination date flexibly during the works council consultation, for example: “The intention is to give ordinary notice of termination in accordance with the standard notice period at the earliest possible date; this would be [date] upon receipt of the notice of termination in [month].” If, however, a specific date was given and it has passed, it is advisable to hold a further consultation as a precautionary measure. The same applies until the Federal Labour Court (BAG) issues a clarifying ruling. Where there is a dispute as to whether a notice of termination has been received, whether it was valid in form, or whether an undelivered notice is still ‘in circulation’, companies should still, as a precaution, hold a further consultation, as the Regional Labour Court’s (LAG) decision only concerns a notice of termination that was undisputedly undelivered and ultimately remained with the courier service. The effort involved is minimal, but the risk of an invalid termination is high. Termination notices should, where possible, be served by couriers with documented proof of delivery. Sufficient time should be allowed for failed delivery attempts. Latest News
Latest Events
client news November 19, 2026 Eversheds Sutherland advises EDF on landmark UK energy retail acquisition deal alerts November 06, 2026 Eversheds Sutherland advises Mercedes-Benz on European fast-charging partne... firm news November 05, 2026 Eversheds Sutherland hires partner Peter Cheng to lead Hong Kong ECM practi... firm news October 27, 2026 Eversheds Sutherland (International) announces senior leadership appointmen... hybrid Europe Action Week 2026 Europe Action Week returns this November with a dynamic mix of events designed to help you navigate what’s next. virtual Immigration UK Business – sponsor licencing course November 24, 2026 9.30am - 11.30am (GMT) Virtual virtual UK employment law training December 01, 2026 1pm - 4pm (GMT) Virtual virtual Strategic Reflections on COP31 December 02, 2026 10am GMT | 11am CET Virtual, |