LawBite: Centre Point cladding costs: Court of Appeal rules
November 18, 2026
LawBite: Centre Point cladding costs: Court of Appeal rulesNovember 18, 2026 The Court of Appeal has ruled in a decision which tests how far the Building Safety Act 2022 (BSA) protects leaseholders in England from service charges for "cladding remediation". In September last year the Upper Tribunal (UT) took a wide view of paragraph 8 of Schedule 8 to the BSA 2022 (Paragraph 8) concluding that it is not limited to fire risks. It also held that no 30-year time limit applies. The protection therefore covered a façade built in the 1960s. The landlord appealed, and the Court of Appeal yesterday confirmed that the appeal is dismissed. The decision applies in England only. It is most relevant to landlords, managing agents, investors, lenders and leaseholders of relevant buildings with unsafe cladding. Background to the disputeThe appellants, Almacantar Centre Point Nominee No.1 Ltd and Almacantar Centre Point Nominee No.2 Ltd (Almacantar) own the freehold of Centre Point House near Tottenham Court Road, London (CPH). The respondents are several leaseholders of CPH. Almacantar‘s original application to the First-tier Tribunal (FTT) was made under section 27A(3) of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1985. It wanted the leaseholders to pay to repair the original 1960s façade through the service charge. The façade had a timber frame and single-glazed windows above spandrel panels. The works cost over £6 million. What the FTT decidedIn March 2024 the FTT found that the leaseholders held “qualifying leases” under section 119 of the BSA 2022 and the works were "cladding remediation". Paragraph 8 therefore prevented Almacantar recovering the costs. The status of the leases was in doubt, but the FTT applied the presumption in paragraph 13 of Schedule 8. This treats leases as qualifying unless shown otherwise. Almacantar had not requested leaseholder deeds of certificate under Regulation 7 of the Building Safety (Leaseholder Protections) (Information etc.) (England) Regulations 2022 (Regulations). It therefore could not rebut the presumption. Almacantar appealed to the UT on two points. First, it said the defects fell outside the BSA 2022 protections. Second, it said the leaseholders did not hold qualifying leases. What the UT decidedThe UT upheld the FTT’s decision. It made three key findings.
The UT would not interfere with the FTT’s findings on the “qualifying lease” and “cladding remediation” points. The appeal to the Court of AppealAlmacantar appealed and the Court of Appeal heard the matter on 15 and 16 October 2026. The appeal raised two main questions about the scope of the leaseholder protections for cladding:
What the Court of Appeal decidedIn a unanimous judgment (Fancourt, Newey and Miles LJJ), the Court of Appeal dismissed Almacantar’s appeal, and upheld the decisions of the FTT and UT on each issue.
Key points
Latest Events |