Following a five day trial, the English High Court has confirmed the conclusions already reached at interim hearing level on numerous occasions, namely that crypto-assets are capable of constituting property. Although this was expected, it is significant as crypto-asset fraud victims ought not to be treated any differently to victims losing funds comprising traditional currencies. The Judge very comprehensively dealt with this issue as part of his analysis of a large body of case law, on defining and identifying various property types that did not squarely fit within the ‘thing in possession’ or ‘thing in action’ categories.
The decision in D’Aloia will also give confidence to litigants pursuing crypto exchanges directly. This is because it demonstrates that courts will refuse to allow exchanges to rely upon good faith based defences in appropriate cases. To date, it has been difficult to sue exchanges because, unless the crypto-assets were still held by the exchange, a victim generally has to meet a high threshold to succeed in recovering cryptocurrency that has been paid away as a result of fraud. This reflects that, like a bank, a crypto exchange acts as agent for its customer, and will be contractually obliged to follow their instructions. Proving that an exchange behaved negligently in their dealings will not suffice because it does not generally owe a duty of care to a third party fraud victim.
Ultimately, through a failure in expert evidence, the claimant was unable to prove that his cryptocurrency had found its way to the exchange in question, Bitkub. Had he done so, he may well have succeeded in his claim. The Court found that, due to its customer repeatedly breaching withdrawal limits (which Bitkub had not explained the reason for), Bitkub had actual knowledge of suspicious account activity on the customer’s account. Consequently, Bitkub was held to have been “on notice of a money laundering risk and failed to take steps in response”. This potentially removed the ability for Bitkub to rely upon good faith based defences such as bona fide purchaser for value.
The decision
D’Aloia is the first High Court trial decision relating to cryptocurrency fraud. The claimant alleged that he had lost USDT (Tether) valued at approximately £2.5m, when he was convinced to transfer crypto-assets from his wallet to another, believing that he was investing with a company called “td-finan”. This was a typical investment scam, where the victim mistakenly moves their funds to a wallet held or controlled by a fraudster. The claimant believed that he had opened an online trading platform with the fictitious investment company, td-finan.
Fraudsters generally move funds at speed to obfuscate their origin, mixing them with other victims’ funds, and ultimately ‘off-ramping’ the stolen cryptocurrency (i.e. converting some or all of those crypto-assets to fiat currency).
The claimant alleged that his crypto-assets were very swiftly moved between various wallets across a series of 14 transactions known as ‘hops’. The claimant’s case was that, at the 14th hop, at least some of his funds had reached a wallet held by a private individual with the Sixth Defendant, Bitkub Online Co Ltd (“Bitkub”), a cryptocurrency exchange based in Thailand.
The D’Aloia judgment covered a range of issues including:
Whether cryptocurrency, specifically USDT, can be categorised as property under English law.
Whether it was possible for the claimant to trace and/or to follow his cryptocurrency to a wallet not paid directly, but which may have received the proceeds of his cryptocurrency holdings.The boundaries of unjust enrichment, including whether it was capable of applying to cryptocurrency, and the treatment of defences of ministerial receipt and change of position.
Whether a constructive trust could be imposed on a cryptocurrency exchange. If so, whether a defence of bona fide purchaser for value without notice was recognised in the context of crypto asset transfers.
There were also ancillary issues, including the adequacy of pleadings, and the approach to expert evidence in cryptocurrency claims.
The Judge was critical of the claimant’s expert, including his explanation of his methodology. Even though the Judge accepted that Bitkub’s customer was probably mixed up in td-finan’s fraud, and had received laundered funds from fraud victims, the claimant could not demonstrate that this included his misappropriated USDT. Ultimately, therefore, the claimant’s claim against Bitkub failed. He had failed to establish that Bitkub received any of his crypto-assets.
Learning points/Commentary
It has been clear for some time that crypto-assets are capable of being categorised as property. As well as the court’s development of this area of the law, steps are being taken to enshrine it in legislation (via the Property (Digital Assets) Bill). This categorisation is important for various issues, including whether a claimant can follow or trace their misappropriated cryptocurrency, and ultimately enforce their losses against either a fraudster or crypto exchange.
In D’Aloia, the claim collapsed because the claimant could not prove that his crypto-assets had made their way to Bitkub. Had he done so, the claimant may well have succeeded in establishing that Bitkub had been unjustly enriched and/or that there was some form of constructive trust entitling the claimant to restitution.
Looking forward
The law relating to unjust enrichment is a developing area. The analysis in D’Aloia is likely to generate wider interest not just for crypto-asset holders, but also for victims of fraud more generally.
In future, if crypto exchanges and regulated financial institutions wish to rely on good faith based defences, they will need to take steps to ensure that they act on potential money laundering risks generated by their customers. However, guidance from the appeal courts about precisely what constitutes bad faith may be required (in this context, parties continue to grapple with what is meant by “a failure to act in a commercially acceptable way”).
For crypto-assets, the disputes space is burgeoning, and the law is developing at speed. We are likely to see many more cases come before the English courts with similar fact patterns.
The materials on the Eversheds Sutherland website are for general information purposes only and do not constitute legal advice. While reasonable care is taken to ensure accuracy, the materials may not reflect the most current legal developments. Eversheds Sutherland disclaims liability for actions taken based on the materials. Always consult a qualified lawyer for specific legal matters. To view the full disclaimer, see our Terms and Conditions or Disclaimer section in the footer. Eversheds Sutherland is a provider of legal and other services operating through various separate and distinct legal entities. For further information about these entities and Eversheds Sutherlands' structure please see the Legal Notice page of this website.