Parties to disputes should keep in mind that the Court will grant freezing orders in support of: (i) any kind of claim (not just fraud claims) so long as the applicant can prove that the various limbs of the procedural test are satisfied, which might mean looking at a wider range of facts than just those giving rise to the claim in order to provide the Court with sufficient evidence; and (ii) arbitration proceedings or proceedings in certain other jurisdictions under the Civil Jurisdiction and Judgments Act 1982.
With that in mind, parties to potential claims should take care to ensure that their dealings with assets are, for example, within the ordinary and proper course of business (if a company) or their ordinary living expenses (if an individual), otherwise a prospective claimant might rely upon those dealings (to the extent they became aware of them) as evidence of a risk of unjustified dissipation in applying for a freezing order and seeking its continuation / resisting its discharge.
Where a party is applying without notice for a freezing order, and is therefore subject to the duty of full and frank disclosure and fair presentation of evidence, it will have to bring to the Court’s attention any relevant security it holds and explain why, in view of that security, there is nevertheless a risk of unjustified dissipation, so as to avoid: (i) giving the respondent the chance to argue that there has been a breach of the duty of full and frank disclosure which justifies the discharge of an ex parte freezing order; and (ii) in the event such argument is successful, the attendant cost and damages consequences (for example, under the cross-undertaking in damages) which may be very significant.
Facts of the Case
The claimant (“C”) is the trustee for loans made under a facility agreement (“FacilityAgreement”) to a Ukrainian grain export company (“GNT”) which the defendants (“Ds”) ultimately beneficially own and control. GNT defaulted on the Facility Agreement and C sought to enforce a package of security and guarantees (the “SecurityPackage”) in various jurisdictions, including bringing an arbitration claim against Ds in the London Court of International Arbitration (“LCIA”) to enforce suretyship deeds (“SuretyshipDeeds”) that they had entered into with C (the “LCIAClaim”).
C obtained without notice worldwide freezing orders (“WFOs”) against Ds in support of the LCIA Claim. Ds applied to set aside the WFOs on the grounds that: (i) there was no real risk of unjustified dissipation of assets, as the various transactions upon which C relied as evidence of risk of dissipation were, in fact, undertaken in the ordinary and proper course of business; (ii) it was not just and convenient to continue the WFOs, as C was more than adequately secured by the Security Package; and/or (iii) C breached its duty of full and frank disclosure and fair presentation on the without notice application on various grounds.
There was a real risk of unjustified dissipation of assets:
C, as a claimant with a contractual claim, was not (as Ds contended) in a fundamentally different position to a claimant with a fraud claim, although the latter might have a head start with the evidence available to satisfy the Court of a risk of unjustified dissipation, and the former might need to look to a wider range of facts;
As agreed between the parties, the Court was entitled to take into consideration events which had occurred since the without notice hearing; and
There was “very powerful” evidence of a real risk of unjustified dissipation of assets, including the following transactions which were not (as Ds contended) legitimate dealings: (i) Ds had transferred shares in companies outside of the GNT Group, without consideration and in breach of the Facility Agreement; (ii) Ds had failed to perfect a pledge over shares in an entity in the GNT Group despite repeated requests by C; (iii) Ds had transferred USD 10m from a Swiss bank account held by a GNT Group company to another company outside of the GNT Group; (iv) Ds had withdrawn large sums of cash from various GNT Group company bank accounts shortly after C had commenced enforcement action; and (v) Ds appeared to have dissipated USD 100m worth of grain stocks pledged to a creditor without the creditor’s consent.
The balance of justice and convenience lay with C, on the findings that: (i) the “good arguable case” and “risk of unjustified dissipation” limbs of the test for a WFO were so overwhelmingly satisfied that it would take a very powerful factor to militate against finding that justice and convenience lay with C; (ii) the existence of the Security Package is a relevant factor to this limb of the test; but (iii) it was of no weight in this case, where: (a) part of the Security Package was the Suretyship Deeds; (b) the Suretyship Deeds did not constrain C in how it enforced other parts of its Security Package; (c) the possibility of C making recoveries from other security did not give a reason as to why, in effect, Ds should be permitted to dissipate their assets in the period between now and when C seeks to enforce any award in the LCIA Claim against them; and (d) there was no way of knowing with confidence from which security C would make recoveries first, as Ds were resisting all steps C was taking to enforce that security and its rights.
Ds’ argument about full and frank disclosure was made far too late (only particularised in their skeleton argument, and aspects of it abandoned in oral submissions) and rejected on that ground. In any event, it would have been rejected on the merits, as there was not any culpable non-disclosure such as would justify setting aside the WFO.
See our earlier briefing here about a decision by Mr Justice Foxton regarding the WFOs made in these proceedings and the scope of the reasonable legal expenses proviso.
The materials on the Eversheds Sutherland website are for general information purposes only and do not constitute legal advice. While reasonable care is taken to ensure accuracy, the materials may not reflect the most current legal developments. Eversheds Sutherland disclaims liability for actions taken based on the materials. Always consult a qualified lawyer for specific legal matters. To view the full disclaimer, see our Terms and Conditions or Disclaimer section in the footer. Eversheds Sutherland is a provider of legal and other services operating through various separate and distinct legal entities. For further information about these entities and Eversheds Sutherlands' structure please see the Legal Notice page of this website.