Ireland - Responsible Use of Generative AI in Court Documents
AI in litigation: Part 6 of the series
November 19, 2026
Ireland - Responsible Use of Generative AI in Court DocumentsAI in litigation: Part 6 of the seriesNovember 19, 2026 On 29 July 2026, the President of the High Court, issued Practice Direction HC 142 on the Responsible Use of Generative Artificial Intelligence in Court Documents (the Practice Direction). The Practice Direction came into operation on 1 September 2026. It applies to all proceedings before the High Court, whether instituted before or after that date, in respect of all Court Documents prepared, produced or generated after commencement. Parties to proceedings already on foot are therefore subject to it now. The Practice Direction recognises that generative AI tools (GenAI Tools) may assist in the efficient conduct of litigation, including by reducing costs and enhancing access to justice. It nonetheless makes clear that the use of such tools does not diminish or alter any obligation owed to the Court, and that all court users remain responsible for the content of their Court Documents. “Court Documents” is broadly defined to include pleadings, submissions, affidavits, witness statements and expert reports, and the Practice Direction applies to parties, legal practitioners, witnesses, experts and litigants in person. In this briefing, we consider the background to the Practice Direction, set out its key requirements, and explain what this means for those litigating in the Irish courts and how the approach compares to the recommendations recently made by the Civil Justice Council (CJC) in England and Wales. Background – why now?The Practice Direction does not arise in a vacuum. Courts here and abroad have increasingly encountered court documents containing AI-generated material that, on inspection, proved unreliable: authorities that do not exist, citations that do not support the proposition advanced and legal concepts with no basis in Irish law. The Practice Direction itself names these so-called “hallucinations” as a known risk of GenAI Tools. Two recent High Court decisions illustrate the problem. In Reddan v An Bord Pleanála [2025] IEHC 172, an unrepresented applicant for leave to seek judicial review invoked a phrase which the Court considered foreign to Irish law and which, in its view, bore “all the hallmarks of ChatGPT, or some similar AI tool”. The Court was particularly troubled because the phrase carried an allegation of criminal conduct that had not been properly substantiated. In Coulston & Others v Elliott & Elliott [2024] IEHC 697, unrepresented defendants put forward an entirely new argument at submissions stage that they were unable to explain to the Court. Rejecting the argument as “fatally flawed”, the Court suggested that, if AI had been used, the defendants had “been fooled”, and issued a broader warning to the public about relying on such tools in legal matters. Against that background, the Practice Direction marks a shift in the Irish position from judicial warnings to the establishment of a clear framework of verification obligations, mandatory declarations and defined sanctions, applicable to practitioners and litigants in person. Key RequirementsWitness statements and affidavits. A witness statement or affidavit must reflect the witness’s own recollection, knowledge and evidence. Unless the Court otherwise directs, the witness or deponent must include the following declaration (amended or adapted as appropriate) in one of the opening paragraphs: “I declare that Generative Artificial Intelligence has not been used for the purposes of generating the substantive content of this [witness statement/affidavit] (including by way of altering, embellishing, strengthening, diluting or rephrasing the evidence set out) and that this [witness statement/affidavit] reflects my personal knowledge, recollection and evidence.” The use of GenAI Tools for administrative or ancillary purposes unconnected to the generation of substantive content, such as formatting or spell-checking, does not prevent the declaration being made. Expert reports. An expert report must reflect the expert’s own opinion, expertise and reasoning and must contain the following declaration at the start of the report (amended as appropriate): “I declare that, save as otherwise expressly stated, Generative Artificial Intelligence has not been used for the purposes of generating the substantive content of this report which reflects my own opinions, knowledge and evidence.” Where GenAI Tools have been used, the expert must disclose the nature and extent of that use, including any material use in drafting, analysing, interpreting or generating substantive content, to the extent necessary to enable the Court and the parties to assess the reliability, independence and evidential weight of the opinion. Pleadings and submissions. There is no general obligation to disclose the use of GenAI in preparing a Court Document, save where the Court directs or the specific evidential requirements apply. However, parties and their legal representatives must ensure that all pleaded facts and chronologies have been checked for accuracy, that claims for relief are based on proper legal principles, and that all legal authorities, citations, quotations and references in submissions have been independently verified using authoritative sources. Verification. Any material generated wholly or partly with GenAI must be appropriately and independently verified through human control and supervision before it is used in proceedings, and any limitation on the ability to do so must be disclosed to the Court. Using the same or another GenAI Tool to confirm accuracy is not sufficient. Court users should fact-check and proofread, adapt content to the circumstances of the case, and verify that every authority exists and supports the proposition for which it is cited. Particular care must be taken to ensure that exhibits, images, recordings and other evidential materials are authentic. Disclosure, confidentiality and privilege. GenAI Tools should not be used in respect of information or documents (including documents obtained on discovery) subject to a Court order or undertaking restricting their use, where that would create a risk of disclosure contrary to the order or undertaking. The Practice Direction also cautions that material entered into GenAI Tools may itself be disclosable, and that privileged information entered into non-private tools may cease to be privileged. We consider this further below. Litigants in person. The Practice Direction applies equally to litigants in person, who are subject to the same obligations of accuracy and candour as represented parties. They must familiarise themselves with the Courts Service’s Guidance for Non-Lawyers on the Responsible Use of Generative AI in Court Proceedings and verify outputs using reliable and authoritative sources. Professional obligations. Legal practitioners remain subject to all of their professional and ethical obligations, must exercise oversight of any GenAI output, and must ensure that their clients understand their duty to the Court and that those swearing affidavits or making witness statements understand their personal responsibility to confirm the truth and completeness of those documents. Identifying and correcting errors. A party identifying a potential issue with another party’s Court Documents should raise it with that party first and, absent an appropriate response within a reasonable period, bring it to the Court’s attention. A party that identifies an issue with its own documents must notify the other parties and the Court without delay, substitute clean and marked-up versions, and bear the costs of doing so unless the Court orders otherwise. Sanctions. Non-compliance may result in adverse costs orders, orders disregarding or rejecting Court Documents in whole or in part, or the striking out of a claim or defence. Practitioners who, for example, cite non-existent sources may be referred to the Legal Services Regulatory Authority or their professional body and may face personal costs orders. Next StepsUnlike the position in England and Wales, there is no further rule-making process to await: the Practice Direction is already in force and the declarations are required now. Separately, the Court may at any time direct a party to disclose whether GenAI Tools were used in preparing any Court Document and the nature and extent of that use, and all persons are expected to be in a position to inform the Court if requested. Given the rapidly developing nature of the technology, the Court has indicated that the Practice Direction will be kept under regular review and may be amended from time to time. What does this mean for litigation in Ireland?The Practice Direction does not prohibit the use of GenAI. It places responsibility for the accuracy and integrity of Court Documents firmly on those who prepare and rely on them, and backs that responsibility with a clear sanctions regime. The declarations required for witness evidence and expert reports are immediate, mandatory requirements, and a missing or inaccurate declaration is likely to attract scrutiny from opponents and the Court, and could undermine the weight given to the evidence. The boundary between permissible “administrative or ancillary” use and use which generates substantive content is not always clear. Because the prescribed declaration expressly extends to “rephrasing” the evidence, caution should be applied if using AI in relation to witness evidence and practitioners should always ensure that the statement retains the witness’ own words. Privilege is a further area of uncertainty. There is, as yet, no Irish authority on whether using a public GenAI Tool waives legal professional privilege, although the Court of Appeal in Guerin v O’Doherty [2026] IECA 48 has addressed the use of AI in litigation more generally (see also When AI Gets it Wrong: Lessons from Guerin v O’Doherty). Courts elsewhere have started to grapple with this issue. In England and Wales, the Upper Tribunal (Immigration and Asylum Chamber) indicated that uploading confidential material to a public AI tool places it in the public domain, breaching confidentiality and waiving privilege, while noting that enterprise tools may not carry the same risk. In the United States, the court in United States v Heppner declined to treat documents a defendant had generated using a public AI tool as privileged, relying in part on the provider’s terms permitting it to retain and share user inputs and outputs. For further information on the interaction between privilege rules and Gen AI tools, see our Gen AI in Litigation series. For Irish litigants, the safest working assumption is that anything entered into a public GenAI Tool may not be protected. It is worth noting, however, that Irish litigation privilege does not require a document to be created by, or at the direction of, a lawyer; the question is whether it was prepared for the dominant purpose of actual or reasonably apprehended litigation. An Irish court might therefore approach AI-generated material differently from the US courts, provided confidentiality has been preserved. How does this approach compare to England and Wales? The CJC has published its final report on the Use of AI for Preparing Court Documents, making 15 recommendations. The approach is broadly similar: the CJC recommends that the Civil Procedure Rules be amended to require witnesses of fact to declare that AI has not generated or influenced the substantive content of their statements, and to require experts to make a declaration where AI use generates or influences the substantive content of their reports. As in Ireland, there will be no general requirement for legal representatives to disclose AI tools used in preparing statements of case or skeleton arguments, the CJC having concluded that existing professional duties provide sufficient safeguards. For further information on the CJC’s recommendations, see our article: Civil Justice Council Final Report – Use of AI for Preparing Court Documents. The key difference between the two jurisdictions is that the Irish requirements are already in force, whereas further news is awaited as to the wording of the rule changes and when they will take effect. Practical tips for in-house lawyers
Latest Insights
Latest Events
hybrid Europe Action Week 2026 Europe Action Week returns this November with a dynamic mix of events designed to help you navigate what’s next. virtual Education Webinar - Protecting your IP when contracting with third parties ... November 19, 2026 11:00AM - 12:00PM virtual Immigration UK Business – sponsor licencing course November 24, 2026 9.30am - 11.30am (GMT) Virtual virtual Special Staff Severance Payments and the Academy Trust Handbook 2026: Know... November 24, 2026 11:00AM - 12:00PM |