Is imitation the highest form of flattery? Lookalike products and IP rights in the UK
November 28, 2024
Is imitation the highest form of flattery? Lookalike products and IP rights in the UKNovember 28, 2024 Why should I read this?The world’s largest businesses make huge investments to perfect and distinguish their brands in order to build a reputation for their products. Then, sometimes overnight, competitors put out products which are remarkably similar, albeit with a few alterations to the product name or packaging. With copycats playing deliberately close to the line and reaping the rewards, intellectual property protection needs to be at the forefront of brand owners’ minds from the outset. This article looks at brand preservation strategies, what the law provides in terms of protection, and how the law is changing in this area. What protection is available for brands?Before we look further into current trends it is worth noting that the key practices below remain critical in brand protection and preservation. Registrations Registered rights are much easier to enforce against third parties than unregistered rights. Trade marks protect names, logos and even the look and feel of packaging. Registered designs, such as those for packaging and products, provide an extra layer of protection. The more that is registered, the easier it is likely to be to assert your rights and defend your brand. Invest in your brand and reputation Recent cases (discussed in more detail below) indicate that claims focusing on damage to brand reputation have a higher chance of success than those relying solely on a likelihood of confusion. Therefore, it is crucial to invest in your brand portfolio not only by registering rights but also by investing in marketing and reputation building. Gather evidence If you receive any feedback or complaints from customers or other third parties who have been confused by the packaging of a product, hold on to it! Cases for trade mark infringement under section 10(2) and cases for passing off require showing actual or a likelihood of confusion and/or misrepresentation. Any examples of actual confusion in the marketplace are likely to be key to overcoming this otherwise difficult hurdle. What does the law say?The traditional approach to brand protection Traditionally, trade mark law has been key to protecting brands. When third parties use similar marks for the same products, such that there is a likelihood of confusion as to the origin of the product, brand owners can rely on registered trade marks as a means of protection against infringers (under section 10(2) of the Trade Marks Act 1994 (TMA)). But today’s shoppers are savvy and are often aware that they are buying imitations. In fact, it is sometimes deliberate as shoppers are continually seeking out deals for good quality products sold at a lower cost. This makes it difficult to prove likelihood of confusion in lookalike cases. There is also the common law of passing off, which provides another option for brands who can show both that they have built up goodwill in respect of their products, and that there has been a misrepresentation by the infringing party, causing damage or a likelihood of damage. However, if shoppers are aware they are buying imitations, this is likely to prove fatal to a passing off claim, on the basis that a misrepresentation cannot be established. Emerging trends There have been an increasing number of infringement claims by brands against supermarkets selling lookalike products, and several emerging trends suggest arguments which are more likely to be successful than the traditional approach.
Registered designs are cheaper and easier to obtain than trade mark registrations but, historically, have been interpreted very narrowly, in part due to case law from the EU. However, the UK’s departure from the EU has given the courts increased freedom to decide and interpret cases, as recently shown in the case of Marks & Spencer PLC v Aldi Stores Limited [2024]. In autumn 2020, Marks & Spencer introduced Christmas-themed gin liqueurs. Gold flakes were suspended in the liqueur to mimic snow, illuminated by an integrated light in the base of the bottle, which itself depicted a wintery woodland scene. It was a hit with Christmas shoppers! Then one year later, in November 2021, Aldi began selling clementine and blackberry flavour gin liqueurs containing gold flakes in ‘strikingly’ similar bottles with an integrated light in the base, a wintery tree scene around the bottle, and the wording “The INFUSIONIST Small Batch” on the front. In the meantime, Marks & Spencer had registered four UK registered designs to protect its light up gin bottles (registered on 29 April 2021). The Court of Appeal held that Aldi’s light up glitter-globe gin bottles infringed Marks and Spencer’s registered design rights. Practical Tips:
As noted above, a number of infringement claims have failed on the basis that claimants could not show a likelihood of confusion and/or a misrepresentation on the part of the infringing party. In 2021, for example, the owners of Hendrick’s Gin (William Grant & Sons) sued Lidl for trade mark infringement under section 10(2)(b) TMA and for passing off after Lidl changed the design of the bottle and logo of its Hampstead Gin to a similar shape and colour, with a similar diamond label (William Grant & Sons Irish Brands Limited v Lidl [2021]). Consumers were deemed unlikely to be confused into thinking that there was an association between the two on the basis that Hampstead gin was exclusively sold in Lidl (and Hendrick’s Gin was not sold in Lidl), and the price was vastly different. But this case brings hope for brand owners in the form of claims under section 10(3) TMA, which applies where trade marks have a reputation in the UK and a third party’s use of a similar or identical mark “takes unfair advantage of, or is detrimental to, the distinctive character or repute of the trade mark”. Hendrick’s Gin is well-known for being best served with cucumber and has been marketed widely on this basis. Indeed, Hendrick’s was deemed to have a sufficient reputation in respect of its trade marks (for both the shape and design of its bottle) that, when Lidl changed the design of its Hampstead gin bottle to feature cucumbers and match the size and alcohol percentage of the Hendrick’s bottle, it was held that Lidl’s intention was to attract customers to it by association with the Hendrick’s brand. Lidl was said to be “riding on the coat tails” of Hendrick’s, taking unfair advantage of the repute of the Hendrick’s marks and harming the brand. Similarly, in 2019 Claridge’s Hotel successfully sued Claridge Candles for infringement of its registered trade mark ‘CLARIDGE’S’, brought under section 10(3) TMA. The court found that Claridge’s Hotel had a substantial reputation linked to “luxury, glamour, elegance and exclusivity” and consumers linked the Claridge Candles products and Claridge’s Hotel, both of which were selling ‘luxury’ offerings (Claridge's Hotel Ltd v Claridge Candles Ltd & Anor [2019]). Practical Tips:
Consumer law already addresses the issue of supermarket lookalikes. The Consumer Protection from Unfair Trading Regulations 2008 includes a specific prohibition on misleading commercial practices (including acts by traders relating to the promotion or supply of products to consumers which would cause the average consumer to “take a transactional decision” that they would not otherwise have taken otherwise), e.g. buy something that they would not otherwise have bought. These restrictions are soon to be replaced by equivalent provisions under the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024 (DMCC) which received Royal Assent on 24 May 2024. Each piece of legislation sets out practices deemed misleading and therefore prohibited. This includes commercial practices which create confusion with any other product, trade mark, trade name or other distinguishing mark of another trader. It also prohibits marketing any products with “an overall presentation which is likely to deceive the average consumer about a matter relating to a product, a trader or any other matter relevant to a transactional decision”. Notably, this does not require proving likelihood of confusion, misrepresentation, or harm to a brand’s reputation linked to a registered trade mark, or goodwill, misrepresentation and damage for a passing off claim. Instead, if the overall impression of a product’s packaging is “likely to deceive” this could be enough to fall foul of the legislation. The new risks posed by the DMCC is that it empowers the Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) to directly enforce its provisions, whereas previously the CMA had to seek permission from the court. The CMA can now directly fine businesses up to 10% of global turnover for non-compliance with consumer protection laws. The DMCC Act is not yet in force, so it remains to be seen how the CMA will exercise its new powers, but this could be a useful tool for brands seeking to knock out the imitation products even without any registered trade marks or designs. It is expected that the CMA’s new enforcement powers will come into force in Spring 2025. Practical Tips:
ConclusionIn the end, while imitation may be seen as flattery, it poses significant challenges for brand owners. The evolving legal landscape offers various tools for protecting intellectual property, from traditional trade marks and passing off claims to newer avenues like registered designs and the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act. By staying vigilant, investing in brand reputation, and leveraging these legal protections, businesses can better safeguard their unique products and maintain consumer trust. Latest InsightsLatest News
Latest Events
legal updates November 18, 2026 UK: FCA releases new ESG ratings rules legal updates November 18, 2026 UK: AI Transcription – harness benefits, manage risks legal updates November 18, 2026 Commercially Connected shorts - 18 November 2026 legal updates November 18, 2026 COP31: Oceans, nature and land use gain ground in climate policy and inves... deal alerts November 06, 2026 Eversheds Sutherland advises Mercedes-Benz on European fast-charging partne... firm news November 05, 2026 Eversheds Sutherland hires partner Peter Cheng to lead Hong Kong ECM practi... firm news October 27, 2026 Eversheds Sutherland (International) announces senior leadership appointmen... firm news October 26, 2026 Eversheds Sutherland deepens fintech and regulatory bench with double partn... hybrid Europe Action Week 2026 Europe Action Week returns this November with a dynamic mix of events designed to help you navigate what’s next. in-person Industrial relations masterclass November 18, 2026 9.30am - 4.30pm (GMT) London, United Kingdom virtual Education Webinar - Equality, diversity and inclusion: current developments... November 18, 2026 11:00AM - 12:00PM virtual Education Webinar - Protecting your IP when contracting with third parties ... November 19, 2026 11:00AM - 12:00PM |