Reform of UK law in relation to transfer pricing, permanent establishment and Diverted Profits Tax
Outcome of HMRC’s consultation
February 01, 2024
Reform of UK law in relation to transfer pricing, permanent establishment and Diverted Profits TaxOutcome of HMRC’s consultationFebruary 01, 2024 On 16 January 2024, HMRC published a summary of responses to its June 2023 consultation on the reform of UK law in relation to transfer pricing, permanent establishment and Diverted Profits Tax (the Consultation). The reforms proposed in the Consultation were intended to ensure the application of the UK’s domestic rules in these areas is clear to taxpayers, and that the outcome of their application remains consistent with the underlying policy intention, international standards and the UK’s bilateral tax treaties. Why should I read this?The summary of responses confirms the approach the government will now adopt in relation to many of the proposals. Perhaps most significantly, the government has confirmed it will remove the status of Diverted Profits Tax (DPT) as a separate tax and bring an equivalent charge into Corporation Tax (CT). The government will take the responses to the Consultation into account in the development of the proposals and will hold a technical consultation on draft legislation later in 2024. In this briefing we set out some of the responses to the Consultation and how the government has indicated it will take key proposals forward. For more detail on the original Consultation proposals, you can read Ben Jones and Rebekka Sandwell’s article in Taxation here (subscription/registration required). What should I do?Affected taxpayers and their advisors should keep a close eye on developments in this area, which will substantially affect UK law in relation to transfer pricing, permanent establishment and DPT. The publication of draft legislation later this year will give taxpayers and their advisors the opportunity to carefully scrutinise the detailed proposals and provide further feedback to the government before the final changes ultimately come into effect at an unconfirmed later date. It should be noted that the progress of these developments may be affected if there is a change of government following the upcoming general election. What do I need to know about the reform of UK law in this area?In its summary of responses to the Consultation, the government notes that the proposals were broadly welcomed by respondents, although some areas of concern were noted. Many respondents wanted the opportunity to review and comment on draft legislation, hence the government’s commitment to hold a technical consultation on draft legislation in 2024. Transfer pricing Following the Consultation, the government has confirmed it is bringing forward changes to transfer pricing legislation which the government considers make the rules simpler, more certain and better aligned with tax treaties; the changes will affect both core transfer pricing rules and their implementation in other parts of tax law. Respondents welcomed the intention of the consultation to clarify, simplify and improve the current rules and supported the government’s effort to improve alignment between UK domestic law and the 2017 OECD Model Tax Convention (MTC) and OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines (TPG). However, respondents were not supportive of radical change to the participation condition. Some respondents believed that the current rules provide sufficient coverage and certainty, whereas others saw benefit in consolidating and clarifying those rules where possible. Some respondents recognised that the current rules may not catch all related party transactions, but this was accompanied by a strong preference to address specific problem cases with targeted, prescriptive rules, as opposed to less prescriptive factual tests. Following the Consultation, the government has confirmed it will address known problem cases in a targeted and prescriptive manner, seeking to avoid materially increasing the compliance burden more generally for taxpayers without those specific fact patterns. The government confirmed it will amend the legislation to target more effectively the scenarios in respect of which the rules were primarily devised and that it will clarify other existing rules within the participation condition. The government has confirmed it has no plans to abolish or significantly alter the ‘one-way street’ tax advantage rule (which prevents unilateral negative adjustments to profits or losses which would otherwise give rise to non-taxation, where a corresponding adjustment is not made in the tax computation of the counterparty to a provision), as the government considers it an important aspect of the UK transfer pricing rules, and consistent with the approach taken by most treaty partners. However, the government sees a need for additional guidance in this area, including certain examples to draw out some of the permutations. The government has confirmed it will relax the obligation to apply transfer pricing between UK entities in situations where the UK tax base is not disadvantaged, noting that respondents considered the application of transfer pricing rules to such transactions creates an unnecessary compliance burden on business relative to the risk to the Exchequer. The government also confirmed it will remove the legislative requirement for Commissioners’ Sanctions, noting the common view among respondents that these sanctions provide little to no additional assurance over and above the government’s existing governance process. The government has confirmed its agreement with respondents that consistency is needed in the government’s approach to transfer pricing enquiries and noted the importance of a robust governance process as a tool in ensuring this consistency. The government will consider how existing safeguards and processes can or should be adapted and will look to provide expanded guidance on current governance processes. Permanent establishment Following the Consultation, the government has indicated it will “continue to consider” whether to adopt the definition of a permanent establishment contained in Article 5 of the 2017 OECD MTC in UK domestic legislation. This follows many respondents expressing concern that the proposals would introduce additional complexity and uncertainty, resulting in further compliance burden for taxpayers in contrast to the stated aims of the reform. In particular, several respondents referred specifically to the asset management sector as an area where the impact of the Article 5 changes might be more immediate, as increased uncertainty around the taxation of offshore funds might damage the UK’s competitiveness, potentially leading to some investment management activities being moved offshore. The government has confirmed the Investment Manager Exemption (IME) and Independent Broker Exemption (IBE) will be retained; this confirmation will be welcome to the financial services sector, including asset managers which rely on the IME. However, the government has said it will consider whether changes are needed to clarify the operation of the IME and IBE and therefore affected industries should keep a close eye on developments in this area. In respect of attribution of profits to permanent establishments, respondents supported aligning UK domestic legislation with the relevant double taxation treaty or with Article 7 of the OECD MTC (supported by the Commentary and the OECD Report on the Attribution of Profits to Permanent Establishments); the government has confirmed it will adopt the latter approach. Diverted profits tax Significantly, the government has confirmed that it will remove DPT’s status as a separate tax and bring an equivalent charge into CT. The government considers this will clarify the relationship between the taxation of diverted profits and transfer pricing and will provide access to treaty benefits while maintaining key features of the regime. The majority of respondents welcomed the proposal to remove DPT’s status as a separate tax and bring the diverted profits regime into the CT framework. In particular, respondents agreed that closer alignment with the CT enquiry framework could simplify the UK tax system and improve certainty. Respondents were also in favour of access to double taxation relief under the UK’s treaty network. (Bringing DPT within the CT framework aims to ensure that a DPT charge is a ‘covered tax’ under the UK’s network of double taxation treaties, reducing the risk of double taxation.) The majority of respondents were in favour of repealing and not directly replacing section 86 of the Finance Act 2015 in the DPT legislation (which targets arrangements designed to avoid a UK permanent establishment). The government has confirmed it believes it can tackle these arrangements successfully under the new diverted profits assessment and will ensure any proposed changes to the permanent establishment legislation are considered alongside the changes to DPT. Respondents suggested the government should evaluate whether a diverted profits regime is still required, in light of the improvements in the OECD TPG following the OECD’s Base Erosion and Profit Shifting work and the ongoing work on the Two Pillar Solution. The government considers that DPT remains a useful tool for the government in encouraging multinational enterprises to pay tax on their economic activities in the UK, but has indicated it will continue to keep the regime under review and will consider the impact of the evolving tax landscape. Respondents requested clarification on how the administration of the diverted profits regime would be incorporated within the CT framework and on the interaction with the Mutual Agreement Procedure (MAP). The government confirmed it expects that MAP will be available where a diverted profits assessment results in double taxation and that it will set out the detail of how a diverted profits assessment will interact with MAP, as well as further information on the administration of the reformed diverted profits assessment, at a technical consultation. Further reading on the reform of UK law in this area
For more information on the reform of UK law in this areaIf you have any questions regarding the proposed changes to transfer pricing, permanent establishment and DPT, or how these changes may affect your business, please do not hesitate to get in touch with one of the Eversheds Sutherland contacts set out below. Latest Insights
Latest News
Latest Events
legal updates November 16, 2026 Civil Justice Council Final Report – Use of AI for Preparing Court Document... legal updates November 16, 2026 COP31: Finance, trade and the challenge of turning climate ambition into in... legal updates November 15, 2026 UK Retail Finance Horizon Scanner - October 2026 legal updates November 13, 2026 COP31: Leaders’ Summit | Resilient Cities and Built Environment deal alerts November 06, 2026 Eversheds Sutherland advises Mercedes-Benz on European fast-charging partne... firm news November 05, 2026 Eversheds Sutherland hires partner Peter Cheng to lead Hong Kong ECM practi... firm news October 27, 2026 Eversheds Sutherland (International) announces senior leadership appointmen... firm news October 26, 2026 Eversheds Sutherland deepens fintech and regulatory bench with double partn... hybrid Europe Action Week 2026 Europe Action Week returns this November with a dynamic mix of events designed to help you navigate what’s next. virtual Belgian employment law training November 17, 2026 2.00pm - 5.00pm (GMT) Virtual virtual Education Webinar - An overview of apprenticeship agreements November 17, 2026 11:090PM - 12:00PM in-person Industrial relations masterclass November 18, 2026 9.30am - 4.30pm (GMT) London, United Kingdom |