Judgment explores active case management for group litigation and the prospect of mandatory ADR
Why should I read this?
The High Court has stayed a group action for eight months and adjourned an application for a group litigation order (“GLO”) so that alternative dispute resolution (“ADR”) could be explored.
The judgment provides a useful insight into the approach the courts are likely to take when faced with the challenges of managing large group claims whose individual value can often rapidly become outweighed by the legal costs incurred by the group in pursuing those claims.
Further, although the judge in this case, Senior Master Fontaine, did not make a mandatory order that the parties engage in ADR during the stay period, she expressly encouraged the parties to do so. The decision therefore also offers useful guidance on the considerations the courts will bear in mind when considering how strongly the parties should be encouraged to explore ADR and the extent to which (if at all) their ability to resolve disputes via legal proceedings should be delayed in the meantime.
What else do I need to know about the decision?
Background
In January 2023, over 900 claimants (current and former students of University College London (“UCL”)) brought a claim against UCL for breach of contract in respect of its alleged failure to provide in-person tuition during the academic teaching years 2017-2022, where teaching days were cancelled due to strike actions and/or where tuition was moved online and access to facilities restricted due to the COVID-19 pandemic. The claimants applied for a GLO.
UCL denied liability and requested a stay of proceedings to enable the claimants to utilise the statute backed ADR scheme (“OIA Scheme”) established by the Office of the Independent Adjudicator (the “OIA”) and specifically available to students studying at higher education institutions. That OIA scheme was referred to in some of the claimant’s contracts with UCL with the intention of providing a mechanism for resolving student complaints without the need for court proceedings.
The question for the court was whether the stay and GLO should be granted.
- UCL’s application for the stay
UCL’s primary submission was that there be a stay for 8 months so that the claimants first utilise the OIA Scheme:
- Parties are expected to try and settle disputes without proceedings. If proceedings are issued, active case management includes encouraging use of ADR. The fact that the proceedings were defended was not a reason not to order a stay;
- Time and cost could be saved if the student claimants participated in the free OIA Scheme, and the process would enable any claims not settled to then be properly particularised;
- There was no evidence from any claimant explaining why ADR had not been pursued;
- UCL was not seeking an order compelling the claimants to enter into ADR, simply an order staying the proceedings and its request for a stay was not open ended;
- The OIA Scheme was an approved consumer ADR body for higher education complaints and, said UCL, was well equipped to deal with the volume of complaints, despite the claimants’ solicitors’ arguments to the contrary;
- Some categories of claimants agreed to use the UCL’s complaint procedure/OIA Scheme under the contractual terms which they signed up to before commencing their studies and the court should uphold these clauses;
- The fact the High Court has jurisdiction to hear the claims did not justify a refusal to engage in ADR or undermine the premise that litigation should be a last resort; and
- The OIA scheme offered a much less expense means by which students could pursue and resolve any claims against UCL. Claimants do not require legal advice and representation to successfully bring their complaints via the OIA Scheme and, as a costs free jurisdiction, students did not face costs risks by bringing their claims via the OIA Scheme (unlike court proceedings).
The claimants’ response to the stay application:
- The claimants could not be compelled to take part in ADR as a condition of pursuing claims. Compelling parties to enter a process to which one of them is opposed was also unlikely to be an effective means of resolving a dispute (Halsey v Milton Keynes NHS Trust [2004] EWCA Civ 576 [4]);
- The claimants were not averse to ADR but contended that the OIA Scheme was not equipped to provide a legal resolution of the claim in the way the courts are. Most notably, because the recommendations provided by the OIA are not informed by legal analysis, the group action raised issues of law which the OIA Scheme was not equipped to deal with, the procedure did not involve any impartial assessment of the claims and the OIA’s review would not be binding as it could only make recommendations. In all these circumstances OIA was an inappropriate form of ADR;
- UCL’s defence rejected the claims and there is no reason to suppose it would come to a different conclusion through the OIA Scheme;
- There was no agreement between the parties to submit their disputes by ADR prior to or instead of bringing legal proceedings;
- Imposing the OIA Scheme as the exclusive first instance dispute mechanism usurped the intention of Parliament to give students a choice as to how their complaints were resolved;
- The proposed stay would create delay and UCL would not be able to resolve the complaints in this time. The claimants challenged whether the OIA Scheme could cope with the scale of complaints and said that no explanation has been provided by OIA for how it proposed to deal with that volume; and
- The claims would end up back in court when the processes of the OIA Scheme had been exhausted.
Judgment: the stay application
Having considered these various arguments Senior Master Fontaine ordered a stay of 8 months. In doing so she made the following observations.
- The court has the power to order a stay pursuant to CPR 3.1(2)(f). Stays can be granted for many different reasons but one of the most common reasons was to allow the parties to engage in ADR. Having carefully reviewed the case law she concluded that a stay for the purpose of ADR could be appropriate even in cases where one or more parties opposed it, liability is denied and/or in the context of group litigation;
- However, on the other side of the scales Senior Master Fontaine considered some of the claimants’ concerns about the OIA scheme to be valid, including the way it which it made decisions (including how it assesses quantum) and its ability to deal with a large number of complaints made in a small timeframe; and
- She also laid down a marker that the claimants should be prepared to make proposals as to how different cohorts of students in similar factual circumstances could be grouped together for the purposes of making progress as to how quantum could be assessed.
Balancing all those considerations, Senior Master Fontaine was persuaded to make the order. The factors which particularly influenced that decision were stated to be:
- The substantial costs that were likely to be incurred in group litigation. She observed that the claimants will not receive 100% of any sums awarded even if successful on the basis that the claims were funded by a damages based agreement and that the costs incurred just for the one day hearing of the application were very high; and
- The length of time required to resolve these claims through litigation in the courts and which reinforced the benefit of exploring whether they could be resolved by other means.
Whilst Senior Master Fontaine was clear that the purpose of the stay was not to order the parties to engage in ADR, she was clear that it had been granted with the express intention of encouraging the parties to use the period of the stay to engage in ADR. What method of ADR might be adopted was a matter for the parties.
She also encouraged the parties, to provide information about the claim to enable progress to be made - whether by settlement discussions or, if those failed, through the court process. She made the point that whoever was right or wrong about the appropriate method of resolving the dispute, the same degree of information was necessary to identify and narrow the issues.
Finally she gave permission for either party to apply to lift the stay after 4 months in the event that ADR is not successful (to be used as a last resort).
2. The claimants’ application for a GLO
The claimants asked the court to exercise its discretion to make a GLO under CPR 19.21 and CPR 19.22 because it would beneficial in this claim as GLOs can facilitate the disposal of large numbers of claims in a single set of proceedings, avoiding numerous individual claims in different courts and the risk of inconsistent judgments. Further, claimant common costs can be shared, and costs can be managed by the court.
UCL submitted that there is no basis for making a GLO for the following reasons:
- There are no sufficient ‘common issues’ (a key ingredient of a GLO)
- There was disparity amongst the claimants in relation to their contractual terms with UCL, programmes studied, years of study, different strike dates and different COVID-19 effects. All of which would impact on the extent to which those students had a claim and if so how much it was worth;
- The court’s existing case management powers were sufficient without the need for a GLO;
- GLOs should not be used as a vehicle to attract additional claimants and thus generate litigation; and
- The consequence of granting a GLO was that significant costs and court time would be incurred and litigation should be the last resort and a GLO would sidestep the free OIA Scheme.
Judgment: the GLO application
Having decided to grant the stay of proceedings, it followed, said Senior Master Fontaine, that the GLO application should be adjourned. She also observed that the GLO application could not proceed in any event until relevant information is gathered to determine appropriate cohorts/groups of claimants. This was information which was required to assist the court in determining whether there was sufficient common or related issues to make it appropriate to order a GLO and what they were likely to be for the purposes of that GLO.
Commentary
- Currently the court has no jurisdiction to force parties to mediate, although ADR is actively encouraged and the court has the power to stay proceedings with a view to giving the parties the opportunity to undertake ADR (as in this case). That position is set to change in the near future after the government announced that it will integrate compulsory mediation for all Part 7 small claims in the County Court (generally those valued under £10,000) [1]. Depending on its success, it could be extended to other claims. Further, notably the Court of Appeal is due to consider whether litigants should exhaust appropriate internal complaint procedures before launching pre-litigation procedures (such as under the Pre-Action protocols) in Churchill v Merthyr Tydfil County Court Borough [2]. The decision could have a significant impact on the future of compulsory mediation/ADR. In the meantime, this judgment confirms that the courts are already very focussed on encouraging parties to consider ADR whatever their reservations and however far off settlement appears.
- If claims can’t be settled then the courts in England & Wales are having to adapt to group litigation as a fact of life. When the CPR was introduced some 26 years ago, the rules didn’t necessarily envisage group litigation in the way we are now seeing being issued on a regular basis. Judges are having to use the tools they have flexibly to actively manage cases. It is clear that in this case, the significant costs incurred to date and even bigger projected costs were a cause for concern.
- The question of whether group claims are dealt with by GLO’s is a thorny one. This case and the broader statistics demonstrate that they can be difficult to obtain. There have only been 8 granted since 2018 and none this year to date. Although the court has adjourned its decision on this one, the comments made by the court highlight the scrutiny which the courts are likely to give any GLO application which is made.
- However litigation is conducted, however many claimants are involved and whatever case management scheme is adopted, some basic principles will prevail. Claimants will be expected to properly articulate the key elements of their case on liability quantum and causation. Even in very large group actions sufficient information should be available in respect of each claimants circumstances to enable defendants to consider that individuals claimant’s case. Where appropriate, defendants too must be willing to disclose information to enable to parties to consider the merits of the case on liability and quantum even if that evidential burden might be challenging; and
- The underlying theme of this case is that constructive attempts should be made to resolve claims from the outset. By ADR if that is achievable and through active dialogue and information exchange whether dispute resolution is pursued via ADR or the court process.
[1] For further information, see here. The government will first integrate mediation for all specified money claims (up to £10,000) within this Parliament and work towards integrating mediation across all standard small claims proceedings thereafter.
[2] The appeal hearing has been fixed for 8 November 2023.
For more information contact: