Parties to a JCT building contract can terminate for repeat of a specified default (UK)
August 28, 2024
Parties to a JCT building contract can terminate for repeat of a specified default (UK)August 28, 2024 Why should I read this?In Providence Building Services Limited v Hexagon Housing Association Limited[1] the Court of Appeal decided that if an Employer under JCT 2016 Design and Build Contract repeats a specified default, the Contractor can serve a notice of termination even if an earlier specified default had been rectified. It was not necessary for the Contractor to be entitled to terminate the contract for the earlier specified default. This decision changes the position from an earlier Court of Appeal decision in 2020. What this means is that if, for example, an Employer fails to pay an amount due to the Contractor on time (and the Contractor is entitled to and serves notice of a specified default), a subsequent failure to make timely payment would entitle the Contractor to terminate the contract for the Employer’s default. The case reinforces the need for Employers to ensure that all sums due are paid on time because two late payments (even if only a few days late) could entitle the Contractor to terminate the contract for the Employer’s default. BackgroundHexagon was the Employer under an amended JCT 2016 Edition Design and Build Contract with Providence as the Contractor. The provisions relating to termination (clause 8.9) were unamended (except for the relevant time periods, as highlighted in bold). The relevant parts of the clause are:
“Default by Employer On 27 November 2022, the Employer’s Agent issued Interim Payment Notice No.27 with a final date for payment of 15 December 2022. Hexagon failed to pay on time and on 16 December 2022, Providence issued a notice under clause 8.9.1 giving Hexagon notice of a specified default (the failure to pay). Hexagon paid the sum due on 29 December 2022. Because the specified default had not continued for 28 days from the date of the 16 December notice, Providence never became entitled to serve a further notice under clause 8.9.3 to terminate the contract. On 28 April 2023, the Employer’s Agent issued Interim Payment Notice No.32 under which Hexagon was required to pay £365,812.22 on or before 17 May 2023. Hexagon failed to pay the sum due by the final date for payment. On the following day, Providence issued a further notice under clause 8.9.4 to terminate the contract. The notice referred to the December 2022 notice given under clause 8.9.3 and relied upon Hexagon’s non-payment of the May interim payment as a repetition of the specified default. The notice also relied on alleged repudiatory breaches (19 late payments) and a common law right to terminate in the alternative. Hexagon paid the sum due in full on 23 May 2023 and the next day disputed the lawfulness of the termination, asserting that Providence had repudiated the contract. Hexagon referred the dispute to adjudication and was successful. At first instance in the TCC, the Judge found in favour of Hexagon, referring to the judgment in Lamesa Investments Limited v Cynergy Bank Limited[2]. What did the Court of Appeal decide?The Court of Appeal considered the judgment in Lamesa. In that case, Sir Geoffrey Vos MR had decided that the right under clause 8.9.4 only arose if there had been a prior specified default and the Contractor could have given notice to terminate under clause 8.9.3 but, for whatever reason, had chosen not to. It was essential that the Employer had not rectified the previous specified default that was the subject of the earlier clause 8.9.3 notice. Hexagon argued that this should remain the position and that Providence’s notice of termination was invalid because it had never been entitled to serve notice of termination following the December 2022 notice, because Hexagon had paid (albeit 14 days late). Providence argued that the Hexagon analysis would allow an Employer to consistently pay late, provided it paid within 27 days of any notice from the Contractor under clause 8.9.3 and that Hexagon’s position required the Court to infer words within clause 8.9.4 which were simply not there. The Court was referred to earlier editions of the JCT Design and Build Contract. It noted that the 1998 version, worded differently to the 2016 version, had the meaning contended by Providence. There was no obvious reason for the difference in wording used in the 2016 version or any indication that the 2016 version was intended to change the risk profile of the parties regarding termination. The Court looked at the ordinary natural meaning of the words in clause 8.9.4 and concluded that “for any reason” was, as the words say, “any reason” which could include that the specified default was rectified by the Employer. Therefore, the Court concluded that it was not necessary for the Contractor to be entitled to terminate based on its prior notice of specified default under clause 8.9.3 to be able to give a valid notice to terminate under clause 8.9.4. What else do I need to know about the judgment?Although the Court of Appeal was concerned with the wording of clause 8.9 in the context of a termination by the Contractor, it noted that the relevant words of clause 8.4, permitting termination by the Employer for Contractor default, were the same. Therefore, the result should be the same (although this conclusion was already clearer from the wording of clause 8.4.3). Another point to note is that the termination provisions of the JCT 2016 Design and Build Contract considered by the Court of Appeal are identical in other JCT contracts, including the JCT 2016 Standard Form of Building Contract With and Without Quantities and the JCT 2024 editions. [1] [2024] EWCA Civ 962 [2] [2020] EWCA Civ 821 Latest Insights
Latest News
Latest Events
legal updates November 16, 2026 COP31: Finance, trade and the challenge of turning climate ambition into in... legal updates November 16, 2026 COP31: Children, Youth, Education and Skills Day legal updates November 16, 2026 Eighth Circuit vacates the Fed’s debit interchange cap: Is a Circuit split ... legal updates November 13, 2026 COP31: Leaders’ Summit | Resilient Cities and Built Environment deal alerts November 06, 2026 Eversheds Sutherland advises Mercedes-Benz on European fast-charging partne... media mentions November 06, 2026 What a Democratic Congress Could Mean for Science media mentions November 06, 2026 Attys Can Curb AI Error Fallout With Candor, Accountability firm news November 05, 2026 Eversheds Sutherland hires partner Peter Cheng to lead Hong Kong ECM practi... hybrid Europe Action Week 2026 Europe Action Week returns this November with a dynamic mix of events designed to help you navigate what’s next. virtual Belgian employment law training November 17, 2026 2.00pm - 5.00pm (GMT) Virtual in-person Industrial relations masterclass November 18, 2026 9.30am - 4.30pm (GMT) London, United Kingdom virtual Immigration UK Business – sponsor licencing course November 24, 2026 9.30am - 11.30am (GMT) Virtual |