New proposals on Diversity and Inclusion (D&I) in UK financial services
October 03, 2023
New proposals on Diversity and Inclusion (D&I) in UK financial servicesOctober 03, 2023 Consultation Papers finally published by the FCA and PRA propose annual reporting on D&I and to codify and expand the rules on non-financial misconduct. What do I need to know?Consultation Papers from the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) and the Prudential Regulation Authority (PRA) on proposed new regulatory requirements for improving D&I in Financial Services have at last been published, more than two years since the joint Discussion Paper on the same topic. Whilst still only at consultation stage, the timescale for implementation does not give firms much time to plan for the proposed changes. Therefore you will need to be aware of the different requirements depending on the size and type of your firm. These are:
The proposals in the Consultation Papers differ in several respects from those in the regulators’ joint Discussion Paper, with many of the July 2021 proposals dropped, at least in the FCA consultation. For example the FCA is not proposing that responsibility for D&I should be allocated to a specific Senior Management Function (SMF), and is dropping suggestions regarding Board recruitment and succession planning, mandatory training, and linking remuneration to D&I metrics. Remuneration metrics proposals may, however, be taken forward when other changes are made to remuneration codes. The PRA consultation proposals, which will apply to Capital Requirement Regulation (CRR) and Solvency II firms, are slightly different in relation to Board D&I strategy, succession planning and Senior Manager accountability. Otherwise the PRA and FCA generally take the same approach. A Policy Statement with final requirements is planned for 2024 with the rules taking effect 12 months later. Non-financial misconductThe proposals on non-financial misconduct are a welcome development for the industry, providing clarification and consistency. The new proposed rules and guidance clarify the circumstances when misconduct will amount to a Conduct Rule breach or impact the assessment of fitness and propriety. These changes largely reflect the content of speeches made by the FCA over the last five years. Proposed amendments to the Code of Conduct Sourcebook (COCON) make it clear that COCON applies to behaviour that is, amongst other things, offensive, intimidating or violent; unreasonable and oppressive, humiliating, degrading or which injures another person. The proposed amendments state that COCON does not cover conduct which occurs in the context of an individual’s private or personal life. Determining whether conduct occurs in an individual’s personal or professional life can be a grey area and the FCA has included a list of relevant factors which will help firms to determine this (such as whether the conduct took place on work premises or involved clients or someone the individual had dealt with on behalf of the firm). According to the proposed guidance, “misconduct by A in relation to a fellow member of the workforce at a social occasion organised by their firm” would be within scope, but “misconduct by A in relation to a fellow member of the workforce at a social occasion organised by them in their personal capacity” would not. There is specific guidance on what would amount to a breach of Conduct Rule 1 (acting with integrity), with violent conduct, seriously offensive malicious or insulting conduct, harassment, victimisation, bullying and/or abuse/misuse of power or position being examples of breach. The new rules will also specifically state that bullying, sexual harassment or violence cannot be justified. There are shorter examples of when non-financial misconduct might be a breach of Conduct Rule 2 (acting with due skill, care and diligence) with examples including failing to protect staff from, or failing to take seriously/deal effectively with complaints about the treatment outlined above. Proposed amendments to the Fit and Proper test (FIT) include examples of issues that will be relevant to the assessment of fitness and propriety. This has been very carefully aligned to the FCA’s statutory objectives. While the proposed COCON amendments primarily relate to misconduct towards others within the workforce, the proposed amendments to FIT also relate to conduct which may take place outside the workplace. For example, the FCA proposes adding “Misconduct in a person’s private or personal life or in their working life outside the regulatory system may be relevant to their fitness and propriety even though there is little or no risk of it being repeated in their work for their firm.This will be the case if it is disgraceful or morally reprehensible or otherwise sufficiently serious. This is because their working in the role for which they are being assessed may damage public confidence in the financial system and financial services industry in the United Kingdom and consequently be inconsistent with the FCA’s statutory objectives” (emphasis added). When assessing “Honesty, integrity and reputation” (FIT 2.1), the proposed amendments require consideration of “violence, sexual offences and offences related to a person’s or a group’s demographic characteristics such as racially motivated or aggravated offences” in addition to criminal convictions. Many of the proposed amendments to FIT appear to be aimed directly at addressing criticisms of the FCA’s approach in cases such as Frensham v FCA, where the FCA was reproached for failing to “forge the necessary link” between the applicant’s criminal conviction and his professional role under the current rules. Reporting Diversity characteristicsThe consultation paper proposes annual mandatory reporting and public disclosure about the age, sex or gender, disability, ethnicity, religion and sexual orientation of your workforce separated into Board, Senior Leadership and all staff collectively for large firms. “Senior Leadership” is defined widely to include 3 potential layers of management. The reporting of certain additional characteristics have been identified as voluntary, although the regulators may move to mandatory reporting later. These are: socio-economic background, gender identity, parental responsibilities and carer responsibilities. Smaller firms are also encouraged to undertake voluntary reporting across all characteristics where they can. Mandatory information will be reported annually to the FCA and PRA via a single regulatory return form to ensure consistency across firms, and also publicly (in electronic format and accessible from a single point on the firm’s website, according to the PRA). To address any concerns about data reporting breaching confidentiality, the regulators have given options to combine data sets and they also suggest using percentages rather than employee numbers. Culture and Inclusion ReportingThe consultation paper also proposes that large firms provide annual mandatory reporting and public disclosure on culture and inclusion feedback from staff at all levels separated into Board, Senior Leadership and all staff collectively. The consultation paper is prescriptive about the questions that have to be asked in the culture and inclusion survey, including how employees feel about speaking up about inappropriate behaviour/misconduct; expressing disagreement/challenging dominant opinions or decisions without fear of negative consequences; the value of their contributions; actions that made them feel insulted or badly treated because of personal characteristics; being able to make an honest mistake; and their manager’s cultivation of an inclusive environment. Answers to these questions should be reported on a 5 point scale of strongly agree to strongly disagree. These mandatory questions will require careful handling. Asking these questions without reviewing your current speak up and inclusion culture and laying the ground work to encourage positive responses will likely lead to a negative outcome. You will also want to engage with your workforce and build trust in why the questions are being asked and what the results will be used for before you roll out the first formal survey. For example, the responses you receive should be anonymous, voluntary and also include a “prefer not to say” option and this should be made clear to your staff. D&I strategiesIt is proposed that large firms and all CRR and Solvency II firms, of whatever size, will be required to establish, implement, maintain and publish a D&I strategy. The consultation papers contain detailed proposals for what should be included in D&I strategies. As a minimum your D&I strategy must contain:
In its multi-firm review the FCA was critical of shortcomings in many existing D&I strategies, so careful review of your current strategies based on clear data, or drafting a new one, will be vital. Boards will be responsible for maintenance and oversight of D&I strategy. The PRA’s gloss on this minimum list is to add the firm’s core values, the culture it is trying to create, its commitment to D&I, and the role of the firm and staff in fostering an open and inclusive environment, empowering colleagues to speak up and express their views. Because CRR and Solvency II firms of all sizes are included, the measures for those firms may be proportionate. D&I targetsLarge firms will also be required to submit annual mandatory reporting and make public disclosure of D&I targets to address underrepresentation under the proposals. Targets should be set by firms themselves – looking at under-representation, especially below senior levels, where the FCA found the biggest drop-off in diversity. The consultation papers make clear that firms are required to consider the context in which they operate by having regard to available data on the diversity profiles of the UK population and the geographical area in which they carry out regulated activities. However they do not propose to mandate the demographics the targets should cover (aside from requiring at least one target for each of the Board, its Senior Leadership and the employee population as a whole), nor what the targets should be, nor how regularly they should be updated. By contrast the PRA consultation says it expects targets for women and ethnicity to be set as a minimum, if underrepresentation is identified in these areas. Both the PRA and FCA make clear, however, that firms must review them regularly for progress and continued suitability. Reporting on targets will include:
Target-setting should be considered carefully to avoid any kind of positive discrimination. Senior Managers, Board and succession planning for CRR and Solvency II firmsCRR and Solvency II firms should note the different approach the PRA has taken in relation to Board D&I strategy, succession planning, Senior Manager accountability and linking remuneration to D&I metrics. Affected firms will need to develop and publish on their website a Board D&I strategy in addition to the one for all staff. The PRA will also clarify that for succession planning, upcoming appointments should be considered in the light of D&I. In addition, those SMFs who have Prescribed Responsibilities relating to culture (PRI and PRH) would be expected to have responsibility for D&I in their Statements of Responsibilities. They would have slightly different responsibilities from each other, although the entire Board would also have input. PRH would have performance objectives and remuneration metrics linked to these responsibilities. If there is no Prescribed Responsibility for Culture, at least one SMF would have responsibility for D&I, again reflected in performance objectives and variable pay. What else do I need to know about the D&I consultation proposals?Mandatory information will be reported annually to the FCA and PRA via a single regulatory return form to ensure consistency across firms. If you are unable to provide a complete report in the first reporting period, you will need to explain why and what steps you are taking to change that (similar to the comply or explain regime under the UK Corporate Governance Code). However, the regulators would expect a complete report from the second reporting period. Publication of all this information to the regulators and on websites will show annual progress. As with other FCA reporting requirements, reporting would be subject to a £250 administrative fee if returns are not completed on time. However, a more serious consequence could come in the form of adverse publicity and/or use of supervisory and enforcement powers in the event of continued non-compliance. Ultimately, a persistent failure to submit regulatory returns may be seen by the regulators as grounds to cancel a firm’s Part 4A permission. CommentMany firms already collect diversity information on sex or gender, ethnicity and possibly sexual orientation. Large firms will need to carefully plan their expanded diversity data collection exercises to get the best engagement from staff and then ensure they analyse the data with a view to introducing meaningful change. The regulators’ choice of what categories of diversity data should be included in mandatory reporting is intriguing. It does not cover all the protected characteristics under the Equality Act 2010 nor socio-economic background – an area particularly highlighted for its inequality in the industry both in progression and pay. The FCA’s consultation paper does not contain any rationale for socio-economic background being voluntary, except perhaps to allow firms time to start work in this area. Only cursory mentions are made of the importance of intersectionality (more prominently in the PRA Consultation Paper), that is, where an individual might face greater barriers if they are part of more than one diversity demographic. This may follow in guidance but we would have expected more emphasis to be placed on this. The regulators are keen to stress how the proposals are designed to improve firms’ culture and align with their statutory objectives by:
Firms should also note that the Suitability considerations of the Threshold Conditions are proposed to include where a firm or person has been involved in “Discriminatory Practices”, or has been convicted of violence, sexual offences, or offences relating to demographic characteristics (e.g. racially motivated or aggravated offences). Failure to grasp and appropriately handle such issues could therefore affect a firm’s regulatory future. Further reading on Diversity and Inclusion in Financial ServicesDirection of Travel: Diversity & Inclusion in Financial Services (eversheds-sutherland.com) CP18/23 – Diversity and inclusion in PRA-regulated firms | Bank of England Latest Insights
Latest News
Latest Events
legal updates November 13, 2026 COP31: Leaders’ Summit | Resilient Cities and Built Environment  legal updates November 12, 2026 COP31: Leaders’ Summit | Zero Waste - The business case for zero waste legal updates November 11, 2026 COP31: Energy and Transport – Electrification takes center stage in Antalya legal updates November 11, 2026 Algorithmic Management of Workforces: Is your business a “platform” without... deal alerts November 06, 2026 Eversheds Sutherland advises Mercedes-Benz on European fast-charging partne... firm news November 05, 2026 Eversheds Sutherland hires partner Peter Cheng to lead Hong Kong ECM practi... firm news October 27, 2026 Eversheds Sutherland (International) announces senior leadership appointmen... firm news October 26, 2026 Eversheds Sutherland deepens fintech and regulatory bench with double partn... hybrid Europe Action Week 2026 Europe Action Week returns this November with a dynamic mix of events designed to help you navigate what’s next. virtual Belgian employment law training November 17, 2026 2.00pm - 5.00pm (GMT) Virtual in-person Industrial relations masterclass November 18, 2026 9.30am - 4.30pm (GMT) London, United Kingdom virtual Immigration UK Business – sponsor licencing course November 24, 2026 9.30am - 11.30am (GMT) Virtual |