The active voting rights of managers in several companies with an internal matrix structure
January 21, 2026
The active voting rights of managers in several companies with an internal matrix structureJanuary 21, 2026 We already reported on the Federal Labour Court (BAG) ruling on this issue in June 2025 (BAG ruling of 22 May 2025, ref. 7 ABR 28/24). As the detailed reasons for the ruling are now available, we like to take the chance to analyse the decision in greater detail. The initial situationThe employer provides IT services and sells IT products at various locations. Due to a general works agreement, five organisational units have been formed, deviating from the works structures of the Works Constitution Act (BetrVG). A separate works council is elected in each of this organisational units. The company’s internal matrix structure is organised as follows: The work tasks are carried out in various areas in which employees from different organisational units work together in teams. These teams are led by so-called matrix managers, who are no senior executives within the meaning of the BetrVG. In the 2022 works council election in the "Southern Region" organisational unit , the election committee considered those matrix managers who lead the employees of the Southern Region to be eligible to vote and included them in the list of voters. Even though these matrix managers were otherwise employed by another (core) business of the employer and their regular place of work was located outside the Southern Region. The list of voters thus included the employees of the Southern Region business and their matrix line managers. The employer took the view that the managers were not eligible to vote because they did not belong to the Southern Region company and therefore contested the works council election. The employer's main argument was that multiple voting rights within the established matrix structure would result in a legally unsecure and unmanageable practice. This would furhter reduce the voting weight of the "real" employees belonging to the company and resulting in a overrepresentation of the matrix managers in the general works council, which would violate the principle of democracy. The Stuttgart Labour Court and the Baden-Württemberg Regional Labour Court (LAG) both declared the election invalid. The Baden-Württemberg LAG assumed that the matrix managers were already assigned to one of the four other companies determined based on the general works agreement and were therefore only eligible to vote there. Multiple voting rights were ruled out. The decision of the Federal Labour CourtThe works council successfully appealed against this decision before the Federal Labour Court (BAG). According to Section 7 (1) of the Works Constitution Act (BetrVG), all employees of the company who have reached the age of 16 are eligible to vote. The BAG emphasises that the law thus links voting rights to the functional affiliation of the individual employee to the company. This affiliation is based on integration into the company organisation on the day of the election. The actual circumstances are decisive in this regard, i.e. whether the company pursues the operational purpose of the business with the help of the employee. This requires an overall assessment of all the circumstances of the individual case. In this context, the technical authority of a matrix manager may be considered if this authority results in involvement in the performance of the operational tasks to be carried out in the company by the employees working there or in the work processes there. According to the Federal Labour Court, a matrix manager is typically considered to be integrated if they must work regularly with the employees working in the company in order to carry out their duties and actually exercises their technical authority. Multiple voting rightsIn the opinion of the BAG, the fact that an employee is already integrated into a company and is eligible to vote there does not preclude them from being eligible to vote in another company. The BAG states that membership of a company is not determined by the negative condition that the employee does not belong to another company. In the opinion of the BAG, it is possible for employees to be eligible to vote in several companies; this is not excluded by the principles of the works constitution. Rather, the works council is legitimised by the democratic election-based representation of the workforce. The purpose of Section 7 of the Works Constitution Act (BetrVG) is to establish the right to vote for those persons for whom the material participation rights of the works council are designed. In the opinion of the BAG, all employees have a need for representation and legitimacy, which is covered by the works council's operational legislation linked to their integration into the company. The fact that matters subject to co-determination also or even exclusively arise in another company to which the manager belongs does not preclude multiple voting rights. Matrix managers are also not overrepresented because of multiple voting rights, as the Works Constitution Act does not inherently provide for employee group-specific representation. This also applies to the secondment of works council members to the general works council to be established. The BAG was unable to conclusively assess whether the matrix managers in this case were integrated into the operational organisation of the Southern Region and was therefore unable to reach a final decision on the matter. Further clarification of the facts by the Regional Labour Court (LAG) is required regarding the effectiveness and requirements of the works council structure established by the GBV, as well as the integration of matrix managers into the Southern Region operation. Explosive issue for corporations/companies with matrix structures: more election challenges?As we have already observed in our own daily consulting work, the BAG's decision is causing considerable controversy in the preparation of works council elections in corporations and companies with matrix structures. According to the present decision, employees who, like matrix managers, belong to several establishments of a company, may also vote in the works council election in several establishments of the company. The multiplication of active voting rights affects the size of the works council, the number of employees released from work and the number of votes cast by the members of the general and group works councils. Incorrect allocation of employees in matrix organisations could lead to an increase in works council election challenges. We have already pointed out that companies should bear this in mind when fulfilling their obligation to provide information to the election committee for the preparation of the voter lists. However, the Federal Labour Court has stated in its ruling that the inclusion of employees who are not eligible to vote in a voter list does justify contesting the works council election, but is not generally sufficient to justify declaring the works council election null and void . This distinction is of practical importance, because, in the event of a challenge, at least the resolutions of the elected works council remain effective until a final decision has been made on the challenge to the election. Against this background, it is generally not possible to obtain a preliminary injunction to halt or temporarily suspend the works council election in the event of incorrect voter lists. It should be noted that in the case before the Federal Labour Court, the matrix managers were in an employment relationship with the employer, who also was the owner of the business. It was not a business "external" to the contractual employer. Overzealous election committees should therefore be reminded that the BAG has still not decided on the question of the active voting rights of matrix managers in a company that is not the contractual employer. The case did not deal with group-wide matrix structures and cross-company technical authority. Options and practical tipsIt remains to be considered whether matrix organisations can still introduce arbitrary employee representation structures within the meaning of Section 3 of the Works Constitution Act (BetrVG) at short notice. One option would be to form a works council for the entire company or to bundle companies together. The multiple voting rights emphasised by the Federal Labour Court may also mean that different co-determination rules (e.g. on the location of working hours) will apply to employees working together in a team. But these coordination requirements do not only apply to matrix managers. The friction in co-determination resulting from the matrix structure in individual cases must be resolved urgently after the works council election by precisely defining the scope of the works agreements. Key contacts
Latest Events |